News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ChuckMcM on Monday August 14, 2017 @02:47PM (#15011359)
Another interesting move on Benchmark's part. I wonder if this is the key sentence: "Travis’s failure to make good on this promise, as well as his continued involvement in the day-to-day running of the company, has created uncertainty for everyone, undermining the success of the CEO search."

One of the key things about organizations which isn't always apparent is that leadership isn't "given" it is earned. This is often used as a tool in story telling where the hero's actions inspire people to follow them and so even though someone else is the "boss" the people are following the "hero."

That they are complaining about Travis, who, AFAICT, does not even have an employee role at all in the company, continues to be "involved" in day to day operations, suggests that his lack of co-operation is the issue and Travis is, or continues to be depending on your point of view, the 'bad actor' in this situation.

Sometimes you have classes where they throw out a hypothetical question like "What if you fired the boss and he didn't leave?" If Travis is able to exert that level of control over the company then clearly he continues to have people loyal to him doing as he asks against the wishes of the board. I can imagine that this would make it extremely hard to manage a company in that situation.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by OzzyB on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:05PM (#15011614)
> Travis’s failure to make good on this promise

Is this what happens when a CEO has a large voting block of shares (b/c he's smart enough to learn from previous founders' experience with VCs), and a VC firm that finds they can't have it their way (like they've been used to), publicly shame him for "not doing what he promised (us)"?

Last I checked they ousted _him_ and now they want to play "victim" because they're finding it hard to find a replacement? Maybe none feels they're able to fill his shoes or do as good a job as he's done? Last I checked Uber was still a tremendous success regardless of all their bad press and missteps/deeds.

Sorry, I just find it hard to sympathize with these people.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ChuckMcM on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:23PM (#15011862)
Not really a question of sympathizing, it's the fascination of watching warfare at these levels. Travis getting himself a right to appoint three directors, just before he is asked to step down, which he does and appoints himself as a director and has tickets for two more. While Benchmark was organizing other members of the Board to fire him, and now dealing a counter play to Travis' board seat strategy. It's rare this stuff goes on where people can see it.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by elmar on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:14PM (#15012419)
Create a board that reflects the ownership of the company (2007)

http://venturehacks.com/articles/board-structure

as a side-note actually current Uber board doesn't reflect the ownership

Benchmark as ~13,5% and one board seat

Travis as ~10% and three board seats

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by kashkhan on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:35PM (#15013647)
Someone who had the power, voted to give him those seats. Maybe they were stupid, maybe not.

Travis may not be a nice person, but he is good at playing this game and is beating the capitalists at their own game.

Why should I cry for benchmark?

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by elmar on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:08PM (#15013848)
Travis is probably the best entrepreneur ever in fundraising, so good he managed to at such later stage to keep control and even have a disproportionate power in relation to is ownership.

Mobody is crying for Benchmark and this lawsuit looks ridiculous and it's going to affect their deal flow quality for many years to come.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by elmar on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:40PM (#15013679)
Just wondering if Travis could ever imagined the Uber success he could have funded Uber Angel round of $1,2M by inself he had the money to do it. Everything being equal he now would own 20% but probably would have the same problem with Benchmark.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by shostack on Monday August 14, 2017 @11:25PM (#15015145)
Fascinating indeed. Do you happen to have any recommended reading for those of us interested in learning how things really happen at the board level? There's so much politics and intrigue that goes on behind the scenes that rarely becomes public.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ChuckMcM on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @12:42AM (#15015561)
Recommended reading? not really. I expect most people would find the real stuff just sad. Much of the drama seems to be politics mixed with greed.

I've served on a couple of boards (private companies) once as an independent director and once as a technical adviser and remember wondering once if the folks I was dealing with were just bored or if they really didn't care one way or the other.

That said, I've also worked with board members at companies that were very engaged and very involved with their companies and the companies involved benefited from their attention.

The only common thread was that generally the board members had a whole lot less to lose if the company failed than the executive staff did, and so they often assume that the executive staff is motivated to make things succeed, and seem disinclined to second guess the CEO and their team's tactics. Of course things get unpleasant when the tactics make them look bad as we've seen in Uber and Theranos as well.

There are various places that recruit people to serve on boards. Some people feel like it 'boosts' their executive street cred if they are on the boards of several companies. I'm not one of the people who is impressed by something like that but I recognize that some folks are and its part of the VC "game". (sort like having rare Magic the Gathering cards I guess, "I play Unicorn Startup on your Bootstrapped Lifestyle Business.") It would probably make for an interesting subplotline in Silicon Valley.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ShabbosGoy on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:28PM (#15011918)
It also serves as a cautionary tale; as an entrepreneur, be very careful whom you accept money from. In many cases, it's a Faustian deal.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by HarryHirsch on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:43PM (#15012092)
a Faustian deal

