News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by manuellemos on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:03PM (#1496104)
This article is just wishful thinking of Microsoft haters.

Microsoft does need to be so much innovative as long as users buy Windows and Office. Windows 7 has been selling at 15 million copies a month. This just proves that whether or not Microsoft is innovative these days, Windows and Office sells like hot-cakes.

Same goes with IBM and their mainframes. A lot of IBM haters kept predicting that IBM and mainframes would be extinct just because they are not innovative, but the reality is that it does not matter. What matters is that they have millions of loyal customers that other companies envy.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by megablast on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:50PM (#1496307)
Well, this is the problem. Microsoft can fritter away billions of dollars on these projects that do not have to have a return. This is why there stock price has not been doing well, because people do not see them producing any more winners.

There attempts in search reek of desperation, paying people to use Bing. Xbox is just now starting to pay off. They have lost mobile. They are losing market share in their webserver and development tools.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by hga on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:14PM (#1496232)
I don't think we can't judge the success of Microsoft by Windows 7 sales since it followed the Vista debacle.

This article said Microsoft wouldn't go extinct for decades, but it would still be pretty ugly in the meanwhile if it followed IBM's mainframe path. Especially since Windows is a lot less alien that that ecosystem, porting is much more of an option.

As a side note, IBM mainframes were massively innovative in their day. System 360 defined the 8 bit oriented CPU approach, there's virtualization (the real OSes haven't been able to boot on bare metal for a long time), there's something to be said for their channel IO architecture (although they regret not making them full fledged CPUs), etc. etc. And they're rock solid and generally responsible about that mission, something Sun notably stumbled on.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by tvon on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:11PM (#1496113)
> The stark truth is that Microsoft has rarely invented anything that mattered.

That doesn't matter, what matters is that lately their execution has sucked.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by troygoode on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:42PM (#1496154)
I think this is largely true, but Microsoft is large enough that it really isn't a single entity - the various divisions are outputting different levels of suckiness/goodness. For instance:

DevDiv is on a pretty good roll right now. It is still many steps behind other communities in a lot of regards (and likely always will be), but LINQ was a huge milestone in 3.5 and the new dynamic integration options of 4.0 is a big step forward for a mainstream static language.

The XBox division continues to do cool things. Last year's dashboard revamp was a huge face lift for the system, XBox Live may continue to be a wretched hive of scum and villainy but it is a well-implemented one. I'm skeptical of Kinect's value for the type of games I play, but I believe it'll be very popular amongst casuals and should be a compelling addition to the XBox's UI for non-gaming apps. Oh, and the "instant-on" 1080p streaming of pay-per-view and Netflix movies is really sick and feels like living in the future.

The Zune may always be an niche choice, but its the best option if you'd prefer to spend $15/mo for "unlimited" music rather than purchasing music at $10/album. Which situation makes the most sense will vary from person to person. Last year Zune started handing out 10 song credits per month to each subscriber as well, which helped take the sting out of the normal arguments against subscription services.

I don't particularly follow the Windows Phone 7 / Kin stuff, but it seems obvious they screwed up royally on at least half that proposition (and I don't expect big things out of the Win Phone 7 half either).

Windows 7 has been very well perceived, though it still lags behind Linux/OSX.

Office 2007 was a pretty good redesign of the suite, but Office 2010 doesn't seem to have raised the bar much. I don't think OpenOffice will ever replace MS Office, rather Office will continue to lead until GoogleDocs is fully ready to take over (its getting closer & closer every day and I don't think MS's new web-based Office will be able to compete).

In retrospect, after reviewing what I've written so far, my opinion seems to be that Microsoft's offerrings haven't been that bad execution-wise lately, but that most are plagued by the fact that they are "also rans": decent products that have some strong merits, but offer no compelling reason to leave the market leader or community favorite.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by Niten on Thursday July 08, 2010 @12:44AM (#1496509)
> Windows 7 has been very well perceived, though it still lags behind Linux/OSX.

Lags behind in what sense?

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by troygoode on Thursday July 08, 2010 @10:08AM (#1497357)
Background: I'm a .NET developer in a Windows shop by day, and run OSX on most of my computers at home (except my primary desktop which is Win7 for gaming and .NET development).

My major pain points on Windows that lag behind Linux/OSX:

- Scripting. PowerShell is getting there, and is fine for system related tasks, but it remains a second-class citizen.

