News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by dvdhnt on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @10:45AM (#15072875)
Personally, I think it is blatantly unfair. It's like if we had a big bad of skittles and every time I took 1 skittle, you took 10 skittles.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by dsacco on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:14AM (#15073180)
But the economy is not zero sum, like that bag. If I have a process that increases the total number of skittles in the bag, is it still unfair for me to take more skittles from it?
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by mattmanser on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:38AM (#15073448)
Depends on your view point.

You could argue that the process was never really "yours" in the first place.

Society, our laws, our armies and natural resources, our roads, bridges, power lines, telecoms structure, are 99% of that process and you added 1%.

You simply took advantage of a lot of luck, a little bit of hard work and probably a bunch of your parents' money to end up owning it.

Maybe you should get a chunk of the rewards, but all of it?

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by dsacco on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:59AM (#15073667)
How would you propose we make a more meritocratic system that doesn't allow for as much luck-based success?
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by TheAdamAndChe on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @12:02AM (#15078443)
Tax the wealthy and use that money to invest in infrastructure, education, and economic growth across the entire country, not just the big cities. Combine that with limiting trade with countries that have abysmal minimum wages and standard of living, and you'd have a fantastic recipe for economic growth for the lower and middle classes.

Luck is always involved, but by increasing opportunities while giving workers more leverage, it is definitely doable.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by AstralStorm on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @01:13PM (#15074414)
I suppose you want some incorruptible and relatively unbiased jury to manage it as well?
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by mcguire on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:53AM (#15073597)
If you end up with a mountain of skittles that you can use to crush anyone who irritates you while everyone else is eating all the skittles they get in order to survive, then yes, that might be a problem.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by dsacco on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:58AM (#15073659)
But does this actually describe the current state of affairs? If not, how would we get there? That seems like a cognitive jump from people taking unequal amounts of skittles.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by mcguire on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @02:53PM (#15075347)
I dunno. How do you feel about the political power wielded by the wealthy? Too much? Not enough? What would it take to be too much?
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by dvdhnt on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:30AM (#15073365)
So, you're right - the economy is not zero sum, but the resources are. The economy is about moving them here or there.

It depends on where you got those skittles? If you are increasing the skittle count by just taking from other peoples' bags of skittles then you're literally the mortgage/banking industry and there are probably lots of empty skittle bags out there propping up our never-ending-skittle-bag.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by dsacco on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:01PM (#15073688)
Is it a problem for me to do what you say if the skittles themselves become effectively cheaper for everyone else to enjoy? What if systemic issues only happen every 10 years? Or 5 years?
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by spo81rty on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:11AM (#15073150)
Except when it comes to wealth there is no limit. Ones success does not mean another's demise. If I mine for Bitcoin and make millions, who did I steal wealth from to get mine?

Your Skittles analogy does not work.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by bendmorris on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:46AM (#15073520)
It's not so simple. Wealth can be used to gain access to limited resources such as land. Greater wealth inequality means a small segment of the population can afford to buy up all of the housing, driving up prices and blocking others (who may not otherwise be any worse off than they ever were) from owning land. They can then perpetually rent out this land, creating an effortless income for themselves and siphoning value from everyone else.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by mcguire on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:57AM (#15073638)
You are not thinking big enough. Wealth is about power. Siphoning value is a distant second order to commanding the peons to trim your lawn with nail scissors.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by AstralStorm on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @01:16PM (#15074443)
Both feed back into one another if used well. Rich can buy power to stay rich and keep their progeny rich until some major levelling drift catches them. (Say a catastrophe of dumb successor or major misfortune.)
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by elsewhen on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:19AM (#15073235)
To be pedantic, is not the "skittles" part that is the problem but ratherthe "bag" part of the analogy, since it implies a fixed amount. If the OP somehow weaved a skittles factory into the analogy, the analogy could be spared.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by AstralStorm on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @01:18PM (#15074467)
There are no truly open systems in the whole universe if physicists are correct. Much less on Earth alone. Entropy is a thing.

About three only abundant energy resource we have is the Sun and it is quite hard to extract it's output.