Faustian deal indeed. The only way to read Faust is as the story of someone who is in over his head and screws up at every turn. Every thing that Faust touches turns to shit. There's nothing Faustian about Faust.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by Hydraulix989 on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:17PM (#15014272)
Almost everyone that uses that phrase uses it in OP's context, making your comment seem like mere pedantry.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by hughw on Monday August 14, 2017 @09:18PM (#15014565)
But welcome pedantry (to me).
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by HarryHirsch on Monday August 14, 2017 @09:41PM (#15014653)
And topical. Travis Kalanick plays Faust, Matt Cohler from Benchmark plays Mephisto. Susan Fowler plays Gretchen (or perhaps Marthe Schwerdtlein, no one applies for a leading position at any large company without doing diligence through inside contacts, and no one can tell me that she didn't know that Uber was full to the rafters with perverts and sex maniacs).
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by vcao2 on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:27PM (#15012538)
It also serves as a cautionary tale; as a venture capitalist, be very careful whom you provide capital to.

It has been obvious for years that Travis Kalanick will run Uber into the ground, unless controlled. This is not new. One of the reasons there isn't a CFO is so he doesn't have to justify his awful ideas.

It's good to see Benchmark is finally admitting that they (and the rest of the board) have failed to do their job; by failing to more adequately govern Uber.

Uber is a looming disaster for investors, and I pity employees there who think their options are going to make them rich. That will only be true for a very, very few, because Travis has made decisions that will leave most of them with basically nothing.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ryanwaggoner on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:08PM (#15013464)
This is a pretty laughable comment to make about a guy who took a company from $0 to $70 billion. Uber has completely changed transportation for millions of people around the globe. You might be right that Uber needs someone different for the next phase, but you make him sound like Michael Scott.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by valuearb on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:14PM (#15014791)
He was a tremendous fund-raiser. He may have been a great early stage CEO.

Right now the company isn't worth $70B, and is hemorrhaging money. Which is why he agreed to step down. He's clearly been overmatched as CEO for a long while now.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ryanwaggoner on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:35PM (#15014892)
Strongly disagree, but we'll see :)
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by jon_richards on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:23PM (#15013566)
Wasn't Michael Scott also extremely successful in the show?
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by bmm6o on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:42PM (#15014402)
He's an incompetent manager. There are suggestions and moments of characterization that suggest that he was a good salesman who was promoted above his abilities. He was not extremely successful.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ryanwaggoner on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:00PM (#15013800)
I've watched like 4 episodes of the office, but we're talking about the same guy, right? The one who is a middle manager at a small sales office in Scranton? Pretty far cry from growing a company from $0 to billions in revenue, creating hundreds of thousands of jobs, and upending a global industry. In 8 years.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by jon_richards on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:51PM (#15014114)
It was a plot point of the show that his branch was the only successful one. The company was literally selling printer paper in an increasingly digital world. He may not have made billions of dollars, but he still succeeded at a seemingly impossible task.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ethbro on Monday August 14, 2017 @11:09PM (#15015061)
> creating hundreds of thousands of jobs

I'd say it's a stretch to call these jobs until they're proven sustainable without VC money subsidizing drivers.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ryanwaggoner on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @06:21AM (#15016896)
Fair enough.

How about: "he convinced billionaires to give generous subsidies to hundreds of thousands of working class drivers"? :)

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by rtx on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:03PM (#15013419)
As a customer they have my Support. Travis and team have created something amazing.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by valuearb on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:10PM (#15014780)
"They" ousted him, but "they" can't force him to leave?

Sounds like a pretty big contradiction.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by dpiers on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:23PM (#15011866)
Travis is a very sympathetic figure to many employees. He has poured his life into the company, to the point the two were indistinguishable up until his resignation. Travis was Uber, and Uber was Travis.

Benchmark's letter makes me wonder about the full content of the Holder report. Their lawsuit listed scandals that were already public, but whatever was in the report seems to be what triggered their initial request for Travis to step away from the company.

I wonder how many of the "Travis loyalists" would reconsider their position if they were aware of the full extent of the risks the company was exposed to as a result of his management.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by munificent on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:27PM (#15013595)
> I wonder how many of the "Travis loyalists" would reconsider their position if they were aware of the full extent of the risks the company was exposed to as a result of his management.

If I learned anything from the last US election it's that many people will overlook all manner of moral failings if the person in question is powerful and "alpha" enough.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by uniformlyrandom on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:07PM (#15012340)
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by dpiers on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:21PM (#15012481)
Those are the recommendations of the report, not the report itself. Only a few people have seen the entire thing.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by leereeves on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:26PM (#15012532)
That's an interesting document. Have the findings of Covington's investigation also been made public, or only the recommendations?
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by samstave on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:21PM (#15012484)
>Travis was Uber, and Uber was Travis.

TBF to travis; that is how it should be, it would seem... but

* the actions of him at dinner in NYC and his comments there

* the claims against the corp from females

* claims by his GF

* THE FACT THAT 99% of his employees are not millenials employed at the SF HQ, vs the ~N K ppl employed as drivers...

Sure, as ChuckMcM said: "direct reports" how many is that? What about the N # of employees that his direct influence didnt positively effect?

