News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by pyroinferno on Friday August 04, 2017 @03:50PM (#14931555)
Yes, take this for an example, if someone were to deliberately sell firearms to someone that they knew would attempt to murder someone with their firearm, do you think they should be partially liable for the murder?
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by comicjk on Friday August 04, 2017 @04:38PM (#14932047)
Yes, the seller would legally be an accessory to the murder, having had knowledge that the crime would be committed and having helped the murderer commit it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accessory_(legal_term)

Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by meowface on Saturday August 05, 2017 @12:12AM (#14934179)
Then shouldn't Hutchins legally be an accessory to uses of the malware to steal money, surveil unsuspecting victims, etc. if it is true that he knowingly sold it to people who do such things?
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by comicjk on Saturday August 05, 2017 @07:43PM (#14938689)
He might be able to get out of it by arguing that he didn't know about any particular crime they would commit, or that he thought they had good faith reasons to buy the software despite being criminals in general. I think this hinges on exactly what he knew.
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by meowface on Saturday August 05, 2017 @08:11PM (#14938834)
Yes, absolutely. The burden is on the government to prove he knew who he was selling it to and that he knew what they were very likely going to use it for.
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by watty on Friday August 04, 2017 @04:19PM (#14931884)
Firearms are legal. If you create an illegal firearm (banking trojan), and did the same, yes - you'd be partially liable.
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by syshum on Friday August 04, 2017 @03:56PM (#14931632)
No.
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by KGIII on Friday August 04, 2017 @09:48PM (#14933811)
I'm a pretty big fan of firearms. I disagree. If you had knowledge before hand, of the crime, and a reasonable expectation, you are culpable, to some percentage.

The law usually agrees with me, if that helps.

Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by syshum on Friday August 04, 2017 @10:03PM (#14933850)
I does not, the vast majority of the law I disagree with

See I can not support the concept of 3rd party lability. I should only ever be responsible for my actions, not the actions of others, and I have no responsibility or obligation to stop any crime.

Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by josefx on Saturday August 05, 2017 @05:49AM (#14934982)
> and I have no responsibility or obligation to stop any crime.

You don't have to ask someone if he wants to commit a crime, so that is not the problem. It is when someone explicitly asks for your help in commiting a crime and you think to yourself "yes I want to be complicit in this" that lands you in legal trouble.

If someone asks you for a handgun to kill someone you don't have to stop him, you just aren't allowed to aid him.

I really don't understand how you people seem to be under the impression that not going out of your way to help criminals takes more effort than not. I am more under the impression that you would pull the trigger on your on grandmother if it made you money, since it is not you but the blodloss that finally does her in - degrees of seperation and all that.

Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by syshum on Saturday August 05, 2017 @07:09AM (#14935197)
Generally I oppose these types of laws because they are never used for the rare cases where Joe says John "hey John hand me your handgun so I can kill my wife"

Instead most often these types of laws are used to prosecute people under a "should have known" scenario.

Examples of real situations of 3rd party liability that have been used to send people to prison

1. Jim takes a friend to a bank, the friend goes in and robs the bank. Jim though the friend was just withdrawing some money from his account but Jim is arrested and convicted of aiding his friend in the robbery

2. Jane does not have a license, a police officer attempts to stop Jane, Jane panics and runs from the police. The Police officer runs through a red light while in pursuit and kills a bystander, Jane is charged with murder.

Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by mdpopescu on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:51PM (#14934127)
I wish there was a way to flag a user as "favorite"... so far I agree with all your comments on this page :)
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by devhead on Friday August 04, 2017 @06:55PM (#14933043)
lets take away the feelings by saying...

if someone were to deliberately sell a pair of shoes to someone that they new would attempt to j-walk with their shoes, do you think they should be partially liable for the j-walking?

> no.

Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by kakarot on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:20PM (#14934045)
sentencing is based around severity, change the severity of the situation and we are no longer talking about the same thing.
Re:Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through securit... by devhead on Monday August 07, 2017 @03:23PM (#14950411)
comment replied to raised the discussion to firearms and murder, which isn't the same as code that is designed to reveal flaws in software.