News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by rarec on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @05:07PM (#14962710)
It's rare to also see these articles point out the immense pay discrepancy that can occur.

Companies seem to want loyalty but they don't want to give it. This leads to the merc approach of just selling to the highest bidder.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by throwaway2016a on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @05:16PM (#14962795)
In my experience while a developer will say it's not about the money, if the gap is big enough it is disrespectful to the developer and they will (easily) find employment elsewhere.

Often time's it's not actually about the money. But the low pay (relatively) is a signal to the developer of how much / little you value them.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by eropple on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @05:30PM (#14962954)
This is, historically, where I was at. Consistently delivering high-quality stuff that makes my fellow devs able to do their jobs faster and better, and while in the top quartile of salaries, it wasn't remotely reflective of the value being generated. That's why I went into consulting in the first place.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by vacri on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:01PM (#14963298)
Running your own (successful) business is always going to net you more money than being salaried. It's the payoff for taking the risk. A company pays a salary based on how hard it is to replace you, not your value generation, whereas your own company nets you $all_the_things.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by JetSpiegel on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:28PM (#14963548)
The risk is $all_the_things <= 0, which is pretty common.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by HeroOfAges on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @02:12PM (#14972017)
See you space cowboy... Sorry, couldn't help myself.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by ringaroundthetx on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:45PM (#14963683)
> In my experience while a developer will say it's not about the money

The people that say this simply rationalize it differently than people willing to say it is about the money. (but yes, there is a group where it really isn't about money)

There is a large segment of the population that feels a stigma for admitting monetary motivation, so if its not "ALL" about the money, where all possible factors are money, they will say it isn't.

People that don't feel a stigma around admitting monetary motivation will reveal that money is a factor if it is at least 1 of the factors. It will be misinterpreted by the other population as being only about the money, whether it is or isn't.

It is just a form of conditioning that will distort any survey for now.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by matwood on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @08:28PM (#14964410)
Money is always a factor, but just like the other factors the amount matters. I’ve taken a little less money before because I liked the job and had control. I also believed it would work out in the end and it did.

I happily admitted if someone offered me %30+ more money I would think hard about leaving. I remember telling my boss that exact thing at the time and he understood. The honesty is one of the reasons I enjoyed the job.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by fweespeech on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @05:16PM (#14962783)
To be honest (at least in my experience) if you are really worth $X as a developer, you can generally get your current employer to give you $X if you are proactive about it.

Quitting generally has more to do with:

A) "You (the employer) Waited Until The Exit Interview To Ask What’s Wrong"

B) "You (the employee) Waited Until The Exit Interview To Convey What's Wrong"

Leaving my last job, I told them what I wanted 1-2 years before I actually left (for more money, but that wasn't the primary cause). The CEO basically told me in the exit interview if it was about money, he'd give me another 30% to get me to stay (and they had countered with that before, back when I told them what I needed to stay long term).

Money isn't necessarily the cause. Its the lack of willingness to communicate and meet the other person's needs.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by morgante on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @02:30AM (#14966056)
Some companies have a hard limit on developer salaries. Many will never pay a developer over $200k, even if the developer is that good.

This can come from two reasons:

1. The company doesn't have sufficiently valuable projects to capture the developer's potential. There are a lot of companies which simply don't need very senior developers and hence cannot match the price for a senior developer on the open market.

2. The company perceives developers as second-class relative to management or their core business leaders. Thus, they can never have developers paid more than those core people.

These companies see a very consistent talent pool of mediocre developers (who have been mediocre for a long time) and junior developers who come in and leave after 1-2 years once they realize they can get more elsewhere.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by fweespeech on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:39AM (#14976424)
There is no real reason to pay developers (or anyone really) over $200k to be perfectly honest. At $200k/year, if you are valuing money over intangibles you are making terrible life choices imho.

Work less, get out and do fun things more.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by spraak on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @05:50PM (#14963187)
I dunno. I work for a company based in the UK, which seems to have much lower pay than the US. I am paid the same as other senior developers at the company, yet my salary by comparison to US standards is quite low ($70k and no benefits since I'm technically a contractor). Otherwise the company is really amazing, so I'm torn.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by mgkimsal on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:11PM (#14963396)
If you are actually in the UK, you have some amazing benefits that US-based folks don't get in the form of healthcare. I know, yes, technically, you're paying for it in taxes, but it's there for you all the time, regardless of your employment status or ability to pay for an insurance policy.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by morgante on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @02:32AM (#14966067)
> If you are actually in the UK, you have some amazing benefits that US-based folks don't get in the form of healthcare.