Look; I love Uber as a service - as a company, Danny deVito would have been a better CEO from a cultural fit.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by rsp1984 on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:13PM (#15012971)
the actions of him at dinner in NYC and his comments there, ..., claims by his GF

Now I'm curious. Can you give more detail here or at least some links?

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by edoceo on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:25PM (#15012522)
I think you mean the character Frank
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by solaarphunk on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:34PM (#15012604)
At least there would have been rum-ham.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:06PM (#15011627)
> If Travis is able to exert that level of control over the company then clearly he continues to have people loyal to him

Kalanick is being accused of defaulting on an agreement "to modify the company’s voting agreement to ensure that the board was composed of independent, diverse, and well qualified directors" and acting "to deter candidates and create a power vacuum in which Travis could return."

Defaulting on agreements doesn't take particular skill. While installing a surrogate would have been a show of power, throwing a wrench into the search process in hopes that it convinces people to bring him back also signals that those same people don't think he should be back right now. It's a move that signals weakness, not strength.

This letter is a message to people who, while perhaps not coöperating with Travis, left him dark corners from which to throw around muck. Loudly and clearly, Benchmark is saying "the old king is dead."

Disclaimer: These is personal, casual commentary and does NOT constitute investment advice. Please do NOT buy or sell any securities based on my Internet comments.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by Normal_gaussian on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:38PM (#15013667)
So you recommend holding onto securities?
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:57PM (#15014148)
ಠ_ಠ
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by throwaway0071 on Monday August 14, 2017 @02:54PM (#15011460)
The fact that Travis doesn't want to let go of Uber is completely normal. He is the founder, the boss, the guy with lots of money. There's a power play in place and people don't know who will win.

It's normal that employees at all levels will still give him some leverage. It doesn't say anything about employee loyalty or Travis being the leader they want.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by justonepost on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:11PM (#15012373)
It's a board battle pure and simple. We are all speculating and making it worse. It's like speculating on a divorce. Doesn't help anyone. However, the married couple needs to come to some common agreement. That much we know.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by anindha on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:16PM (#15012999)
The kids are the employees in that analogy and that is whom to the letter is addressed. Not simply a board battle.
Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by throwasehasdwi on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:20PM (#15012471)
> undermining the success of the CEO search

Travis legally has control of the company just like an owner would. Nobody can "force" him to leave on run his company as certain way. Benchmark is just whining because they can't get their way.

Benchmark agreed to let him have permanent control when they invested, if they didn't want that they shouldn't have signed the contract.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:42PM (#15012670)
> Benchmark agreed to let [Kalanick] have permanent control when they invested, if they didn't want that they shouldn't have signed the contract

Invisibly stapled to every contract is the entire corpus of relevant law. Delaware, for instance, protects minority investors from certain categories of abuse. If the claims in this letter are true regarding Kalanick telling Uber's Board that he was going to sign certain voting rights agreements, and then he did not do that, it could be grounds for finding violations per those laws.

Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This is not legal nor investment advice.

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by samstave on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:23PM (#15011859)
>leadership isn't "given" it is earned

Yeah, but; earned by whom???

The board? What if they are inept? What if you have X0,000?? employees - especially those who are 99.9% NEVER going to set foot in an office of, or the presence of "dear leader"?

Why/how shall they 'earn' the respect of said leader?

Not going to happen...

Leadership respect is earned by those in proximity to direct results that affect THEM...

Driver results from leader in Uber's case == "all gripes drivers have due to proximity to leader/leader's policies that affect their $$ line...."

Tell Zuck to be a line cook in the BBQ stand in MPK - for two months, and not having to go to his palo alto compound, attend his 'charity' events for new-parent-syndrome-billionaires, etc... the outcome will be diff...

He will never earn the respect of a line-cook, as JK will never earn the respect of an uberdriver doing their "side-hustle" (the recent uber commercial is advertising to young, black, urban females to "get a side-hustle"^ by being an uber driver.

^ -- Yes this is the actual quote from the commercial.

Oh look; they have the male trope going as well:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZsbWt6FjlTk

So black science teachers who chill and play pool needa side hustle as well??

Re:Letter from Benchmark to Uber Employees [pdf] by ChuckMcM on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:34PM (#15012003)

   > Yeah, but; earned by whom???
Your direct reports. I have known managers who had earned the followship of their direct reports, and I've known some who "lead" by threatening their direct reports with retribution. In the latter case you can change leaders easily because there is no loyalty to the person just a fear of the retribution. If on the other hand a leader earns their followers loyalty their direct reports will do what they can to aid them, even when it might be against the rules to do so.

One of the tougher places you can find yourself is when you're loyalty is to one leader, but you are being asked to follow a different leader. That is especially difficult if it is a different leader that you do not respect.

I've seen that situation occur when the leader is removed against their wishes and so they have made no effort to help the team transition to the new leader (or acting leader). That is hard on the new leader and unfair to the team, but I have seen it up close more than once.