News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Origin of Japanese Tempura by Berobero on Friday August 11, 2017 @03:25PM (#14993305)
Portuguese loanwords in Japanese are interesting because, unlike other Western word imports, a lot of them have been around long enough, and thoroughly integrated into the culture and writing system, that a number of them are assumed to be Japanese or Sino-Japanese words by most all native speakers.

Tenpura (commonly seen as 天麩羅 or 天婦羅) is one example, but also karuta (a card game, commonly 歌留多 or 加留多) and konpeitō (a confection, commonly 金平糖). The the case of karuta, at least, it feels enough like a regular Japanese word that it undergoes a morphophonological transformation (rendaku e.g. uta-garuta) typically reserved for the native Japanese lexicon (i.e. not Sino-Japanese or other loanwords).

Re:The Origin of Japanese Tempura by jpatokal on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:53PM (#14995403)
Kanji are not commonly used for any of those words. However, they are typically rendered in hiragana, which is usually reserved only for native Japanese words.

Tabako (タバコ、たばこ、煙草) is another well-entrenched Portuguese loan, with particularly wacky kanji: they mean "smoke grass", which is reasonable enough, but you'd never guess the characters are read "tabako".

Re:The Origin of Japanese Tempura by rangibaby on Saturday August 12, 2017 @07:16AM (#14997452)
煙草 is ateji which in this case means that the characters are read that way only for that word.

The other kind of ateji is when kanji are used like an alphabet eg 亜米利加 (A me ri ka). The second kind is mainly used for abbreviations in modern Japanese eg 米 is equivalent to writing "US" in English.

Re:The Origin of Japanese Tempura by Berobero on Friday August 11, 2017 @10:26PM (#14996048)
> Kanji are not commonly used for any of those words.

Forgive me if it seemed as though I was talking about usage ratios; I was merely saying that it's not uncommon to see them written in the kanji stylized form; in the case of konpeito, however, the kanji is by far the most common form (probably because the character semantics fit well). 天 also literally means tempura in a variety of derivative words.

But mostly I was just getting at how fundamentally integrated portuguese loanwords are in Japanese in general. shabon-dama (bubbles), kappa (raincoat), kabocha (pumpkin), and other's. Juban (a traditional undergarment) is probably the most surprising.

Re:The Origin of Japanese Tempura by cdavid on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:26PM (#14995817)
The writing "天ぷら" is common enough I think. I just got tempura udon a day ago, and the menu was using the kanji.
Re:The Origin of Japanese Tempura by cma on Saturday August 12, 2017 @03:52AM (#14996915)
Are arigato and obrigado related? (edit: apparently not, it is mentioned here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glossary_of_Japanese_words_of_... )
Re:The Origin of Japanese Tempura by ekianjo on Friday August 11, 2017 @08:55PM (#14995694)
there is castella too. written in katakana though. But then even Coffee has a kanji spellIng and nobody is going to assume its a native japanese word. 珈琲