Where did you get this? Some direct quotes from the article, emphasis added:
"…human activities, especially emissions of greenhouse (heat-trapping) gases, are primarily responsible for recent observed climate change."
"…it is possible to attribute some extreme weather to climate change."
"…significant advances have been made linking human influence to individual extreme weather events since the last National Climate Assessment was produced in 2014. Still, it notes, crucial uncertainties remain."
"…“relatively strong evidence” showed that a man-made factor contributed to the extreme weather."
"Worldwide, the draft report finds it “extremely likely” that more than half of the global mean temperature increase since 1951 can be linked to human influence."
"Human activity, the report goes on to say, is a primary culprit."
Nothing here comes close to asserting that the change is entirely man-made. In fact, the article is quite careful to avoid saying that, over and over again.
This doesn't require an especially close reading to discover. Rather, you would have to go out of your way to distort what the article is saying in order to reach the conclusion that you did.
FWIW, I doubt you're engaging in this distortion on purpose. More likely it's a subconscious reaction to encountering information that you don't want to be true.
The New York Times has made the 545 page report available (https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/08/07/climate/docum...) and at a passing glance, it contains oodles of data. The article links to it.
Lisa said that mean temperatures rose, then mentioned that President Trump and his cabinet have said that "the human contribution is uncertain", that report (which I have read in its entirety) does not detail any way in which the (degree of) human contribution to climate change is "certain". The document has a helpful rubric for what they would consider "Virtually Certain" or "Extremely Likely" on page 9.
I'm just not satisfied with the link between the two clauses in that paragraph. One does not imply the other.
"It is extremely likely that most of the global mean temperature increase since 1951 was caused by human influence (high confidence)"
Page 13, line 21. That uses the terms defined in the rubric you noted.
That's in direct contrast to the cabinet quote ("uncertain").
If that's the case, then wouldn't it already be born out in other widely available temperature datasets?
It is. Really.
There's even a nice dataset on Kaggle you can play with if you like: https://www.kaggle.com/berkeleyearth/climate-change-earth-su...
If you have data to back up your points, show the data
The data is linked, and there is plenty more data out there.
Enjoy.
Source observations are provided as originally reported and will contain many quality control and redundancy issues. Intermediate data is constructed from the source data by merging redundant records, identifying a variety of quality control problems, and creating monthly averages from daily reports when necessary.
You can choose to use breakpoint adjusted or not, the data is all there.
That was my point, Lisa presented this fact as though it's unique to the report. In this case, it's just background data, because anyone can look at temperature trends and let out a giant DUH when asked if the mean temperatures are rising.
So you agree climate change is real and significant? Edit: Because plenty do deny that, although I agree they aren't credible. Your initial, unedited reply read just like that.
And you are just angry that the NYTimes posted that this report might not be released? Or something?
Apologies for the bad first draft, maybe it should have been embargoed. ;- )
> And you are just angry that the NYTimes posted that this report might not be released? Or something?
I'm unhappy with the tone and tenor of discussions and presentations of climate issues. The part that "97%" of climate scientists agree on is not disputed by the President or his Cabinet.
The agreement is basically a) that the global mean temperature has increased dramatically, b) that atmospheric carbon dioxide increase has almost certainly had an effect, and finally c) that humans have sufficiently affected the amount of atmospheric carbon dioxide to consider that these emissions account for a measurable portion of the temperature increase.
Almost everything else is very much up for debate, and when people present some additional assertions as verified fact, the curious people notice that they're being dishonest, and wonder what else they're being dishonest about.
For example, Neil DeGrasse Tyson once quite regularly told people that if the ice caps melt, the water level will be above the elbow of the statue of liberty. As far as I can tell, this does not match the models, it doesn't make sense, and it makes everything these public "science guy" types say utterly suspect.
The gripe I was hoping (and failing) to get across was that even a subtle misrepresentation or overstatement can cast doubt on your entire presentation. This, I think, is a common and grave mistake of people who present on issues which appear to divide people. When combined with smugness, any (otherwise factual) presentation can instantly convert mildly curious people into rebels.
Not sure what your problem is here. The Statue of Liberty is 90M tall, and if Antarctica and Greenland melt then estimates are that sea level will rise between 60M and 70M.
It's unknown how likely the icecap melt is, but plenty of scenarios lead to significant ice-cap break up by 2100.
- I think that paragraph is a little confusing. It might be better as "It _also_ directly contradicts claims" - ie the first sentence is not tied to the second sentence, even though I could see how it might at first read that way.
The article is not a jab at the Trump administration, it warns the reader that such a report exists, and that it may not be approved for publication by the administration, which, you may admit could be problematic.
Recent decades are likely the warmest in 1500 years. What data opposes this view?
If that's the case, then wouldn't it already be born out in other widely available temperature datasets? No credible person denies that the global (and U.S. local) mean temperature has increased, this is not news.
> The draft report by scientists from 13 federal agencies, which has not yet been made public, concludes that Americans are feeling the effects of climate change right now. It directly contradicts claims by President Trump and members of his cabinet who say that the human contribution to climate change is uncertain, and that the ability to predict the effects is limited.
These are entirely separate claims. The author of the article is saying that the United States are warmer; then implying that the change is entirely man-made and detrimental to make a political point (in this case, a hit against President Trump, though I suppose it's a step in the right direction that NYT are now allowed to refer to the President as the President). (Edit: I should clarify that I'm talking about the link between the two clauses in this paragraph, which makes it seem like one supports the other when this is not the case)
> and that the ability to predict the effects is limited.
It is limited, the report details the limits, as do many other great sources. The climate models we have are about as good as the economic models; that is to say, they're basically useless for genuine predictions. They do not fit historic data without piles of corrections, some of which are dubious. There is work to be done.
If you have data to back up your points, show the data. If you are making a point which is not supported by the data, don't use slight of hand to make it seem like it is.
The reason that there are so many people skeptical about the alarming claims, is because the presentations have been so dishonest and manipulative. Public figures frequently grossly overstate the certainty of statements which are not really settled, and some climate scientists and academic administrators have been caught basically ganging up on people who do not present alarming news.
I understand why some of you feel, as Fej says elsewhere in this thread, that "At this point, mass panic might be more effective than mass ignorance.", but it's important that we be honest in presenting what we know to the public.
Every time you present an opinion as a fact, somebody somewhere no longer trusts you, and those people will be vocal and active in letting people know that you've been dishonest.