News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by hugh3 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @01:57PM (#1491744)
Pretty much exactly what that guy from Mad Money predicted would happen.

I wouldn't invest in Tesla. Either electric cars take off or they don't, but if they do then the big car companies can easily muscle in and eat Tesla's lunch. Nissan and Chevy both have electric cars coming out soon which will present a much better value proposition than the Tesla Model S.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by phreeza on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:40PM (#1491899)
By that logic, no startup that somehow touches on established players markets would be worth doing.

A bit like saying Writely should never have built a web-based text processor because Microsoft can "easily muscle in" and eat their lunch.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by hugh3 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @03:11PM (#1492021)
What I should have said is that the car industry, unlike the software industry, has huge advantages for big players (due to the enormous capital cost of... well, nearly everything), and small advantages for first movers (due to the near-nonexistent network effects).
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by jbooth on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @03:38PM (#1492108)
Yeah, but the product cycle is 2-4 years. Plenty of time for you to get rich by being bought out by the big guys to accelerate time to market, or by land-grabbing a decent market share in that window before they catch up to you.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by nostrademons on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @03:36PM (#1492104)
That's largely true.

Writely and Word are in different markets - the market for web-based cloud word processors is very different than the one for full-featured desktop word processors. Same goes for most of the web startups that have succeeded.

Somebody is inevitably going to bring up Google, since there were established players in search when Google was founded. But at the time of Google's founding, all the established players in search thought that their business was in portals, leaving the search market itself open for a hungry competitor.

Clayton Christensen has more on this in The Innovator's Dilemma/Solution. Innovations that make things better for an established market's existing customers tend to be sustaining innovations, benefiting entrenched players. Even if a startup gets a foothold on one, they can and will be bought out or outcompeted by a big firm, which has more resources and every incentive to pour them into development.

Innovations that make things better for a new and untapped customer base, however, tend to be disruptive innovations, the sort of which new successful startups are made. The defining characteristic of disruptive innovations is that they're less profitable than sustaining innovations: therefore, at every point in time, the large entrenched competitors have every incentive not to succeed in the startup's market. Things like the PC for IBM, the web for Microsoft, free online access for newspapers, and search for Altavista.

Note that in all cases, those companies did enter the new market, they just didn't succeed in it. Because it was not in the company's interest to succeed: A success would mean that the company's overall profit is less than it started with, which is awfully hard to justify to shareholders.

I'm not entirely sure which category Tesla fits into, but I'm having a tough time seeing a $109k roadster and $57k sedan as disruptive innovations, which usually target cheaper market segments that big companies overlook as unprofitable.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by pchristensen on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @04:27PM (#1492250)
I pretty much agree, just one more thing to add. Disruptive innovations are more about the market and business model than the technology itself. That's why relatively crappy inventions can take root.

For instance, PCs were not good compared to mainframes or workstations, but they were bought by people that weren't buying workstations. This gave them the chance to build businesses and improve until they could later compete with, and displace workstations.

For Tesla, what is the disruptive market? I'm not sure. Their cars do the same things as other cars, with different inputs. If their "disruptive" niche is to be an eco-fashion symbol, and that gives them time to build a car whose TCO is 20+% less because of the difference in fuel cost per mile, then they have a shot.

For what could truly be disruptive to personal transportation is Better Place ( http://www.wired.com/cars/futuretransport/magazine/16-09/ff_... ). Sure, it's expensive, limited, and poor right now, but if it can work in Israel, Denmark, and Hawaii, and prove and grow the business from there, it can change things in a much bigger way than Tesla can.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by eru on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @05:45PM (#1492503)
You can sell electric cars on subscription where the customers pays per km driven. That might be a disruptive business model. Some companies are already doing so.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by dgreensp on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @11:44PM (#1493244)
I agree with some of your points, but I think "avoid competition / competitors' markets" is a fallacy and bad advice.

Successful companies succeed in the face of competition, and capitalize on some opportunity, which could be a technology, a market shift, a business model, or a partnership. You can often turn this "seizing a (unique) opportunity" truism into a "looking where others didn't" story in hindsight, and start getting excited about real "off the map" innovations, as if there's something inherently good about that, business-wise. In Google's case they simply came up with a better business model, though their tech strength helped.

