News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by rbanffy on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:21AM (#1508141)
It's a competitor even if it addresses a subset of the iPad functionality. This one has e-book reading, something many people buy the iPad for. Different people weight different features differently (sory - had to do it) and this thingie may end up with a better value than an iPad for a lot of people.

Me included, BTW. I could buy one of these and a Nook for less than what an iPad costs. For me, it's a winner.

It's a competitor, even if you prefer the iPad.

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by slantyyz on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:38AM (#1508219)
Yes, it is a competitor, but is it a "real competitor"? Real is the operative word. When you suggest that this product is a "real competitor", I expect it to have real potential to sell more than a million devices.

The reason why I am dismissive of this device is that the headline of the OTA is a little bit linkbaitish considering that the device is made by a little known Asian manufacturer who is going to spend next to nothing on marketing and has a questionable pedigree when it comes to product quality.

There will be real competitors from Android and WebOS, once the big players enter the market. But this thing? No way. I would say that none of the big players with plans for an Android slate would even consider this thing competition.

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by rbanffy on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:30PM (#1508432)
> I expect it to have real potential to sell more than a million devices

Is the iPad a real competitor to netbooks? This specific product is not a huge risk for Apple - it's easily clonable by other manufacturers and, by itself, it will never have a huge market share. The combined power of just about every Chinese manufacturer is a very real threat to Apple.

Steve must remember the Apple II.

Hardware makers for this class of devices will not - and need not to - spend a ton of money on marketing. They will have this thingie sitting on aisles of major supermarkets.

And that's a killer move in the lower-end. Nobody will remember their brand next week. But, in the meantime, they will sell lots of units.

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by slantyyz on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:44PM (#1508706)
By virtue of the iPad's capabilities, you could also argue that it's a competitor to PCs and laptops. I would argue that most of the people who are currently claiming that the iPad is a threat to computers and laptops are simply trying to draw eyeballs to their blogs with sensationalistic headlines.

I see a lot of cheap keychain digital cameras being sold at supermarkets, but I highly doubt that anyone would seriously consider them to be competition for even a $100 digital camera from any major camera manufacturer.

Competition isn't just about features or market share in the overall segment. Apple has a very specific set of customer personas it sells to, and it does well selling to them. That people outside of their defined persons buys their devices is -gravy-. I highly doubt any of their target customers are even interested in this Pandigital device, which makes it a device that is not real competition for the iPad.

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by rbanffy on Monday July 12, 2010 @05:11PM (#1509446)
> it's a competitor to PCs and laptops.

iPad sales will eat into sales of both desktop computers and laptops. Not all people need a desktop computer to check e-mail and browse the web. An iPad is cheaper than many desktops and very mobile, which may be a bonus. A lot of people also demand similarly simple uses with mobility. If all you'll do is to check your e-mail and browse the web, the iPad may be the notebook for you.

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by dkarl on Monday July 12, 2010 @03:03PM (#1509008)
I think he meant it's a real competitor for developers and geeks who are looking to buy a tablet. Mainstream buyers aren't going to respond to a sales pitch of "no rooting is necessary! All that’s involved is installing a different device driver and then a new Home launcher!"
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by mattmaroon on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:32AM (#1508187)
Do you really think people buy the iPad for reading ebooks? I find it to be not significantly better than reading on a monitor. The iPad is great for some things for sure (Plants vs Zombies being first and foremost in my experience) but I think if I wanted to read books I'd get a Kindle or some eink device.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by DrJokepu on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:18PM (#1508596)
Yes, I've bought an iPad for reading books. And I'm using it all the time as an e-book reader.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by jsz0 on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:52PM (#1510204)
I'm more of an audiobook person myself but I have read 2 books on the iPad with good results. The only drawback is the temptation to hit the home button and do something else which isn't a real problem on current e-ink devices since they don't really do anything else. Which is also the same reason I wouldn't buy one. I don't read enough text to justify a standalone device.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by chris11 on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @03:27AM (#1510651)
That is one of the reasons I like my Sony Touch ebook reader. It basically is only good for reading, so I don't end up interrupting my reading to do something else on it.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by stcredzero on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:01PM (#1508324)
I read books on my iPad all the time.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by kristiandupont on Monday July 12, 2010 @04:36PM (#1509334)
I switched from the Sony eReader to iPad for reading books. And while I prefer looking at eink, I am much happier with the overall iPad experience.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by rbanffy on Monday July 12, 2010 @05:08PM (#1509436)
That's what I was trying to say. Maybe, for you, the iPad is a better value than a Sony eReader. A lot of people will agree with you and a lot of people will disagree.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by pavel_lishin on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:05PM (#1510230)
Bring a monitor to bed with you, or on a bus, or on a plane, and then we'll talk.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by masklinn on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:08PM (#1508567)
> I find it to be not significantly better than reading on a monitor.

Nielsen's tests very emphatically disagree

http://www.useit.com/alertbox/ipad-kindle-reading.html

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by mattmaroon on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:13PM (#1508578)
Neilsen tested only speed. It's eyestrain that bothers me and is why ebook readers typically use e-ink.
Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by masklinn on Monday July 12, 2010 @02:59PM (#1508995)
> Neilsen tested only speed.

Neilsen tested only speed if you read only the first half of the results. You might want to read the next one as well. It's called "User Satisfaction".

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by mattmaroon on Monday July 12, 2010 @04:20PM (#1509272)
He doesn't say how long he asked people to read for. My suspicion is that the longer the timeframe, the more results between print and monitor (and Kindle and iPad) will diverge. You don't get eyestrain from even light reading on a monitor.

Also, satisfaction can mean a number of things, and he didn't define it, as evidenced by comments about weight. A lot of people could have had higher reading satisfaction on an iPad because it's an iPad.

Neilsen's results have no bearing one way or the other on my original statement, which is that people don't buy iPads to read books.

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by NyxWulf on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @09:59AM (#1514555)
User satisfaction includes all of the relevant issues for a person, and in this test they were testing reading, so eye strain would matter to people.

People absolutely buy the iPad to read books. It may not be the only thing they do with it-since it is a multi function device. However reading books is a very large component of the purchase for everyone that I know that has bought one.

My graduate program just bought 65 iPads for the incoming class to read their books and PDFs. They bought those based on user feedback that people hate reading on the tablet and don't like hauling around forty seven pounds of dead trees. The majority user request was to load the reading on an iPad.

Re:Out Of Nowhere, The iPad Has A Real Competitor by rbreve on Monday July 12, 2010 @04:30PM (#1509309)
I also have an iPad and read books on it