I might not have worked on my passion in specific there, but I had a great time, learned a ton, and IMO set myself up for a great trajectory in my career.
Like most other large companies, YMMV depending on where you're at.
First, because I think you're factually mistaken - for a lot of people, a big name on your resume is a huge, positive flag.
Second, because there are other effects of working at a large company which you're not considering. Most importantly - they're large! That means you're going to interact with a huge amount of people. In 3 years at a BigCo, you'll likely have contacts not only in various departments, but probably in several other companies as well, both because of work with outside companies, and because of interacting with employees who left.
Not to mention, you can learn a lot about the industry that you might not necessarily be exposed to while at a small startup - via interactions with those outside companies (customers, partners, etc). You can also work on seriously big things, which you won't be working on at a startup, for example.
None of this is to say that working at a BigCo is the right move. I actually tend to think the opposite, depending on various factors. But it's definitely not an all-downsides proposition.
I respectfully disagree. Recruiters and hiring managers, and even individual interviewers take me far more seriously after having "Google" on my resume than they did before. It's not enough to land a good job automatically, but most interactions now at least start from the presumption that I'm competent, which makes a job search less frustrating.
I know some well-known niche companies with highly-coveted positions that appear to make new hires almost exclusively from AppAmaGooBookSoft alumni (last time I mentioned this, a user correctly guessed one of the companies I was referring to from just such a vague description).
The reality is that most people hate hiring and have no idea whatsoever how to do it well (in the sense of bringing on competent people, not from the HR perspective of minimizing legal liability). Big names, in either education or employment history, help a lot. It's probably easy to underestimate how much they help if you haven't gone without them.
I would also venture that ex-BigNameCo is a lot less of a big deal if you work somewhere that's a hotspot for that type of company (Silicon Valley, Seattle). There it may be seen more as a sign of rejection than success, like "Why don't you still work at Google if you were Google material?". But even still, most companies are going to be swayed significantly by a big name on the resume.
Do you have evidence on that? Virtually all data I've seen from salary sharing threads, and all compensation discussions I've had with startups suggests the contrary.
The point of a CV is to get you an interview. A person who graduated from an Ivy/Russell, did a year or two at Google and a similar spell at Goldman Sachs, will be able to get an interview anywhere, for the rest of their lives.
They probably won't get an easier ride in the interview, it may even be harder as the interviewer's egos insist that they best one of the "elite", but they will never need to worry about passing a screen.
Nowadays I am looking for a new permanent position (have been freelancing for a couple of years). My wife happens to be a headhunter and knows how most HR and internal recruitment teams think and work. She tells me with Amazon in my CV many more doors would open. I don't regret turning them down, I know for sure had I accepted to work with them I would have never met my wife, who brings me more joy than any job would ever do... But I can't help to wonder...
As for name recognition, it always helps. No employer is going to hire someone solely based on where they went to school or where they worked previously. However a well-known school or company can be the deciding factor between two candidates who are otherwise equal. My wife went to Purdue and did her pharmacy residency in Colorado. She later found out that she was competing with three other candidates for one position who were equally as good in the eyes of the residency program, and she won because she graduated from a well-known, top 10 pharmacy school.
Me: "Hey how come you guys don't use source control?"
Manager: "Are you being an asshole?"
Right, because BY FAR they are making the most progress, in the most promising technologies today, and they pay egregiously well.
- A big company on your resume has no outside value to your prospects.
Seriously. There's not "hey well he worked for amazon so we know he's good" free pass in the future for having Amazon on your resume.
There might be a "well, she wasted 3 years at amazon and we all know that's a hellhole so we can get away with abusing her" signal though. (Amazon is a hellhole, I spent 2 years there, in retrospect I would have been better off walking the day it became clear they were using cult methodology.[1])
It took me many years to find my calling. Once I did then my career direction was set. I'll only be working for companies in this industry going forward, because it really is my calling.
Take a job that maximizes your creativity and ability to contribute.
Don't chase big money or big names. The two almost never go together, anyway.
[1] Magical Phrases are a key indicator of cult methodology. Also known as "thought terminating cliches" they are multi-purpose sayings that are used to invoke company ideology and shut down dissent. At amazon there are things like "It's day one!" and the like. Every time I've seen these cult signals at a company it turned out to be a toxic work environment.
A good question to ask in interviews is if they company has any slogans all the employees know.