Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by bearcobra on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:00PM
(#14983564)
A question I've been pondering since the Martin Shkreli verdict, is fraud OK if the deceived parties still profit?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by shallot_router on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:29PM
(#14983881)
Yes. You can't take a bunch of money from investors and then lie to them and tell them their money's doing great when most of it's actually gone, even if you do later manage to hit it big and pay them back. Imagine the kind of precedent that would set if this weren't considered fraud. "Temporary Ponzi schemes" would spring up everywhere.
Maybe it changes the charges and the sentencing, if there is no indication that the person sought to personally profit or steal from the investors, but lying is lying.
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by sah2ed on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:11PM
(#14983657)
Fraud is never OK. The end does not justify the means.
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by angersock on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:22PM
(#14984900)
What a small-minded view. Our entire runs on fraud of one degree or another--sometimes it's just more than people are willing to bear.
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by sah2ed on Thursday August 10, 2017 @06:33PM
(#14984977)
You are joking right?
The question about fraud was in the context of the misappropriation of capital from investors for a purpose different from what was initially agreed to, and not as a general catch-all term for posturing or affectation either by politicians or the general populace.
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by angersock on Friday August 11, 2017 @01:13AM
(#14986723)
Hell, you could make the same argument about a company jumping into a different product line with capital intended for a particular buildout.
Your blanket statement "this is never is justified" was my primary objection.
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by danielam on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:06PM
(#14983622)
A consequentialist might argue that it is, but then, consequentialists are wrong.
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by EthanHeilman on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:23PM
(#14983806)
Given human nature, widespread belief in consequentialism as an ethical system would likely result is very bad consequences. So from the position that consequentialism is correct it is probably unethical to advocate as a correct viewpoint.
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by shallot_router on Thursday August 10, 2017 @04:30PM
(#14983891)
What if (purely hypothically) all consequentialists could agree on the same set of standards for what constitutes positive and negative utility?
Re:Benchmark Capital Sues Travis Kalanick for Fraud
by EthanHeilman on Thursday August 10, 2017 @05:02PM
(#14984245)
How do you think this purely hypothetical conspiracy of consequentialists would go about convincing people to follow that set of standards?