- Application Installation. No apt-get; no simple dragging an app into the Apps folder. Same for uninstallation.

- Security. I don't hate UAC nearly as much as everyone else seems to, but give me sudo any day. I'm also concerned by reports I've read of how easy it is for malicious software to get around UAC.

- Settings/Configuration. Control Panel is still a cluster fuck and every app on my computer seems to have a different route to their custom config screen.

- Startup. Yes I know about msconfig, but my wife certainly doesn't, nor does my mother.

I don't hate Windows. I make my livelihood from it, use it all day with little complaint (Win7 is my favorite Windows version since Win2000), and its clearly the only real choice for PC gaming (I have like 3 games for my Macs via Steam). That doesn't mean I am or should be blind to where it falls behind its competitors.

For what its worth, I have the same feeling about .NET: I use it, love it, make money off it, have fun with it; but I'm not blind to its faults.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by endtime on Thursday July 08, 2010 @01:27AM (#1496575)
>Office 2007 was a pretty good redesign of the suite, but Office 2010 doesn't seem to have raised the bar much.

I don't know if you use Outlook (I'm guessing not) but Outlook 2010's handling of threading makes it a huge improvement over 2007, IMO.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by troygoode on Thursday July 08, 2010 @09:57AM (#1497307)
I do use Office. I'm a dev in a ".NET shop" and the org is Windows all the way around so I most certainly do use Office.

That said, I'm not using Office for anything fancy: lots and lots of Outlook, some basic Word-based requirements docs, a bunch of Excel, and the rare Powerpoint. I also have a pretty monster rig at work, and never had any performance problems with 2007. I upgraded to 2010 during beta and am running the release right now. I like it (the UI improvements in Outlook are nice), but it doesn't strike me as a "must have" upgrade over 2007. It _certainly_ isn't an upgrade I would've spent $100+ of my _own_ money on.

I use GoogleDocs at home for personal use.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by endtime on Thursday July 08, 2010 @05:42PM (#1498880)
Fair enough. The threading is the killer feature for me, but I guess the value of that varies with personal preference.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by dasil003 on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:43PM (#1496155)
Yeah I was just gonna quote that line as well. Nowadays invention is often meaningless anyway since there are so many ideas and mashups floating around. And even when it does matter, it has little correlation with success.

In any case, Microsoft's success was based on innovation in the business model, and they've done a lot of innovation with their software over the years.

The real problem with Microsoft if the insider stories are anything to go by is that it's full of bureaucratic middle management self-sabotaging with no real leadership. All you have to do is listen to Steve Ballmer bluster his way through an interview to realize that being a good sales guy in no way confers the ability lead a technology company.

However Microsoft still has a ton of successful products and great people. I imagine if they were to do some kind of massive internal housecleaning and layoff of underperforming and territorial middle management based on interviews of the rank and file that they could restore quite a bit of their product development savvy overnight.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by ojbyrne on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:36PM (#1496281)
I think Microsoft's biggest innovation was not a thing but a process, and it that served them very well for most of their history. Namely "fast follow" - the ability to take a competitor's product and very quickly produce their own, better version. DOS, Windows 3, Word, Excel, MSVC++, Internet Explorer, etc. etc.

Windows 7 seems noticeably absent from the list of stuff the R&D department produced.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by sen on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:01PM (#1496099)
Toyota didn't invent the wheel, are they dying now?

Apple didn't invent the phone, is the iPhone a flop and will Apple die next?

And MS hasn't made anything in the last few years that is worthy of mentioning? What about Windows 7, love it or hate it, it's the fastest selling OS in history.

Inventing something isn't a sign of success. Taking an idea, whether it has already been invented or not, then creating the best (or at least the most popular) iteration of that idea, is what matters. I'm no Microsoft fan-boy (I use Linux, have an Android phone, although I do own and love my Xbox 360 to be fair).. but even I can't deny Microsoft's ability to consistently churn out some pretty amazing products (yes, and their fair share of flops too.. but no-one is immune to that.. Apple Newton anyone?).

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by alanh on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:49PM (#1496174)
Those are bad examples that miss the point.

• Toyota brought hybrids to market.

• Apple elevated cellphones to a completely new level, inventing underlying technology along the way.

I consider both to be bold, innovative moves. I think you are defining "invention" far too narrowly. Edit: Name a single completely new "invention" from software industries. Nothing? Then stop being so pedantic.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by sen on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:13PM (#1496230)
I'm talking about his statement that companies that don't "invent", don't last.

