News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by lettergram on Monday July 31, 2017 @03:05AM (#14890027)
I don't really understand why the author of the article is worried about the CEO not being a woman... Seriously, who cares? It's not going to look good for who ever takes over and there are a lot less woman candidates. Uber will be lucky if it makes it to 2019 IMO.

Would give them 6 months, but half the valley invested in them.

Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by AJRF on Monday July 31, 2017 @04:24AM (#14890304)
Kara Swisher writes "Ew" in news articles. Her work is devoid of substance and just pushes an agenda that is populist and will get her likes from the largest group of people on Twitter
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by malandrew on Monday July 31, 2017 @01:09PM (#14893849)
There is no better evidence of her bias against Travis and Uber than how she conducted herself in her interview with Adam Lashinsky. Here's the full transcript:

https://www.recode.net/2017/7/16/15980006/transcript-journal...

She isn't a journalist. She's an activist pushing an agenda, facts-be-damned. Long gone are the day's of Walter Cronkite's "And that's the way it is."

Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by theseatoms on Monday July 31, 2017 @01:20PM (#14893977)
This is a much broader trend in contemporary media. The line between news and editorial has been all but erased.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by malandrew on Monday July 31, 2017 @01:41PM (#14894248)
Yes, I agree. However, it's one thing to occasionally give an opinion in the course of practicing journalism and something entirely different to steer the conversation towards the message you're trying to push. Kara wasn't even subtle about it this interview. Her bias was not just showing, but on full display for all to see.

It's really unfortunate because the individuals in the general population don't really get the facts and an opportunity to each come to slightly different conclusions. It's journalist malpractice to tell people what to think, since that's not journalism. That's propaganda.

Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by n72 on Monday July 31, 2017 @05:55AM (#14890629)
Yup, this doesn't contain any quotes from well placed sources or anything like that nor delivers any new information about, say, Meg Whitman's candidacy. Totally devoid of merit.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by n72 on Monday July 31, 2017 @05:52AM (#14890615)
I guess you just must have been momentarily distracted when you reached the part in the article in which she explicitly states why: "While gender of a leader should not matter to dispatching such appalling behaviors, the symbolism over the appointment of a female CEO at Silicon Valley’s most toxic-bro startup is unquestionable."
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by DoofusOfDeath on Monday July 31, 2017 @08:41AM (#14891358)
That quote seems to have some sexist elements itself.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by mlloyd on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:18AM (#14891622)
It doesn't when this entire drama is due to the company's sexist and toxic culture.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by humanrebar on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:56AM (#14891970)
The sexist part is the implication that every man is "bro" somehow... that only a female CEO could count as a symbolic change in leadership.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by dieterrams on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:41AM (#14892394)
That isn't being implied.

And an "unquestionable" symbolism is not the same as "the only possible" symbolism.

Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by humanrebar on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:55AM (#14892543)
The only unquestionable symbolism would be hiring a female CEO?
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by HelloMcFly on Monday July 31, 2017 @12:40PM (#14893523)
You're exhausting if only because you try to place the comments of others into a linguistic box of your own creation, not theirs.

There are undoubtedly many things Uber could do that would be "unquestionably symbolic." Hiring someone else with a history of sexual harassment would be unquestionably symbolic. Nowhere did anyone say that hiring a female CEO is the only unquestionably symbolic act they could do. But it is one of them, and in that hypothetical instance, the symbolism would be positive.

And no, it isn't the only unquestionably positive act they could do.

Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by untog on Monday July 31, 2017 @12:16PM (#14893259)
I don't see the implication at all. The culture of the company can be "bro" without every single employee being "bro". By your logic all the women working at Uber would also have to be "bro".
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by atom-morgan on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:54AM (#14891956)
sexism + sexism != sexism?
[dead]
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by HelloMcFly on Monday July 31, 2017 @12:44PM (#14893584)
I don't see anyone making that claim, but you are yet another commenter that feels they have to take any statement to their most extreme in order to challenge the conversation. And it's so commonly done in the same lazy way that at best charitably resembles the Socratic method, but at worst is just willful contrarianism.

Females are not incapable of being sexist. Nobody claimed that. In a culture alleged (with evidence) to be at least somewhat unfriendly towards women, a female CEO is likely to be better able to empathize with the issues and experiences women face. If one of your major concerns is to make the workplace more welcome for all, then it seems reasonable that a leader that comes from the class of workers who were not given a great experience is reasonable.

Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by asdfologist on Monday July 31, 2017 @01:26PM (#14894058)
Then where's the guarantee that men will be treated fairly? The main problem with your argument is the assumption that the gender of the leader will somehow make things better, and this line of thinking only contributes to the very sexism it aims to eliminate. Why not judge leaders by their track record, not the gender they were born into?
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by HelloMcFly on Monday July 31, 2017 @02:38PM (#14894746)
> Then where's the guarantee that men will be treated fairly?

Your immediate descent into victimhood strikes me as the same mentality of Men's Rights groups who typically seem more interested in making sure their position as the most privileged group is maintained. Do you also like to say "All Lives Matter" in response to "Black Lives Matter"? This feels comparable to me.

There is no guarantee that anyone will be treated fairly by any new CEO hire, or any CEO in general. But it's not unreasonable to be generally more concerned about the group that have had a systematically worse experience. Improving their experience does not in any way mean that others must suffer. Fairness and empathy are not zero-sum.

