News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In what language do deaf people think? by sliverstorm on Sunday July 11, 2010 @02:19PM (#1505886)
I don't think in English as if I was having a conversation with myself. I think the best way to describe it is my brain precaches the words of objects or things or concepts I am thinking about.

If I look at the bolts sitting on my table, I don't literally think in my mind 'oh look those are bolts'. I recognize them for what they are, my brain does some processing, and at the same time as my mind is about to wander off thinking about the project I have them for, it loads the word 'bolts' into fast-access memory for immediate access.

That's why I get so hung up if I see or discuss something I can't remember the word for. I go into a waiting-for-IO state where I can't precache the right word :)

Re:In what language do deaf people think? by pbhjpbhj on Sunday July 11, 2010 @04:40PM (#1506078)
>That's why I get so hung up if I see or discuss something I can't remember the word for. I go into a waiting-for-IO state where I can't precache the right word :)

I've a terrible memory and it's been getting worse, sometimes I'll use a temporary variable until the relevant part of my brain has recalled the proper term - this can be for abstract concepts, names or other nouns. Kinda like when one uses the term "whatsit" or "thing-a-me-bob" in physical speech.

I find that words come to me sometimes days later, especially when it's a given name.

My grandfather had alzeimer's and mother is convinced she is going that way, I'm only in my 30s though - it is a bit worrying but also fascinating to consider the internal machinations.

Re:In what language do deaf people think? by JoeAltmaier on Sunday July 11, 2010 @11:21PM (#1506688)
Agreed, thinking isn't words. Thinking happens lightning-fast below words. We just routinely load it into and out of the "language buffer" because we are the communicating animal.

I often solve problems when thinking about something else - a song, a radio program. THen when I go back to the problem, the solution is clear. Where did that "Thinking" occur? Not in my language buffer, it was fully occupied. In fact in might have been getting the language buffer "out of the loop" that allowed the thinking to occur.

When debugging code, I absolutely DO NOT have an internal dialog going on. I'm paging through code, following definitions, looking at code blocks as a whole, putting the code into some mental space that is not words, then voila! the wrong piece shows up in my mind and I have it.

Language is over-rated.

Re:In what language do deaf people think? by scott_s on Monday July 12, 2010 @05:58AM (#1507358)
The debugging process you described has the same drawback as editing your own essay: you see what you think you wrote, not necessary what is there. That is, you know what a certain chunk of code is supposed to do, so you might glance over it and not actually read it again.

Experienced programmers know this, and constantly re-read their code to make sure it does what they think it does. But I just finished teaching programming to complete beginners, and this was a big hurdle. They would constantly say "My code's right, but the answer is wrong," not realizing the absurdity of the statement. It took a lot of time and patience to train them to always read the code they wrote.

Re:In what language do deaf people think? by JoeAltmaier on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:17AM (#1507672)
Agreed. I am "reading" my code, a page/method/block at a time, but not with an internal dialog. And I'm certainly not "arguing with myself" in words about what it does. So the thinking is occurring below/behind/between the words.
Re:In what language do deaf people think? by dan00 on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:25AM (#1508162)
"Agreed, thinking isn't words."

But what's the definition of thinking?

For me there are two ways of "thinking", the conscious one, in which I'm talking to myself and the unconscious, intuitive one, in which I don't talk to myself, but get some kind of "enlightenment", just see or understand something without a conscious thought.

The unconscious thinking works for me on all stuff I'm good at, stuff I learned und exercised a lot, so in a way the conscious thinking has been done before, created some kind of neural connection, and know this connection is activated without my assistance.

For me it's also the case that my logic sometimes works in a unconscious way, that I just get something, but it's the question how much this unconscious logic is assisted by former training.

A quite long time I only used the unconscious thinking. As long I advanced, there has been no need for an other way of thinking. But I got at a barrier, where my unconscious thinking couldn't go further.

I think, that If you're confronted with something completely new and very hard, then the unconscious thinking can go some way, but at some point it won't get further. You need then to change to the conscious thinking, create the necessary neural connections, and If that's done, then you're able to think again in an unconscious way.

I think, that you can limit yourself, if you're only used to one way of thinking

Often I'm debbuging in the same way as you. But sometimes it's very inefficient, when I'm stumble around without a direction.

Sometimes it's way more efficient to step back, get the bigger picture, ask yourself some questions, build assumptions and verify them.

Sometimes during the "conscious" debugging, when I'm talking to myself I'm getting an "enlightenment", and the bug is solved.

Re:In what language do deaf people think? by JoeAltmaier on Monday July 12, 2010 @04:40PM (#1509349)
I don't see thinking without words as "unconscious" at all. I'm aware I'm doing it; I keep the thoughts in the forefront of my brain and direct my investigation consciously. Its just not in words at all.

E.g. play a kids match game, where you turn up pairs of cards looking for a match. Two of spades, Three of hearts - no match. Turn them back over, try again.

But really, you aren't saying those things in your head - you might but you don't have to. You just look at the cards, and if they don't match you turn them back down. Try another pair - five of diamonds, two of spades - hey! that matches the 1st two of spades I saw!

The whole time you are consciously looking for a match, and unless you're explaining the game to somebody, your language processor can remain idle.

Re:In what language do deaf people think? by dan00 on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @03:32AM (#1510665)
"I don't see thinking without words as "unconscious" at all. I'm aware I'm doing it; I keep the thoughts in the forefront of my brain and direct my investigation consciously. Its just not in words at all."

That's right. My naming of the thinking "styles" has been suboptimal.

I think, that the kids game is just easy enough, that your brain can get the rules and playing it without contorted maneuvers.

This isn't unconscious, you're aware of everything, but in a way you just see it, without the need understanding. In a way you're brain understands for you, you don't see the needed steps to get to the understanding.

But when something is a lot harder, than your brain can't just understand all at once, then you need to do the steps for "yourself", by talking to you, by explaining it to you, or by reading an explanation, and this explanation is "written" in your brain, so that the next time the brain can do the steps for itself.

Re:In what language do deaf people think? by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @09:45AM (#1511301)
I couldn't disagree more. I think the mental conversation is just our idle language-processor following along as we think in other modes.

When learning from a textbook, there are those that need pictures to understand explanations. There are those that need the explanation, pictures are useless to them. I don't think they are necessarily thinking any differently, just entering the knowledge through different i/o ports.