News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by joe_the_user on Saturday July 10, 2010 @12:43PM (#1503923)
That's an interesting idea.

The problem is preventing this leading a site dominated by a group of people who share a set of extreme opinions of one sort or another. There's no now site where you can't get karma for reinforcing some commonly held group opinion and if Karma became self-reinforcing, the problem would get harder.

It might not be impossible - maybe you could have secret algorithm for rewarding people only for making well-respected non-polarizing posts. But it would be quite tricky.

Re:What were the key decisions that Page and Brin made in th... by resdirector on Saturday July 10, 2010 @03:13PM (#1504177)
Ah, yup, there's ways around that.

The Q&A PeopleRank idea will probably be my next start-up, if Vark doesn't beat me to it. Reading http://blog.vark.com/?p=352, it seems that they're on the right track. (Although their UX is a little clunky).

However, even if Vark builds a kick-ass product, you can still apply the PeopleRank idea to news-sites like HN.

Anyone interested in building a Q&A/news site feel free to message me.