News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by jstanley on Thursday August 24, 2017 @04:23AM (#15088458)
You don't get to decide how much "societal value" a job adds. Society decides, by paying for it.

It's likely that the investment banking industry adds a lot more value than you think it does, else where does the money come from?

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by moxious on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:17AM (#15089804)
> Society decides, by paying for it.

This works nicely, in theory, in the absence of market distortions and coercive forces. In practice, both of those things do exist, and so markets don't work entirely like theory predicts. Classical economics doesn't adjust itself for things like regulatory capture, corruption, bundling of services, and a host of other factors that are likely at play in investment banking.

It shows far too much faith in the workings of the system to claim that society is deeming investment banking of high social value because it pays a lot.

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by JSONwebtoken on Thursday August 24, 2017 @04:54AM (#15088573)
Society also pays the Realtor 6% and the sports betting website 10%. Just because a transaction has historically occurred at a given price doesn't mean it should continue to be worth that much in the modern services market.

Accounting and law firms shouldn't be worried about automation just yet when frat stars are still being paid $140k/yr out of college to make powerpoint presentations.

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by gaius on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:15AM (#15089787)
You're right - they should be working on new ways to show ads and steal personal data - that's REAL value for society!

Glass houses, stones and all that...

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by CPLX on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:23AM (#15089843)
> It's likely that the investment banking industry adds a lot more value than you think it does, else where does the money come from?

The same place Mobutu and Ferdinand Marcos's billions come from. The logical leap you're attempting here is profoundly unsound.

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by bbctol on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:33AM (#15090396)
On the docks in 1776: You don't get to decide how much "societal value" King George adds. Society decides, by paying for it. If he wasn't adding so much value, why would we be sending him so much money?

I swear, I didn't consider myself that far left, but it's unreal how religious the concept of the market has become.

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by Nursie on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:42AM (#15088757)
Of course you do - you can recognise that (for instance) carers add a lot of value to society, making little money while each making a huge impact on a small number of people.

And you can recognise that a lot of people make a lot of money from doing things so abstracted from every day life, nobody would be the wiser if they just popped out of existence one day.

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by DanBC on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:27AM (#15089180)
An off topic nitpick: In the UK strictly speaking carers by definition are not paid. People often say "carer" when they mean "care worker". This is important because care workers have legal rights which are often ignored, and because carers are often not identified (and thus don't receive the statutory help they're entitled to) because people think "carer" means "paid employee".
Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by Nursie on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:47PM (#15091706)
Oh fair enough, I shall try to keep that in mind. I do use the terms interchangeably and that's probably not helpful.
Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by jstanley on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:16AM (#15089139)
Carers add a lot of value as a group, and are compensated heavily as a group, but any individual carer does not add very much value because they can only care for so many people.
Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by Nursie on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:49PM (#15091722)
Sure, I agree. However the people who make a ton of money juggling arcane financial instruments... societal value and financial recompense are somewhat removed from each other is all I'm saying.

An imperfect fit.

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by kazagistar on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:32AM (#15090388)
If we all had the same purchazing power, then you would be right. But how much you get paid is not determined by how much societal value you add, but how much value you add to existing pools of capital. The money is in making the rich get richer.
Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by stale2002 on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:00PM (#15091200)
And if those people get replaced, then something else is providing that value for cheaper.

We are arguing that these people can, and should be replaced with something much cheaper and better.

Re:Is Social Capital trying to end run banks by creating IPO... by paulgb on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:35AM (#15089953)
Economic rent