I don't think there is anything representative of an employee's quality of work that can be done during a short interview that would have a strong correlate to productivity and quality. I think a real-world take-home problem followed by a meeting-style presentation of your work, your solution, and a Q&A about the implementation with a representative subset of your peers would be better as this would actually be representative of the work load at hand at the company.

the basis of the question its self invalidates middle ground