News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Assume positive intent by botswana99 on Thursday August 17, 2017 @05:16PM (#15041098)
Hanlon's Razor (‘Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by neglect.’) is better ... just assume people are not trying to screw you right away.

The lack assumed negative intent is a positive in my book

https://www.farnamstreetblog.com/2017/04/mental-model-hanlon...

Re:Assume positive intent by whipoodle on Thursday August 17, 2017 @05:28PM (#15041199)
That does seem better, because I don't think I would say people generally have positive intent. It's more like benign or neutral intent.
Re:Assume positive intent by Swizec on Thursday August 17, 2017 @07:34PM (#15042047)
The way I like to put it is: People aren't for you or against you, they're for themselves.

Most of the time people don't intentionally slight you, they just don't care enough to actively avoid it.

Re:Assume positive intent by 77pt77 on Friday August 18, 2017 @06:05AM (#15044885)
> People aren't for you or against you, they're for themselves.

Where does bullying fall in your classification?

Re:Assume positive intent by jpatokal on Friday August 18, 2017 @06:38AM (#15045029)
One popular theory of bullying states that bullies are uncertain of their own position in the social hierarchy, so they attempt to bolster it by pushing down on those weaker than them.

http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html

Re:Assume positive intent by ZeroGravitas on Friday August 18, 2017 @07:20AM (#15045192)
Which means that to be "for themselves" they feel the need to be "against others" as they view things as zero sum. I guess similar applies to other zero sum situations (or situations that people view as zero sum). The car salesman isn't trying to screw you, he's just trying to make more money for himself, by screwing you.
Re:Assume positive intent by bobbles on Thursday August 17, 2017 @07:45PM (#15042120)
I think its safe to assume in general people are just trying to do the best they can, whether they have the tools and support they need to get there is another matter
Re:Assume positive intent by AstralStorm on Friday August 18, 2017 @04:43AM (#15044559)
I do not agree. Many people just do enough to get by or say get promoted. I would hazard saying most.

It is a rare person that really wants to do best and they are typically not rewarded for it. Especially when they don't get rewarded.

Re:Assume positive intent by bitL on Friday August 18, 2017 @05:14AM (#15044675)
Unless you are trained by high-performing sociopaths (e.g. by having them in your own family) and then seeing half-baked "mastery" of those techniques in almost everyone you meet, as they are subconsciously aping those "masters" that became successful. Once you start seeing this, it can't be unseen; good luck not feeling disgusted all day long.
Re:Assume positive intent by fapjacks on Friday August 18, 2017 @07:06AM (#15045126)
There is one thing that people are binary about: Their feelings for sociopaths. You can immediately tell who has had to spend time around an honest-to-goodness sociopath and who hasn't. I always say that sociopaths are insects in human skin. Once you've had a brush with one of these "people", it forever alters your perception of the world and the people that inhabit it.
Re:Assume positive intent by CuriouslyC on Friday August 18, 2017 @08:20AM (#15045458)
I can tell you from personal experience that having faulty empathy wiring really sucks, and people who suffer from this problem are deserving of sympathy, even if it's at arms-length. It shouldn't be a surprise that going through life feeling cold and isolated is going to result in someone who does shitty things.
Re:Assume positive intent by dTal on Friday August 18, 2017 @06:27AM (#15044982)
Which techniques?
Re:Assume positive intent by doc_gunthrop on Friday August 18, 2017 @03:30PM (#15049060)
[Gaslighting](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaslighting) is perhaps one such example.
Re:Assume positive intent by beobab on Friday August 18, 2017 @06:53AM (#15045083)
bitL suggested that you are better off not knowing. Are you sure you want to go down the avenue bitL explicitly suggests will disgust you all day long?
Re:Assume positive intent by fizixer on Thursday August 17, 2017 @06:12PM (#15041520)
Came here to say this.

This kind of work irks me. No offense to the author, this is a widespread trend, not a single example.

You write a whole blog-post on a topic and not mention Hanlon's razor. It is inexcusable that you didn't know about it. It was your job to do "literature survey" or some google search, or an intellectual discussion with a handful of people, (ideally all three of them, and more) before you blurt out a whole essay on a topic. And then in the essay you create an image of yourself originally coming up with such a brilliant idea.

