Re:Sun Flyer, an Electric Trainer Aircraft
by sokoloff on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @12:14PM
(#15082723)
Shock cooling as a concern for cylinder cracking is a fairly well debunked myth at this point, IMO, short of crashing your airplane into a cold lake.
Agreed the tech is old, but the uncommanded in-flight shutdown rate for pistons is also very low. Part of that is driven by high maintenance demands (some of which introduces failures themself), but a lot is due to the simplicity and redundancy.
Would I like variable spark timing (beyond impulse couplers for starting)? Would I like more automated starting, especially for hot starts? Would I like thermostatic cooling of cylinders? Yes, but not if they came with any substantial increase in failure modes. When I'm taking the family 700 miles at night in a single-engine airplane to grandma's for christmas, I'll suffer with arcane checklists and having to manually manage the engine if it reduces the chance of an uncommanded shutdown by even 5%.
Re:Sun Flyer, an Electric Trainer Aircraft
by mnw21cam on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @04:52AM
(#15079725)
A lot of that "mess" is due to a couple of critical requirements. Namely, low engine weight and reliability.
Re:Sun Flyer, an Electric Trainer Aircraft
by pdelbarba on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @11:24AM
(#15082209)
At this point it's mostly certification cost and liability insurance cost that's keeping the tech back. You can easily modify modern aircraft engines to be more reliable and efficient (PMAGs) but you need an STC (certification procedure) to make the switch so the experimental home builders are the only ones who actually benefit.
Airplane gasoline engines are a mess, the technology is ~1950s at best and just hasn't advanced at all, with a few exceptions that, pardon the pun, never really took off.