News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by myrandomcomment on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:07PM (#15011641)
Part of the reason we served was to allow people we disagree with have the right to freedom of speech no matter how stupid their views are. Banning hate speech (no matter how abhorrent) is a slippery slope.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by CydeWeys on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:14PM (#15011744)
Private companies are allowed to choose who they want to do business with. To give you an example, pornography is legal, and the government can't jail you for making or distributing it, but it's also within Facebook's rights to decide that they don't want it on their platform.

Freedom of speech has to do with freedom from government censorship and prosecution; you can't force random private entities to help spread your speech.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by myrandomcomment on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:31PM (#15011950)
Can a domain register refuse to host a registration record for a site they disagree with? The domain system is a public system, not a corporate one.

If I register "godaddysucks.com" with Go Daddy can they say sorry you cannot register that?

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by jahewson on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:26PM (#15012524)
Yes, absolutely. All the domain name registrars have terms of service. The domain name system is not a public system, it is not run by any government. For example terms of services will often disallow uses related to pornography, gambling, violence, crime, fraud, etc.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by myrandomcomment on Monday August 14, 2017 @11:16PM (#15015099)
They have the right to be a registrar because the government allowed it (here in the US). It seems that if I registered godaddysucks.com and they refused I would have a case as they are blocking political speech on a service they where granted the right to service by the US government and thus the people.

In China the government which controls the registars for their country would of course ban"wedrovetanksovertheprotestors.co.cn". Does not seem we in the USA should allow that sort of restriction here, no?

All free speech has to be allowed. The internet in the US is a public monopoly like power, etc (despite the current FCC chairs view). As a public monopoly the right of free speech for something like a registrar has to be enforced. This does not mean Facebook cannot enforce a terms of service as you do not need to use Facebook. But banning the public resource of domain registration which allows these dumbasses to put up and host their own site violates the idea of free speech as they require a registrar to exist in order to speak. It does not matter if we do not like what they have to say. After all you need not visit the site.

Banning Nazi speech in Germay has not resulted Germany being free of neo-nazis.

Hitler started slow, prohibiting the trade unionist. Seemed like a great idea at the time.... it's a slippery slope.

Education is the only cure here. Restricting speech only leads to more extreme behavior and opens the path for others to restrict what they do not like.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by steveeq1 on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:15PM (#15011767)
Yet the government can force private entities to sell a cake to a homosexual couple? The laws seem arbitrary to me.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by ceejayoz on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:16PM (#15011784)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class

edit: The cake case was due to state laws, though.

> No federal law requires businesses to serve all customers without regard to their sexual orientation, but 21 states have “public accommodations” laws that prohibit discrimination against gays and lesbians. - http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-pol-court-gays-religio...

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by JohnTHaller on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:27PM (#15012544)
Discrimination against individuals based on gender, age, sexual orientation, etc are protected classes in many states. You're free to lobby the government to make nazis a protected class if you'd like.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by dragonwriter on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:56PM (#15012235)
> Yet the government can force private entities to sell a cake to a homosexual couple?

The government equally could adopt a law prohibiting discrimination based on advocacy of race-based violence in public accommodation as several state governments have for gender preference.

> Yet the government can force private entities to sell a cake to a homosexual couple?

Laws reflect human preferences, which are at some level arbitrary. Apparently, many states think that discrimination against gays is a problem that needs to be addressed, whereas discrimination against violent racists is not.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by jahewson on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:37PM (#15012626)
You might want to take a look at the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It's one of the most famous pieces of legislation of the 20th century - you might have heard of it? Go read the bit about "protected classes".