Toyota didn't "invent" the Hybrid, if anything that's another case that perfectly proves my point.. Toyota took an existing invention, the Hybrid car, and created a brilliant marketable implementation of that pre-existing idea.

Apple didn't "invent" the touch screen, multi touch, the cell phone, or any of the other stuff that makes the iPhone such a good phone. It just once again took pre-existing ideas and created a brilliant marketable implementation of the combined ideas into a product that has netted them billions of dollars.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by tvon on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:14PM (#1496118)
Far, far too much emphasis has been put on invention/innovation/originality lately. Doing something well is (generally) more important than doing something new. IMO, anyway.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by alanh on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:57PM (#1496195)
“The first, the best, or the free.” New Microsoft products seem to be none of the above lately, including the Zune, their phones, and their consoles (though there, “best” is at least debatable).

Office and Windows are effectively “first” because they have incredible traction.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by barryfandango on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:22PM (#1496247)
The Windows 7 Phone OS has been hyping up for a while now and won't be out for till the holidays, so who knows, but it looks fantastic.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by d0m on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:11PM (#1496228)
I've got friends that work there and they have so many great technologies and products that they don't publish. I have no idea why but if you have time, go look at microsoft research center.. I mean, what are they waiting ?!
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by pohl on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @11:12PM (#1496355)
I rarely have something positive to say about Microsoft. I was a customer until the early 90s when I decided the Open Systems world was more appealing. My disgust only increased over the years as it became well-nigh impossible to navigate a Microsoft-free career path in the shadow of the behemoth.

Oddly, though, I found myself realizing just today that when Kinect comes out that I want to buy an Xbox 360 (which are finally quiet enough thanks to a 45nm process) just to play EA Sports Active 2.0. It's crazy how things change.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by gfodor on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:41PM (#1496150)
Project Natal. Nuff said.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by gfodor on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:53PM (#1496183)
Why the downvotes? The thesis of this article is that Microsoft is incapable of innovation.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by InclinedPlane on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:05PM (#1496210)
It's not enough said, but it is a reasonable counterpoint. MS is taking a big risk with kinect/natal, one of the biggest they've taken in a long while.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by hga on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @08:21PM (#1496023)
Hmmm, has Microsoft "rarely invented anything that mattered"?
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by i80and on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @08:34PM (#1496050)
The problem isn't that they're not inventing stuff; that R&D money isn't just spent on paperclips, and a lot of interesting stuff comes out as a result. The problem is that the inventions get squished, not released.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by hga on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:01PM (#1496206)
Well, there's F#, and they support the reference Haskell compiler. But the more we learn about how totally political the D part of the company is the more we're likely to believe your thesis that Microsoft Research's notable lack of impact on the greater company is due to the latter. And they don't have Xerox's excuse!

Heck, they're so messed up they almost destroyed one of their foundational cash cows (Windows with the Vista debacle), which would have killed another (Office). A commentator to Mini-Microsoft's previous blog item claimed that the Windows group engineers are now required to fill out by the hour time sheets. The mind boggles ... even if that's not true, the fact that it's believable says enough.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by sukuriant on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @08:57PM (#1496091)
That's not entirely true. In fact, there was an article on HackerNews just the other day about one of the developments that their research department came up with. It substantially reduced the number of blue screens that occurred. Other research that has come from Microsoft R&D is the new camera used in their newest xbox peripherals.

Not everything is squished.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by csomar on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:07PM (#1496213)
Microsoft is not innovative, but does that matter? Does Offices with bureaucratic rules need innovation?

Microsoft sells Windows and Office because companies don't like the cloud (less stable, speed, privacy) and don't like Apple (expensive, re-education of employees...). So Microsoft products are a good solution.

Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by borisk on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:30PM (#1496138)
Ha, did MS invent Basic, DOS, word processing, electronic spreadsheets, GUI? billg was the king of execution. After he moved from managing the company to working on the antimonopoly case MS lost direction and now behaves like a typical Fortune 500 corporation.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by zaphar on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:52PM (#1496309)
This article assumes microsoft will never improve its management structure. This may be true but is pure speculation on the authors part. A lot can happen in decades and MS had the cash to spend while working it out.
Re:Is Microsoft Headed Towards Extinction? by c00p3r on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @11:21PM (#1496367)
Isn't it obvious since 2003?