This is just a piece of writing (and maybe I am a bit harsh but I'm just trying to point to a trend). We're on HN. This is way worse when it comes to coding/github projects:

You create some kind of code, put it on github, create a blog-post in some shiny flat/material design, grey font, maybe medium or nautil.us posting. And put that posting on tech forums, HN, linkedin, reddit, whatever.

And you fail to mention other projects preceding you on this same exact topic, much less discuss the pros and cons of your approach vs previous approach(es). Who knows you might've ended up finding out your own code was a complete reinventing of the wheel and completely redundant (maybe you're too afraid to find that out). (As an example, look at my recent comment about 'building your own linux' vs LFS [1]).

Creating something new and original is hard work. Part of that hard work is searching for existing efforts, related work, doing a literature survey, and whether or not they were successful, and how they compare/contrast with what you did or are going to do, and so on. Short of that, you're just contributing to the noise, the bloat, and the information overload of your content consumers.

What's worse. Not putting in the full effort works for these people too. More often than not, such people are looking for a quick karma-whoring to meet their immediate objective. A github coder is looking to put something quick on their resume, to land a job interview. It's the job of the interviewer or potential employer to hold such people accountable, but I doubt they do.

I don't know. This irks me to no extent. I'm big on minimalism. I spend a lot of my efforts making sure I don't say something that's already said ('say' = a piece or writing, or a piece of code). I don't like to contribute to information bloat. Maybe it's a self-defeating habit (i.e., if you don't say anything most of time, people think you have no talent, you're a nobody).

edit: It also reminds of NIH (not-invented-here) syndrome, something Google is known for. To be clear, it's worse than when it's done by noobs (e.g., for quick karma-whoring to land a job interview, at least they're desperate). When you're in a position of "status", you definitely can do better. It also reminds of the website LessWrong [2]. Those self-entitled wannabes have created a whole universe of philosophical/logical terminology for themselves without consulting the outside world and trying to find out whether "their ideas" originated elsewhere or not.

edit 2: In case anyone wondering, yes I am advocating the opposite of 'publish or perish'. And 'publish or perish' is part of the reason we have so much information bloat (on the internet, in the libraries, everywhere). And that's part of the reason why I say my approach is self-defeating.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15030582

[2] http://lesswrong.com/

Re:Assume positive intent by vvanders on Thursday August 17, 2017 @06:36PM (#15041701)
Once you've earned a bit of trust with the approach in the article the above post shows you how effectively to destroy any relationship you've now built.
Re:Assume positive intent by unit91 on Friday August 18, 2017 @10:33AM (#15046509)
> You write a whole blog-post on a topic...It was your job to do "literature survey"

That's a pretty high bar to impose on a guy's personal blog site. I mean, he also has a poetry section. From clicking around on his blog it also appears he has a PhD from MIT, so he's certainly no stranger to research, if that were his project in this post.

> And put that posting on tech forums, HN, linkedin, reddit, whatever.

It doesn't look like that happened here. The blog was written by a guy named Rick Manelius, and posted to HN a guy named by Dan Moore. While it's possible there's some collusion going on here, I say we "assume positive intent"; that is, assume Dan found Rick's blog entry insightful and posted it to HN for the rest of us to consider.

Re:Assume positive intent by mratzloff on Friday August 18, 2017 @08:42AM (#15045578)
I see where you're coming from. As I get older I keep seeing the same things reinvented, only with all-new problems (or even the same problems). That said, I invite you to consider two things:

1) Since this is going to happen regardless of how you feel about it, arguing that human beings "should" do something differently just leads to dissatisfaction on your part. I simply roll "cites prior work" and "compares to similar approaches" into my set of criteria for judging the utility of a work or idea.

2) There is inherent value for learners in revisiting familiar (to us) concepts on their own terms. If they get excited about learning something or producing something that has been around for decades, great. They don't diminish the other works by producing theirs. And sometimes there are kernels of something new.

That said, I do require every engineer who wants to introduce some new piece of technology to do a "literature survey" as a means of teaching them how to think critically about problems.