> The main problem with your argument is the assumption that the gender of the leader will somehow make things better

The main problem with your entire line of reasoning is that you keep making problematic assumptions. I don't assume that any given woman will make things better. I do assume that - probabilistically - any given senior female leader will have a better appreciation for and more developed thoughts around the troubles females experience in so-called "bro environments" than any given senior male leader. That comment has nothing to say about their other qualifications.

> this line of thinking only contributes to the very sexism it aims to eliminate.

I will agree that if you either intentionally or ignorantly - but either way incorrectly - apply a "women will be better than men" philosophy onto my position then that would indeed be sexist. Thankfully, neither my public comments or most-private thoughts carry that belief.

> Why not judge leaders by their track record, not the gender they were born into?

You need to judge prospective leaders on the entire constellation of performance domains you wish them to achieve in. In this instance, one of those performance domains is a culture change that makes the workplace less of woman-hostile environment. But it's not the only one, and it shouldn't (and almost certainly won't) be treated as such.

Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by malandrew on Monday July 31, 2017 @04:36PM (#14895683)
It's ironic that you don't try to avoid the same criticism that you have doled out elsewhere. Previously you criticized someone for "feel[ing] they have to take any statement to their most extreme in order to challenge the conversation", yet in this comment you have done the same.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by HelloMcFly on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @09:36AM (#14900427)
I disagree, I feel every comment was sufficiently justified by the text of the parent comment. My only regret is including the "Do you say 'All Lives Matter...". I shouldn't have made that a question targeting the parent comment, and just noted that the protestation seemed comparable.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by asdfologist on Monday July 31, 2017 @06:05PM (#14896301)
Agreed, let's all try to have a civil discussion around here, folks.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by asdfologist on Monday July 31, 2017 @06:04PM (#14896294)
So by your own admission, you're advocating hiring a female CEO based on a probabilistic argument that females tend to make the workplace more female-friendly. Isn't this akin to saying that the US Department of Education should hire an Asian leader because the US is bad at math and science, and Asians have been shown to be generally better at math and science?
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by HelloMcFly on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @09:51AM (#14900550)
Good grief. No, I do not advocate hiring a female - or anyone - on any single set of criteria. I don't think Uber - or anyone - should only consider or be committed to hiring women. To do so would be both unethical, sub-optimal and illegal. That is as clear as I can be on that subject.

However, I do think they should make an increased effort to find qualified female candidates for the CEO position and put them through same selection process as male candidates. And I do think that all things being equal, women candidates will have a leg-up on male candidates in the one particular performance domain of redressing the female-hostile culture Travis and the leadership team created because on balance women will have more understanding of the issues facing the female workforce.

However, 1) that isn't the only performance domain, and 2) the selection process may very well reveal that one or more of the male candidates has better insight into the issue, more personal experience creating the kind of culture change needed, or both. That's why the selection process exist.

> Isn't this akin to saying that the US Department of Education should hire an Asian leader because the US is bad at math and science, and Asians have been shown to be generally better at math and science?

No, it's not, and that doesn't seem to me to be a good-faith analogy on your part at all.

Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by lightbyte on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:10AM (#14892114)
Are you implying the only possible solution for that is a women? That itself is very sexist.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by lettergram on Monday July 31, 2017 @11:18AM (#14892778)
Indeed, my point exactly.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by harryh on Monday July 31, 2017 @08:21AM (#14891231)
I will bet you any amount of money that you care to wager that Uber "makes it to 2019."
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by furioussloth on Monday July 31, 2017 @01:57PM (#14894402)
Your criticism of company is one thing but thinking that they are not lasting longer than 6 months is a complete oversight on your part of how dominant they are in market or how many new markets they are trying to enter. No one cares about their management troubles outside silicon valley and rightly so. Consumers care about product and convenience . I agree with the part that they should aim for competent candidate not female candidate but thinking they are not making it into 2019 is just laughable.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by johnrichardson on Monday July 31, 2017 @04:35AM (#14890352)
Agreed. I wish they would just state the facts, and avoid the SJW nonsense. I don't care about the author's thoughts on identity politics - I just want the substance of the story.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by mlloyd on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:20AM (#14891648)
Calling out the prime goal of remedying a toxic sexist culture in an article that is being written because of said company's toxic sexist culture isn't identity politics nor SJW, it's reality.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by johnrichardson on Monday July 31, 2017 @04:08PM (#14895457)
Here's reality: kowtowing to leftist media pressure in the name of making a company more 'sensitive and diverse' (i.e., hiring people for any reason other than their competence, such as their addition to 'diversity'), will kill it. Full stop. Ridesharing is quickly turning into a low margin, commodified business, and the more time Uber wastes with this nonsense, the more of an edge its competitors will gain on it.
Re:Lack of cohesion in Uber's search for a new CEO by malandrew on Monday July 31, 2017 @04:49PM (#14895771)
Unfortunately, your observation applies to all American companies.

Diversity can contribute value in many contexts, but diversity for the sake of diversity is a distraction. Homogeneity can also contribute in many contexts as well. Homogeneity and diversity exist on a spectrum and the right balance between those two depends on what you're optimizing for. There is no silver bullet.

That all said, the only diversity that really matters is diversity of knowledge, experiences, opinions and thoughts. Not all experiences, opinions and thoughts are relevant to the task at hand. Diversity of identity is generally a poor proxy for the type of diversity that has utility.