Then there are certain biological restrictions like having to eat - a chemical input. Arable land is worth quite a lot, fertile much more still. It is not evenly distributed over Earth. (Similar with fertile paths of the oceans and seas.)

Dense energy sources are yet more scarce.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by dvdhnt on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:24AM (#15073292)
That's not true at all.

For one, you're talking about a digit currency derived from a (currently) finite resource: electricity. While you suck up electricity mining BTC, you add to the demand for said electricity. Higher demand means higher prices, meaning those with money can afford more electricity and mine more BTC, while those who can't afford more electricity to mine cannot. Additionally, those who could afford just enough power for non-BTC mining now struggle to afford power at all; and even if they do, they now must save less, growing the gap.

I didn't say the word "steal"; that's something you derived from my analogy because my analogy is obvious. Resources, and wealth, are all finite; so more for one literally means less or none for another if that one takes as much as they please. Otherwise, I could walk into any bank in the world and just take out as much money as I wanted to.

I was once told that if I were in the middle of a discussion with my wife and she completely refocused the discussion onto something else, I should be happy internally that I was right, but externally I should take the loss.

You're talking about BTC now, so I guess I'll take that L.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by danharaj on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @10:54AM (#15072979)
It's worse then that. It's as if every day you got to take 1 skittle, but the rich take 2^n skittles on the nth day. That is, until the skittle system breaks down.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by logicchains on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @10:54AM (#15072978)
More like, if we had a big patch of strawberries and every day I picked 100 and you picked 1000, why should I get to take yours?
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by js8 on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:02AM (#15073077)
Because you're cheating - I saw some Mexicans picking them for you.
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by logicchains on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:17AM (#15073217)
Why are the Mexicans picking them for me, not for you or for themselves? Assuming I didn't enslave them, I must be offering them something that makes it worth their while. Maybe I spent some time building better tools for berry picking, so using those tools they can take home more berries overall than they could without my help even if they're giving some to me. Maybe I saved some berries, traded them for supplies with someone else, and built some kind of shelter over the berry bush. Maybe I've got a spear to scare off the men who threaten them when they try to pick berries in Mexico.

I think this is particularly relevant to software developers. It's often fairly easy for us to go into contracting, or start our own business, but many developers with those opportunities (myself included) still choose to work for others. Perhaps we prefer the stability of not having to manage our own business, perhaps we like the projects a particular company is working on and lack the resources to attempt them ourselves, perhaps we want to acquire more savings before starting out on our own, perhaps we want to learn from a particular company. And even when we do start our own businesses, for some reason we still tend to prefer traditional structures over more equal structures like cooperatives, prefer structures in which people work for others.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by js8 on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:38AM (#15073446)
Maybe.. I can completely change a reasonable answer to any moral problem just by adding another maybe.

But it doesn't really matter. The analogy is flawed, that's the point, because it's not how it works in the real world. In the real world, people are not getting 1000000x higher income just because they do 1000000x more of the same work.

The main problem is in how we value things that are collectively produced (via cooperation of different people, especially in different points in time). There are basically two main solutions to the problem, both of them wrong. One is the neoclassical solution, which is to deny that we cooperate. Then there is Marx's solution, which is labor theory of value.

I don't believe it has a good solution.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by logicchains on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:00PM (#15073680)
>In the real world, people are not getting 1000000x higher income just because they do 1000000x more of the same work.

You could argue that they get 1000x (1000000x is disingenuous; 1000000x the minimum wage is around $15,000,000,000 per year, practically nobody makes that) higher income because they do something that people value 1000x more. If we assume people pay others for doing this they value, if a developer can't find somebody who values what they provide enough to pay them more than $80,000, while a fund manager can find someone to pay them $80,000,000, some people must value what the fund manager is doing a lot more or else they wouldn't pay him/her.

>One is the neoclassical solution, which is to deny that we cooperate.

How does it deny we cooperate? I have an apple and I want an orange, you have an orange and you want an apple, we exchange those things, how is that not cooperation?

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by js8 on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:27PM (#15073968)
> If we assume people pay others for doing this they value

That's a strong assumption and as a matter of fact, they don't. For example, when I go to cinema, I pay to the ticket seller. I don't pay to the people who actually produced the movie. I rely on some (unknown to me) mechanism according to which those people get paid, but I don't pay them.

