Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by semperdark on Sunday August 13, 2017 @10:35AM
(#15003057)
Your copy says:
"Instead of paying $1,800+ per project, or hiring an in-house UI designer with a $70,000+/year salary, Fairpixels Pro gives you the best of both worlds at a fraction of the cost."
At the same time, your cheapest plan is $1750/mo. I get that it's "technically" under $1800, but are you expecting startups to have multiple projects per month to make the math work?
Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by jakobegger on Sunday August 13, 2017 @03:23PM
(#15004449)
My experience with designers is that it takes a lot of revisions to get stuff right. A single project will have dozens of emails back and forth. If a response really takes 4 working days, that doesn’t sound very useful — unless you aren’t picky and will accept whatever the designer sends you (which in my experience usually isn’t even close to the quality of the work in their portfolio)
Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by fairpx on Sunday August 13, 2017 @04:48PM
(#15004858)
We're averaging about 3 projects/mo per client based on the first batch of customers who've been using the service for the last 4 months or so. Having a dedicated design team (not outsourced but in house) makes it easier for the client. They know what to expect. The workflow gets improved etc. the way we can make it work is because of the subscription model. It allows us to spend less time looking for projects (time = money). And more time doing what we love (designing interfaces and brands)
Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by have_faith on Sunday August 13, 2017 @07:46AM
(#15002536)
I'm immediately put off by any service that uses the word unlimited in marketing material. Whether that's "unlimited" bandwidth, storage space, use of someone's time, or all you can eat hot wings.
Some criticisms: The site is a one page brochure site, it feels odd for a service of this scale. Your example images aren't clickable and there's no explanation of what I'm looking at exactly. Email sounds like a bad format for handling project management, it's difficult to follow an email chain to figure out what was agreed on etc, email is a very bad single-source-of-truth for project details.
I'm being critical because I don't think it's a bad idea, I just think the execution could do with polishing. There are companies that could perhaps benefits from this idea, but I would be put off by this page.
Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by tsunamifury on Sunday August 13, 2017 @11:57AM
(#15003390)
I guess this service somehow hopes that you can separate the interaction design from the visual design... except the interaction design is the expensive part (to the tune of a 2x more than 70k/y).
So I guess in this workflow the PM is also the interaction designer and implementation with an engineer, while you pay for these UI decorators on top.
Might work for some small website updates, but anything more substatial would probably be not worth it.
Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by jtth on Sunday August 13, 2017 @11:40AM
(#15003323)
In a well-oiled world, someone subscribing to this service would use one employee full-time. $1750 doesn't pay that person's monthly salary unless you're outsourcing heavily, which is something people shopping for this service probably already know how to do. So I guess I'm confused as to how this all works, other than relying on the subscribers' downtime as profit, which sets up a really weird relationship between the business and its users.
Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by fairpx on Sunday August 13, 2017 @05:32PM
(#15005076)
We've been running thr service for a while now and the reality is that one designer can easily handle multiple clients. We've basically improved our internal workflow to work as effectively as possible. The more we work with a particular client, the better we get at anticipating their project types, expectations, etc.
Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by majewsky on Sunday August 13, 2017 @04:42PM
(#15004830)
I'm seeing a bunch of white and gray screen areas without any text in them. That's either a refreshing and bold insistence on minimalism or uMatrix doing its job.
Re:Show HN: Unlimited UI design
by davidmurdoch on Sunday August 13, 2017 @07:14AM
(#15002458)
You've got a 404 on the link in the top left corner (mobile).
Is this site associated with Remy Sharp?
Also, when scanning your prices real quick on mobile I saw "$6,000/mo" and just about noped out. I understand what you're trying to do here, but maybe you need to rethink the placement of this comparison price?
"Instead of paying $1,800+ per project, or hiring an in-house UI designer with a $70,000+/year salary, Fairpixels Pro gives you the best of both worlds at a fraction of the cost."
At the same time, your cheapest plan is $1750/mo. I get that it's "technically" under $1800, but are you expecting startups to have multiple projects per month to make the math work?
Whether they can actually deliver finished designs every 4 days is a different question.
Some criticisms: The site is a one page brochure site, it feels odd for a service of this scale. Your example images aren't clickable and there's no explanation of what I'm looking at exactly. Email sounds like a bad format for handling project management, it's difficult to follow an email chain to figure out what was agreed on etc, email is a very bad single-source-of-truth for project details.
I'm being critical because I don't think it's a bad idea, I just think the execution could do with polishing. There are companies that could perhaps benefits from this idea, but I would be put off by this page.
p.s. you're missing a favicon.
There's some history and discussions in the (many) older posts by the user[1].
(I think trying to create a repeatable model for services is great BTW -- helps support smaller lifestyle business, IMO, which we need more of.)
https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=fairpx
So I guess in this workflow the PM is also the interaction designer and implementation with an engineer, while you pay for these UI decorators on top.
Might work for some small website updates, but anything more substatial would probably be not worth it.
I would think that an agency would only feature their best designs, in which case I'd hate to see what the median looks like.
Is this site associated with Remy Sharp?
Also, when scanning your prices real quick on mobile I saw "$6,000/mo" and just about noped out. I understand what you're trying to do here, but maybe you need to rethink the placement of this comparison price?
What about my comment could be improved here?
> Without paying $6,000/mo+ for an in-house UI designer
..with the actual price right below.