I cannot claim that it is better than zsh in every aspect yet, but it is getting there.
However, my view is that we are generally chronological beings at heart, and knowing the year that something was posted (if it wasn't the current year) is a useful to aid in determining whether we may have seen it before or whether it may be particularly relevant to our interests.
It still catches me out with its sub shells too sometimes. ( () is equiv to $() in bash )
Also. No control+R
Otherwise I think it's a beautiful shell and I keep using it.
And the up arrow already does something similar to ctrl-R by default. No need to have a separate hotkey for that behavior.
What would control+R do for you that isn't just part of the fish autocompletion?
However, I particularly found it difficult to get working with nix, unfortunately.
I remember that I was interested in it for its multiline command formatting and history. Since then, though, I've learned that zsh also has support for multiline command history, and its vi keybindings support multiline editing for a single command. It's like every command line is a little multiline vi buffer. For this reason, I've chosen my prompt so that the command starts at the first column.
Who cares if it's old, if it's still relevant?
Is there something out there now that is better than zsh?