You'd have to go about that very carefully not to accidentally re-inforce a message that has already been planted and ending up making things worse rather than better.
I'm not sure what that means; doesn't every group have an agenda? I think the implication is that these groups' agendas are no better than any other groups' agendas. I think that's clearly wrong; we can't take politically correct relativism and openness to a logical extreme - we must make distinctions between good and bad (though carefully reasoned ones). Though I agree we should be careful, and no group or agenda is perfect, the agendas of hate groups are not just as good as the ADL's, for example.
> They shouldn't be allowed to block articles which disagree with their agenda.
Is that the standard used by Google?
I wouldn't say that there's a moral equivalence between the ADL's agenda (promoting Israel) and, say, Amnesty's agenda (ending torture & political imprisonment).
Amnesty got hit by the latest "fake news" google update:
https://mronline.org/2017/07/28/new-google-algorithm-restric...
Beyond that basic observation, I can't speak to the other groups, but to me, the degree of anti-Arab bias that the ADL exhibits is really appalling, and I have no confidence whatsoever in their ability to fairly filter the news for the masses.
The answer is no. This post is about YouTube. Presumably a magazine won't be impacted. Also, new content is not being removed, but rather:
"If we find that these videos don’t violate our policies but contain controversial religious or supremacist content, they will be placed in a limited state. The videos will remain on YouTube behind an interstitial, won’t be recommended, won’t be monetized, and won’t have key features including comments, suggested videos, and likes."
Which is ironically not dissimilar from your suggestion that hateful and ignorant views be taught in context to school children.
You comment reminds me of those news stories where the headline is a question. When you read the article, the answer is always, "No."
It's not an abstract issue, it actually happens.
Should we ban it?
Social psychiatric help and better public education are also necessary tools in this battle.
Here's Dabiq, ISIS's propaganda magazine.[1] It's well-produced and in English. See what the other side wants. There are the usual rants: "We ask Allah to support the mujāhidīn of the Islamic State against the agents of the tawāghīt and the crusaders until the banner of the Khilāfah is raised high above Istanbul and Vatican City". Their strongest ire is raised against Arabs who oppose ISIS. The West is just the enemy, but Islamists who oppose them are committing apostasy. They're opposed to democracy on principle. Allah must rule, and that means autocratic rule by religious leaders. "Legislation is not but for Allah".
There's a concern that some people will be taken in by this stuff. That's only a problem for people who haven't seen enough extremist material to be able to evaluate it. There's a certain similarity to all that stuff, along the lines of "We're good, because God is on our side, and we have to kill the other guys because they're evil." This message is available in Christian, Jewish, and Islamic flavors. Kids should see all of those in school, to immunize them against such messages.
Will "trusted flaggers" be allowed to make Dabiq inaccessable?
("Maybe they is not evil. Maybe they is just enemies." - Poul Anderson)
[1] https://clarionproject.org/islamic-state-isis-isil-propagand...