- Underrepresented groups are by default less qualified than average
- Hiring decisionmakers are incapable of assessing people objectively enough to overcome inherent biases
Are there other possible consistent implications? Honest question.
It seems to me either scenario is fundamentally toxic.
Quotas are a crude tool but I'd rather see something like that than simply accept a world with a cycle of the powerful remaining powerful in large part due to the less powerful never having opportunity.
You don't need any wealth to enter university. You just need to be smart and get good grades.
Family wealth plays no factor what so ever.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.forbes.com/sites/eriksherma...
If you come from a disadvantaged position, you have to be better to succeed, not equal. White men don't have it easy but they have it less hard.
But merit is just a table stake and never goes far on its own. Nobody is supposing that companies are occupied by a bunch of white cabbages (although the fact that googleboy got any support really does make me wonder as he was so intellectually vacuous). And it's ingrained into our culture that white men take the top jobs right through business, culture and arts, science, and politics - so the danger is we see it as 'how things are' and assume it's evolved for the best.
But it's completely optional and man-made, and ultimately a political choice, 1. not to have a level playing field when it comes to equality of opportunity and 2. to stack it in that direction. The reality is that tech companies led by women do better and the biggest indicator of ending up poor is having the misfortune to be born poor, so society at large isn't going to fall in by redressing the balance.
And no, fixing a racist and sexist system isn't racism or sexism. The issue many people have here is that they don't recognise it as institutionally racist and sexist in the first place. That's because they are the beneficiaries of the system and cannot see it (I know how hard it is to see past that as I'm one too, and this is why I mention the Blub paradox). You are absolutely right to look at the the figures and point out the number of Asians. We need to check the figures because we can't be objective by just going off our feels (we are a great bunch of guys and love and respect women and don't have a racist bone in our bodies etc). It's a systemic issue, very rarely a personal one (although of course it's personal to all those who are disadvantaged by it).
http://truewealthvc.com/women-led-businesses-outperform/
btw I believe that comparing someone to a Nazi is against the conduct rules of HN and can earn you a shadowban
No, actually quite the opposite.
When a company/university/country enshrines diversity quotas, they are basically telling minorities that they are by default stupider than average.
Also, enforcing these diversity quotas will create a (probably valid) impression that minority members who make it anywhere did not do so on their own merit.
As a minority I would much rather know there are no diversity programs so that I know that where ever I get, it's based on my merit, not some charity. Even if I was the only one in the room from my ethnic origin (which is actually often the case).