Altavista was a search company. Google didn't succeed by not stepping on Altavista's toes in the "portal market" (which I'm sure is entirely distinct from the web search market), they just built a better search business.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by nostrademons on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @01:05AM (#1493372)
Successful companies succeed by picking their competition carefully. You want to compete with firms that either don't know or don't care about your customers' use case, so that you can bring more resources to bear on this particular problem than they can.

Altavista was a search company, but in the late 90s, they didn't particularly care about search. If they did, they could easily have copied PageRank (which was published, and the patent is owned by Stanford anyway) and search ads (which were done by Overture before Google) and done as well as Google did. They didn't realize that it was a threat until Google started making serious inroads in the early 2000s, though, and by then it was too late. (Interestingly, both of the founders of Altavista ended up working at Google.)

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by huhtenberg on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:33PM (#1491867)
> muscle in and eat Tesla's lunch

This would largely depend on whether Tesla would strive to become a mainstream car maker or would choose to retain its focus on building luxury/exotic cars. Think Aston Martin kind of company.

Though they have already announced an average-priced sedan version that was scheduled for mass production in 2012, so I guess they are going after the behemoths.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by hugh3 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:54PM (#1491955)
Luxury and exotic cars is a terrible business to be in. Small-volume supercar manufacturers pop in and out of existence every few years, leaving behind tiny production runs of awesome-looking machines and no spare parts.

The only luxury/exotic car manufacturers which have survived are the ones which managed to pick up enough of a history to be bought out by a much larger mass-market brand as a halo. afaik they mostly operate at a loss. Bentley, Lamborghini and Bugatti belong to VW. Ferrari is Fiat. Lotus is Proton, and Rolls-Royce gets passed around like a cheap hooker. Only Aston Martin is currently owned by someone other than another car company, but that may not last.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by huhtenberg on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @04:06PM (#1492190)
> afaik they mostly operate at a loss

As much as I trust your "afaik", I find it very hard to believe. For example, the "cheap hooker" raked £593m of profit in 2008 according to http://www.rolls-royce.com/investors/news/2009/300709_2009_h...

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by hugh3 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @04:30PM (#1492259)
That's Rolls-Royce plc, the publicly-listed company that mostly makes aircraft engines, not Rolls-Royce Motor Cars, the completely unrelated subsidiary of BMW that makes... well, motor cars.

The history of the two is awfully complicated, but I gather that they've been separate entities since 1973.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by shin_lao on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @03:16PM (#1492039)
What about Porsche, BMW and Mercedes?

Any business is good to be in - provided you're good enough. There's no such thing as easy money.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by eru on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @03:34PM (#1492100)
Porsche was recently pulled into VW, though Porsche nearly succeeded in buying VW earlier. Mercedes and BMW (but especially Mercedes) are more upper middle class than truly luxury.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by brc on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @05:27PM (#1492442)
Porsche was the most profitable car company in the world prior to the VW takeover debacle.

Ironically, though, it was mostly from selling SUVs instead of sports cars. Which just shows that selling overpriced oversized ego vehicles is the best way to make money in the car business.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by hugh3 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @05:41PM (#1492492)
Low-end luxury seems to be very profitable, as those three companies demonstrate. They're comfortably away from the cost-cutting at the bottom of the market, but still accessible to a large number of customers.

It was the really high-end cars ($100K+) I was talking about as apparently being unprofitable.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by shin_lao on Friday July 09, 2010 @10:32AM (#1500710)
Mercedes and BMW manufacture and sell cars in the price range you are talking about.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by keltex on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:38PM (#1491887)
You mean the Aston Martin that was part of Ford until 2007?