So? That's pretty irrelevant since any good developer job in the US comes with excellent health coverage.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by Tangurena2 on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @07:25AM (#14967488)
The healthcare that comes with any good developer job is the same healthcare that management thinks is good enough for their employees. It is rarely the case that it is good by objective standards.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by mgkimsal on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @10:25AM (#14969192)
And when you lose your job... you lose access to that "excellent health coverage".

Health insurance being so culturally tied to "employment" is ... very problematic.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by morgante on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @10:41AM (#14969438)
You don't have to preach that to me (I agree), but it does mean that you shouldn't really consider universal healthcare to be an additional benefit when comparing UK & US developers. The US developer also has healthcare not factored into their salary.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by spraak on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @08:43PM (#14964516)
Sorry it wasn't clear, I'm actually in the US.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by Leon on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @07:22PM (#14963951)
In addition to more vacation days, maternity leave, etc
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by flukus on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @09:01PM (#14964624)
Contractors don't get those. In theory they get paid higher as compensation for not getting them, in practice they generally get the same money with less benefits.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by orf on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:39PM (#14963638)
Do you work in London or Cambridge? If so, that's a pretty low salary for a senior developer. In my experience that's mid level range, you're looking at more 70+k ($90k) for senior. That's excluding finance of course, where salaries are astronomical.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by richardknop on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @07:40PM (#14964103)
This. For highly talented developer it is definitely possible to make 6 digit salary in London at least, not sure about Cambridge.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by spraak on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @08:44PM (#14964524)
Sorry, I'm actually in the US. I'm surprised to hear that that's a low salary for the UK, as well.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by user5994461 on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @09:07PM (#14964668)
London only, not to confuse with the UK.

Good luck finding a senior developer for £70k over there.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by fweespeech on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:02PM (#14963310)
Expecting countries to match salaries an ocean apart is...unwise. Countries have very different economic situations.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by preid24 on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @12:52PM (#14971115)
London is its own bubble. The part of the UK I'm in, £35k is the going rate for a senior software developer.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by fweespeech on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:41AM (#14976434)
I'm really sorry. :\ That is absurd.

You should be able to find remote work that pays £50k+ relatively easily. Although the whole Brexit thing may make that harder. :\

To me, £70k was more a geographic / economic area issue. Under $50k/£50k you just have to get out.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by spraak on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @08:44PM (#14964521)
I understand that, but it still hurts.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by Consultant32452 on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @08:52PM (#14964569)
Stop comparing your salary to the US and start comparing it to India. You can be certain that's what your employer is comparing it to. And as soon as they can get the the same quality of work out of India you'll get the boot.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by Retra on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:26PM (#14965295)
And how soon do you think that'll be?
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by iends on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:51PM (#14965410)
Long after it matters to me.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by scottLobster on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:05PM (#14963341)
How would that work? For the company to make a profit, employees by definition have to produce more value than they consume.
Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by fweespeech on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @08:48PM (#14964544)
> How would that work? For the company to make a profit, employees by definition have to produce more value than they consume.

Most people aren't primarily motivated by money once they are making a full salary as a developer.

PTO, Work/Life Balance, and Geography are more relevant to my life choices than how much I'm paid (to a point, certain areas I've noticed don't pay enough).

https://ycharts.com/companies/GOOG/profit_margin

Alphabet was running a 13.55% margin for its latest quarter.

https://ycharts.com/companies/WMT/profit_margin

Walmart was at a 2.59% profit margin for its latest quarter.

Which of these companies do you think are providing better PTO, Work/Life Balance, etc.?

The reality is intangibles mean more to developers than another 10% salary bump once they are making $150k.

Re:Why some of the best developers keep quitting by TwelveNights on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @09:04PM (#14964649)
A shame too because money can be one of the most powerful factors for retention. Someone who enjoys a company could still simply leave due to better prospects elsewhere.