News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by paul on Saturday July 10, 2010 @12:55AM (#1503075)
It's also full of inaccuracies. The "interesting details" are largely wrong. Unfortunately it's written in an authoratative style, so people assume it's true and upvote, demonstrating one of the major flaws in vote based systems.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by greenlblue on Saturday July 10, 2010 @02:28AM (#1503184)
Plus, quora is not really living up to it's promise of a high quality question/answer social site. Most questions and answers are as inane as on yahoo answers and the only difference is the more pleasing UI but that wears off pretty quickly.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by Retric on Saturday July 10, 2010 @08:15AM (#1503533)
I don't know it seems to have a reasonable summery:

The most common decisions cited are:

    * Realizing that search was important.
    * Focusing on speed.
    * Maintaining corporate control.
    * Focusing on the user experience and deferring revenue.
    * Scaling out computation over a large number of cheap computers.
    * Hiring very smart people.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by resdirector on Saturday July 10, 2010 @03:18AM (#1503253)
Agreed re voting systems.

I believe that a good Q&A site should use "voting" to recursively find smart people who are similar to you and can provide you with good answers....as opposed to showing the most popular/well-written/pithiest answer. "PeopleRank", maybe.

Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by joe_the_user on Saturday July 10, 2010 @12:43PM (#1503923)
That's an interesting idea.

The problem is preventing this leading a site dominated by a group of people who share a set of extreme opinions of one sort or another. There's no now site where you can't get karma for reinforcing some commonly held group opinion and if Karma became self-reinforcing, the problem would get harder.

It might not be impossible - maybe you could have secret algorithm for rewarding people only for making well-respected non-polarizing posts. But it would be quite tricky.

Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by resdirector on Saturday July 10, 2010 @03:13PM (#1504177)
Ah, yup, there's ways around that.

The Q&A PeopleRank idea will probably be my next start-up, if Vark doesn't beat me to it. Reading http://blog.vark.com/?p=352, it seems that they're on the right track. (Although their UX is a little clunky).

However, even if Vark builds a kick-ass product, you can still apply the PeopleRank idea to news-sites like HN.

Anyone interested in building a Q&A/news site feel free to message me.

Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by jamiequint on Saturday July 10, 2010 @12:02PM (#1503846)
I agree with this and have been saying it for a while. Quora could avoid inaccuracies like this one by weighting a person's answer on a topic based on their endorsements in PageRank fashion. e.g. I endorse you on Google, which has more weight if I am myself endorsed on Google with the weight increasing based on the number of times I am endorsed and how many people have endorsed the people endorsing me and so on. I'm relatively sure Quora will do this eventually.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by mleonhard on Saturday July 10, 2010 @02:25PM (#1504096)
I started building a site that works kind of like that. It is essentially a reddit clone that will rank articles by how likely you are to vote them up. I put it on hold and decided to first build a product that users would pay for. But I would still like to build this site someday, or use it if someone else builds it first.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by marze on Saturday July 10, 2010 @02:05AM (#1503151)
What do you consider the best available information on google's history?
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by blueberry on Saturday July 10, 2010 @04:12AM (#1503341)
hey paul! why don't you write an answer there, instead of commenting here? the quoran community could benefit too :)
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by johnfn on Saturday July 10, 2010 @01:10AM (#1503085)
I suppose, before I upvote you, that I should ask you for sources then.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by mmaunder on Saturday July 10, 2010 @01:29AM (#1503099)
Paul was Google employee #23.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by jonpaul on Saturday July 10, 2010 @04:13AM (#1503346)
I would also like to point out that he has been a member of Hacker News today for exactly: 1234 days =)