Ford still own a portion of and to which they contribute the parts and engineering know how.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by sbov on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:54PM (#1491954)
Last I heard the model S was going to start at 49k. That definitely is in the luxury car price range, and not competition with toyota/nissan/etc.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by timwiseman on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @05:20PM (#1492416)
If Tesla develops relatively good technology and a good patent portfolio then it is much more likely that they would get purchased than simply be out competed. If they are purchased while on the path to success it is likely that the founders and many early investors will make a very nice sum in the process.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by neurotech1 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:23PM (#1491831)
Don't forget that Toyota has a stake in Tesla, and they are a big car company. It's not inconceivable that Toyota could assist in distribution, as it doesn't directly compete against the Prius.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by hugh3 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:38PM (#1491889)
Or they could say "thanks for the technology, suckers!", write off their piddly $50 million investment in Tesla, and start cranking out electric Corollas from a factory in Yokohama and/or Guangzhou.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by eru on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @05:47PM (#1492510)
While this outcome would not be very glamorous, I'd might still be worthwhile for the founders.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by ghurlman on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:36PM (#1491880)
It wouldn't surprise me one bit if down the road Tesla became a Toyota-owned & operated brand, much like Scion is today.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by bdlang on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:13PM (#1491794)
I don't believe the IPO is about the model S; it's about ramping up to build a sub 30K (or was it 20K) model at the newly acquired plant in Nor Cal, partnered with Toyota.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by jaekwon on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:26PM (#1491842)
citations? I thought it was about the model S, e.g. model S _is_ their consumer model.

wikipedia: "On May 20, 2010 Tesla Motors announced it would form a partnership with Toyota to produce a new lower-priced model along with the Model S at the former NUMMI assembly plant in Fremont, California.[6]"

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by joshfinnie on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:39PM (#1491897)
I am confused by our comment, jaekwon. It seems as though you are asking for proof and then give it. Maybe I am just misunderstanding, but the wikipedia quote does state that there is a new model along with the Model S.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by jaekwon on Thursday July 08, 2010 @01:06AM (#1496540)
You got me. I guess I skipped the words "along with" when scanning. To my credit, the cited link [6] tells nothing about a new lower-priced model other than the Model S.
Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by pavs on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:22PM (#1491827)
To the best of my knowledge, none of the big car manufacturers have any electric cars that is anywhere comparable to the mileage of Tesla. The second best option, Nissan Leaf, has less than half of Tesla's mileage.

Can anyone else verify this?

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by hugh3 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:33PM (#1491866)
I assume by "mileage" you mean "range"? But yes, the Leaf has a shorter range than the Tesla Roadster, and is also a lot cheaper. Price vs range is the basic tradeoff when building an electric car. Nissan could build a more expensive Leaf with a longer range if they thought there was a market for it.

I like the Chevy Volt's best-of-both-worlds solution, since it will do your sub-40-mile commute on electricity but still fire up its petrol-powered generator if you want to do hundreds of miles on the weekend. For an electric car, a zero risk of getting stranded is a huge selling point.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by ynniv on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:27PM (#1491848)
That may be true, but only because the Tesla Roadster has twice the battery capacity (53 kWh vs Leaf's 24 kWh). The Roadster battery costs about $36,000, which is more than the sticker price of a Leaf. The Roadster is supposed to get 21.7 kWh/100mi, which is about the same as the Leaf (22.5 kWh/100 mi) and the Volt (25 kWh/100 mi). Given the current (im)maturity of the electric car industry, I would say those numbers are too close to differentiate.

[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Roadster]

[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nissan_Leaf]

[http://www.businessinsider.com/theres-no-way-the-model-s-jus...]

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by mattmcknight on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @05:17PM (#1492411)
I did buy some, but I only sold about half when it was up 50%. I own a lot more of BYD, which is way up from when I got hold of it. I am still not sure the whole electric car concept makes sense yet.

One thing about plugin electrics that gets me though is that, for me, they switch from gasoline powered energy to coal power off of the grid, which would seem to be a bit more carbon-y.

Another slightly amusing negative is that the current Energy bill winding its way through congress looks like it is going to put a carbon tax on utilities (where the power for the cars would be paid) and not on gasoline, thus making it potentially more expensive for electric power than gas power (and making the scapegoat utility companies appear to be raising rates for customers while the politically unpopular gas tax is avoided.

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by bobbyi on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @02:57PM (#1491967)
> Pretty much exactly what that guy from Mad Money predicted would happen.

How so? Mad Money was bearish on Tesla as a company and so far since its IPO it is beating the market as a whole (the Nasdaq Comp and the S&P 500).

Re:Tesla stock is now back below its IPO price. by hugh3 on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @03:04PM (#1491988)
Well, he predicted a first-day bump followed by a long slide. There's still room for him to be proven wrong, though.