> How does it deny we cooperate?

So you can see that in the above example. I don't pay individuals for doing things for me that I value. Instead, I pay to some organization which then redistributes the money. Neoclassical solution denies an existence of such organization. (Which is not quite wrong - I have no idea how to define this organization correctly for all edge cases - as I already mentioned, I don't see a solution. But it is also not correct.)

And it gets even worse! Some people cannot be paid for what valuable they are doing for me, because they are already dead. For example, I am not paying to Beethoven. There are even things that produce things of value without any human intervention; who do I pay then?

So yeah, maybe it kinda works for apples and oranges, and picking strawberries, but not in general.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by logicchains on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @08:00AM (#15080708)
>For example, when I go to cinema, I pay to the ticket seller. I don't pay to the people who actually produced the movie. I rely on some (unknown to me) mechanism according to which those people get paid, but I don't pay them.

The mechanism is the same; it's transitive. You pay the ticket seller, the ticket seller pays the distribution company, the distribution company pays the production company, something along those lines. If we assume nobody's going around stealing or printing money, then that's the only way the people producing the move could be getting money.

If you don't like all those middle-men, that's why things like Kickstarter are appealing to many people. I wanted the people who made Planescape Torment, one of my favourite games, to make a sequel. I paid them in advance directly, via Kickstarter, as did many others. They made an excellent (at least in my view) game.

>And it gets even worse! Some people cannot be paid for what valuable they are doing for me, because they are already dead. For example, I am not paying to Beethoven. There are even things that produce things of value without any human intervention; who do I pay then?

Payment motivates somebody to give up something and give it to you. If something can be taken without depriving anybody of it, why is payment needed? Some people oppose intellectual property laws for this reason, because unlike physical property, using intellectual property doesn't deprive the creator of it due to text being practically free to reproduce.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by js8 on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @08:59AM (#15081130)
I didn't say I didn't like the middle-men; they are useful. What I object to is trying to model this as if there is no structure of middle-men, when it is actually there.

The problem is, how you ensure all these people get paid? Contracts, law, government.. it gets very complicated very quickly. It's not just a series of independent transactions between two parties, as the neoclassicals like to portray it. It's also the whole social system, which ensures, as you say, nobody is going around stealing and printing money.

You cannot just ignore this structure because it is this structure which determines, if say a film director gets paid say 2x than film cutter. It's not you as a viewer who determines this. That's the main contradiction - this cannot be objectively determined (if we want fairness by any reasonable definition), yet it somehow must be determined for those people to be paid.

> If something can be taken without depriving anybody of it, why is payment needed?

That's a good question. Unfortunately, if you answer it positively, then you are effectively against all property rights, not just intellectual property. For example, let's say I have two houses but I need only one. Why shouldn't you use my otherwise empty house for free, if you keep it in the same order?

Ultimately, again, you will get a contradiction within any sort of moral framework, some people who provide value will not get paid, some will get paid.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by dsacco on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:12AM (#15073159)
Why is that cheating?
Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by jly on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:35AM (#15073412)
You shouldn't, but this example is not the way the existing capitalist economies of the world work.

In your example, a shared resource has labor applied to meet a clear human need, and those that physically do more of it reap more rewards. In the real world, someone owns the field, does no work, pays individuals (potentially) far less than the value of their labor to do the picking, and reaps most of the rewards. Then that field gets passed down to their offspring who continue to gain the rewards without doing any work.

Why should they get to do that?

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by wonder_er on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @11:56AM (#15073623)
Buying land and establishing a farm is not "no work".

Passing physical goods to offspring goes in the same bucket as passing monetary units to offspring, goes in the same bucket as passing valuable ideas to offspring.

In other words, parents should be able to pass whatever they want to their offspring.

To inject the state in that process and break it... you're making (basically) a god of the state. It's all powerful, benevolent, and able to do anything in any capacity in any situation.

Re:US Income Inequality: All for the Top 1% by mcguire on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:00PM (#15073671)
Because you are surviving by eating your strawberries while I'm loading my excess into my catapult so that I can raid your house and take all of your coffee mugs.