Re:Assume positive intent by PeanutCurry on Thursday August 17, 2017 @06:38PM (#15041715)
That's a very low bar for an essay... at least in terms of length. I'd be surprised if this took long to write which isn't a criticism so much an expression of confusion as to why you called it an essay. It's also a little weird to call it inexcusable they didn't acknowledge Hanlon's Razor because it's hardly a common reference. Even the wikipedia page only gives two instances of Hanlon's razor being used and one of them is an acknowledgement that the general idea is very likely much older than the Jargon File glossary entry.
Re:Assume positive intent by fizixer on Thursday August 17, 2017 @06:41PM (#15041730)
As I said, I admit I might be a bit harsh. I took a slightly bad example of what I had in mind and went ahead and said what I wanted to say.

The bulk of my comment is about the general trend, as well as the coding community.

Re:Assume positive intent by moccachino on Friday August 18, 2017 @03:07AM (#15044154)
I feel you, I do this so often :/
Re:Assume positive intent by MrQuincle on Friday August 18, 2017 @12:20AM (#15043532)
This reminds me of another comment I once read...
Re:Assume positive intent by botswana99 on Friday August 18, 2017 @03:58PM (#15049270)
I love this comment. Maybe because I am a software engineer and dig the comments on the lack of precision and research. But also because I'm a manager and had to talk many developers of a cliff who got irked when things are not right or complete.

Applying Hanlon's Razor, I don't see any malice in this comment at all. It's just a sharp comment with a logically valid point that is a little off base socially. Behavior like this is a feature of analytic/software/STEMy people, not a bug!

Re:Assume positive intent by mekkkkkk on Friday August 18, 2017 @06:03PM (#15050119)
I've always held the belief that"reinventing the wheel" in this context is at worst a neutral thing. At best it is part of iterative progress. Perhaps the wheel itself is the same, but one small part could be slightly better. Sharing your findings is a part of this.

What really seems to grind your gears is the curation. The fact that this "inexcusable" blog post made it to the HN front page. Blaming the author for not living up to your (extremely ambitious) standards seem silly to me.

Re:Assume positive intent by taurath on Thursday August 17, 2017 @11:47PM (#15043400)
Given that almost every original thought as we know it is a synthesis of many different pieces of data rather than a burst of light out of a void, your argument is based on some very liquid ground.
Re:Assume positive intent by gasof on Thursday August 17, 2017 @09:02PM (#15042594)
What's wrong with recreating and repackaging ideas?

You'll gain a better understanding of the ideas, show others how to do the same (if you publish your efforts) and perhaps create new ideas through accidental new combinations or the concerted effort to integrate multiple existing ideas in an unusual way.

Re:Assume positive intent by dr_hooo on Friday August 18, 2017 @09:46AM (#15046059)
> And you fail to mention other projects preceding you on this same exact topic, much less discuss the pros and cons of your approach vs previous approach(es).

I think the issue isn't the recreation/repackaging but the omission of an honest discussion of how the new approach differs or what is done differently.

Re:Assume positive intent by forgottenpass on Friday August 18, 2017 @08:38AM (#15045563)
You're speaking to an important point and I often share this frustration. I don't have much to add in a comment, but thought I'd say as much because the other replies are disagreeing.
Re:Assume positive intent by komali2 on Thursday August 17, 2017 @06:43PM (#15041742)
Dude, this is so negative, what gives?
Re:Assume positive intent by matt4077 on Thursday August 17, 2017 @08:30PM (#15042372)
Hanlon is in the same-but-different territory, because it's possible (or even somewhat assumed) that Hanlon's incompetence comes with good intentions (since you've rejected malice).

Focussing on the good intentions instead of the incompetence may be beneficial for your own mental health.

Re:Assume positive intent by gasof on Thursday August 17, 2017 @08:54PM (#15042540)
It sure is interesting whether it's just good for your mental health or also good for your longevity and lifetime influence.
Re:Assume positive intent by novaleaf on Saturday August 19, 2017 @12:06PM (#15054093)
unless you are doing business in China, or with others with similar geo-political leanings. Oh wait, then how will you know?

This is why in high stakes environments this "assume positive intent" falls apart. Only where the costs don't really matter (and for a lot of wealthy americans, a couple hundred bucks lost on a bad contractor is low stakes) can you really afford to be so lax.