The law will always seem arbitrary to you as long as you are ignorant of it.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by CydeWeys on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:18PM (#15011803)
Nazis aren't a protected class in the US.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by steveeq1 on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:50PM (#15012180)
So if homosexuals weren't a protected group, you would support that?
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by CydeWeys on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:19PM (#15012465)
This is a discussion of what is legal and what isn't, no? I don't make the laws so I don't see how my views are relevant here. It's legal to refuse to do business with Nazis. That's what's at issue here.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by 0x4f3759df on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:48PM (#15012154)
Some animals are more equal than others
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by r00fus on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:30PM (#15012568)
Nice try, but how often do Nazis get beat up and killed because of their views?
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by willstrafach on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:18PM (#15011810)
The pornography example is also a good one because they experience significantly more issues with web hosting and merchant accounts due to ToS. They seem to understand and accept that.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by actsasbuffoon on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:58PM (#15013382)
> Banning hate speech (no matter how abhorrent) is a slippery slope.

We already ban some kinds of speech, and I've never heard anyone complain about it. For instance, you can't stand on a street corner and try to recruit people to join ISIS. You can't threaten to hurt or kill someone. You can't show pornography to minors, or show anyone pornography that contains minors.

These are all very popular restrictions on free speech.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by O1111OOO on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:39PM (#15014036)
> For instance, you can't stand on a street corner and try to recruit people to join ISIS. You can't threaten to hurt or kill someone. You can't show pornography to minors, or show anyone pornography that contains minors.

> These are all very popular restrictions on free speech.

A person can engage in any of the activities you describe. They will just be dealt with by those elected by the people under law established by the people.

Google, Facebook and many others are deciding what they feel you should see based on their own prejudices, identity politics, agenda-driven deals, control and manipulation of information and/or other factors.

It's a slippery slope indeed with no oversight, no means to defend yourself. A person, a domain... simply gets wiped from existence.

It's like AT&T monitoring phone calls (oh, wait...) and killing your phone service because of something you said in a group chat. Or an ISP monitoring your online activities (oh, wait...) and cutting service because you visited a controversial (but legal) site. Or a building owner tossing you out on the street because your politics don't align with his/hers.

We have laws. We also have agencies whose functions are to deal with those breaking those laws. If a domain is doing something illegal - let the law handle it and not your "well-meaning" Uncle Scrooge and his shotgun.

We also have laws against vigilantes. Are the Googles, Facebooks and others turning into information vigilantes?

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by dragonwriter on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:44PM (#15014064)
> We also have laws against vigilantes. Are the Googles, Facebooks and others turning into information vigilantes?

No, they are the owners of major digital presses that other people would like to use. But they have the freedom to choose what to use them for.

You can say whatever you want; that is protected by free speech. Google can choose not to provide a venue and assistance to you in publicizing those views; that, too, is free speech.

Your freedom of speech does not entitle you to commandeer the resources of unwilling third parties to deliver your speech. If you want collaborators, you need to convince them.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by vorotato on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:52PM (#15012202)
A single event does not a slippery slope make. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by ggggtez on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:13PM (#15011732)
Freedom of speech only applies to government entities.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by problems on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:13PM (#15011741)
Legally speaking in the US, yes. But freedom of speech arguably holds value as a concept outside of its strict legal definition.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by matt4077 on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:19PM (#15012456)
What did you serve? Coffee?
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by steveeq1 on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:14PM (#15011749)
Yes, I agree. We can easily apply the same logic and apply the ban to, say, gangsta rap, as many of lyrics are hate speech. But I'm willing to bet most people would be against this.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by PeanutCurry on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:20PM (#15011825)
Pure anecdote, but I feel like there's been a shift in terms of speech/expression philosophy. At home and in school, so-cal for context, I was taught to practice tolerance. Not because every person or peoples were good in their own way, but because attacking them or their rights would weaken the integrity of my own rights and protections since both of us derived our privileges from the same body of law. I don't know if it's just the times or post-internet connectivity but I see a lot more popular support for censorship and violence these days and it makes me a little uncomfortable.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by to_bpr on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:10PM (#15011690)
Google, Facebook, Twitter etc. have a pretty beefy track record in very selective censorship. Why would you expect anything else from them?