Or is this just going to be a news blip that's forgotten as Tesla's stock surges and Musk makes other sensational news?
Are there any consequences for failure here?
As for Musk? Well, considering that he's spent time in the past sleeping at the assembly lines to make sure stuff is going well, I don't see him reneging on this.
Managers may know how to manage, but the best people who know how to do the technical job, and how to do it best are always the folks on the production line.
1) The article is BS and Musk's statement reflects the real state of Tesla manufacturing-labor principles. 2) Musk's statement and the article are both accurate and work habits will change, which means Tesla will voluntarily reduce output. No worries, they have lots of capital and can afford to slow the rollout. 3) Musk's statement and the article are both accurate but Musk is being undermined by mid-level managers he can't control. Poor hapless ineffectual Elon. 4) Musk's statement is deceptive PR. He is in control and forced to choose between hitting ship targets (widely reported as crucial to Tesla's survival) and reducing worker injuries, he is choosing the former.
Does no one else see how this is an intimidation tactic?
A CEO of Alcoa famously required any injury to be on his desk within 24 hours and some high level executives were fired for not taking it seriously when the information emerged through indirect channels. The ultimate result was dramatically improved safety for ~10,000 employees. Elon Musk is certainly taking a page from Alcoa's playbook here.
In Alcoa's case, the safety record improved because the CEO made safety the number one priority over even profits, and this led to a culture shift that examined small inefficiencies and led to improved quality as well as improved safety practices.
Reducing harm requires actually implementing a harm reduction strategy. Informing the CEO of every single injury can tell them when the plan isn't working [as they receive each report], but it also fails to tell them it is working, because they don't necessarily know why they aren't hearing reports.
You don't need to personally receive these reports as a CEO. This is just Musk being a control freak. Usually, CEOs implement policies like "inform me immediately every time X happens" because they don't want to get caught off guard when something bad happens.
I dealt with a similar thing at a previous job, and it definitely instilled fear in a lot of people, but it never addressed the cause of the concern. Churning on injuries to reduce specific causes of specific injuries is not a culture shift, it's reactionary.
1. "Going forward, I’ve asked that every injury be reported directly to me, without exception."
2. "I’m meeting with the safety team every week and would like to meet every injured person as soon as they are well, so that I can understand from them exactly what we need to do to make it better."
3. "I will then go down to the production line and perform the same task that they perform."
There is an implied fourth step that the process will be changed based on this feedback. I agree it should be explicit in this note -- but the Mercury News article does say that the 3 assembly has been changed to be easier for line workers based on feedback from S and X, so presumably that will continue.
I originally thought that he was requiring the injured parties report to him directly, but on a second reading that doesn't seem like the case. So I don't think it's an intimidation tactic anymore. I do, however, think that he is nuts.
Which makes logical sense too. Why are their injury rates higher? Because management isn't doing the right things to lower them. That's because either a) they don't care (which seems unlikely, given that they really need to hit production targets, and injured people can't work) or b) they're ignorant as to the actual causes.
Immersion in "minutia" (aka the actual work experience) is certainly one way to cure ignorance.
However Musk also demands overtime and says the production will be difficult, so I'm not sure how long it will take for things to improve, particularly for repetitive strain injuries.
Are you claiming that meeting Elon would be intimidating and the 'threat' of that would prevent people from reporting injuries at all?
For anything even remotely serious that seems unlikely to have an impact, if you're injured enough to need medical care I don't think that "management will find out" is going to dissuade you from making whatever reports you need to get medical care.
Or do you mean he is intimidating the managers into taking injuries seriously? In that case, yes, I guess you could call it that. But I definitely support that sort of intimidation.
It's 'caring theater'. He thinks he is the President meeting with people getting the purple heart for service. Such utter bullshit. [1] [2]
[1] The fact that he says he wants to be personally involved in the process is what puts it over the edge. I mean he is running how many companies?
[2] And to front run any legal or PR issues. Create an emotional block for the harmed to take things a step further. "Keep your friends close and your enemies closer".
I read similar stuff in The Toyota Way book where workers kept complaining to the management about poor manufacturing processes leading to the injury and poor quality incidents and then the management made sure these processes are constantly improved (Kaizen).
Right. That is what I am calling out. The fact that he will do this is ludicrous and certainly not anywhere near the best use of his time.
We are not talking about a small mom and pop or lean startup with limited resources.
> and then the management made sure these processes
The CEO of Toyota? Almost certainly not.
Undercover boss type things or spending a few hours in a call center or store or anywhere to get a seat of the pants feel for things? Sure.
Musk is ultraproductive and works very closely with his employees. Tesla only has two factories; it's on a much more manageable scale than something like Toyota.
Sure and maybe to show his appreciation he will invite all of them to use some of the great things that he gains or has that they don't (material or otherwise) for the herculean effort. They aren't all created equal and his equal we all know that. Would think especially the factory workers on the floor.
And I am a owner and not a worker. So this isn't about the downtrodden or me feeling abused in a similar situation. Hasn't happened. It's about being realistic and quite frankly in all honesty jealousy of someone that can flip such stuff which I was never able to do even if it would benefit me. Couldn't be that dishonest.
Not saying that it isn't an effective technique (your point). It is.
The thing people are wondering about is whether it is disingenuous bullshit PR.
[0]: > “No words can express how much I care about your safety and wellbeing. It breaks my heart when someone is injured building cars and trying their best to make Tesla successful.
Going forward, I’ve asked that every injury be reported directly to me, without exception. I’m meeting with the safety team every week and would like to meet every injured person as soon as they are well, so that I can understand from them exactly what we need to do to make it better. I will then go down to the production line and perform the same task that they perform.
This is what all managers at Tesla should do as a matter of course. At Tesla, we lead from the front line, not from some safe and comfortable ivory tower. Managers must always put their team’s safety above their own.”