News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slight Street Sign Modifications Can Fool Machine Learnin... by mannykannot on Saturday August 05, 2017 @11:29AM (#14936175)
The fragility of AI decision-making in general absolutely is an issue. Feel free to post a submission when it has been solved to a level that matches or exceeds human capabilities.
Re:Slight Street Sign Modifications Can Fool Machine Learnin... by rm999 on Saturday August 05, 2017 @02:17PM (#14937059)
I build AI/ML systems for a living and it's not as big of a deal as you think. Production machine learning systems built by experienced teams will almost always have business logic protections built-in to stop the machine from doing something totally stupid. For example, an auto-bidder may have capped velocities or auto-shutoff mechanisms (those examples of bidders spending billions of dollars in minutes are exceedingly sloppy).

This is not unlike the human body's deeply-evolved reflexes - before the neocortex can even process that a pan is boiling hot, the nervous system bypasses the brain and and tells the hands to drop it.

In the case of driverless cars, DannyBee is absolutely correct: truly driverless cars will not make decisions from a single data point. I have some past experience with unmanned aerial vehicles and those things had insane amounts of redundancy in almost every signal and decision making process; driverless cars are more complex and will come decades later and will probably take this even further.

Re:Slight Street Sign Modifications Can Fool Machine Learnin... by oneshot908 on Saturday August 05, 2017 @03:46PM (#14937521)
As another such practitioner, why oh why would we ignore hard-learned unambiguous signals and wisdom because we jumped on the machine learning bandwagon? We embraced machine learning to detect and uncover the things we don't see, not to replace the things we already know. There's no conflict here whatsoever.
Re:Slight Street Sign Modifications Can Fool Machine Learnin... by mannykannot on Saturday August 05, 2017 @04:43PM (#14937804)
> Production machine learning systems built by experienced teams will almost always have business logic protections built-in to stop the machine from doing something totally stupid.

In the case of driving, however, the problem of deciding what behavior to veto is itself a hard problem - perhaps the hardest of all. When the system monitoring the AI is itself AI, the argument becomes circular - which is not to say it cannot be solved, but I think it makes it harder to dismiss the concerns.

[dead]
Re:Slight Street Sign Modifications Can Fool Machine Learnin... by dboreham on Saturday August 05, 2017 @01:52PM (#14936910)
Let's start with Spam : filtering it out with 100% guarantee of no false positives has still not been achieved.
Re:Slight Street Sign Modifications Can Fool Machine Learnin... by MR4D on Saturday August 05, 2017 @09:43PM (#14939210)
But also true of humans. In fact, I would guess I that advanced spam filtering engines might be _better_ than the average human. Remember, the Nigerian scammers are still around because someone is dumb enough to still give them money.