News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by jacquesm on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:42AM (#1488077)
Jeff Bezos seems to suffer from selection bias. We don't always have those choices, count yourself lucky if you do and then make the right ones but don't fret about it if you do not.

Not all of us will become billionaires by simply making 'the right choices', plenty of people made the choices the right way and ended up average or dirt poor.

Count your wealth in the number of smiles you see when people meet you again after not seeing you for a while.

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by kylemathews on Monday July 05, 2010 @11:00AM (#1488318)
Huh? Everyone has to make the choice between being clever or kind. The point of the talk wasn't "make the right choices and you'll end up a billionaire." The point of the story was the quality of your life, your own happiness, and your real worth is determined by the choices you make, not what gifts you have because, as Jeff pointed out, they're just gifts after all, you didn't earn them.

His implicit point was an average intelligent person with average wealth can be just as satisfied with his/her life as a highly intelligent, highly gifted billionaire provided they both made quality choices about how they lived their life.

Edit: clarified last sentence.

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by jacquesm on Monday July 05, 2010 @11:14AM (#1488356)
That's easy to say when you have a few billion in the bank. But most people simply don't have the liberty of choice at all, their lives are driven by requirements, not by freedom of choice.

Freedom of choice is for the most part an illusion, it is only true freedom if you determine what's on the menu. To be able to choose 'left' or 'right' when you want 'straight', 'down', 'reverse' and so on as valid choices but you don't have them because of the constraints placed on you by every day life is a false kind of freedom presented in those limited choices.

So, in practice, your average billionaire has more (many more) choices available to him than those lower on the financial ladder. The reason Jeff Bezos had the choice to give that speech or not is not because he's particularly happy, but because he's rich.

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by kylemathews on Monday July 05, 2010 @12:46PM (#1488577)
Many less choices doesn't mean no choices.

I lived and worked for two years in the Philippines amongst some of the poorest people in the world. These people were constrained in many ways as you describe in job choices, educational attainments, opportunity for travel etc. But regardless of how poor they were they still had the choice of to be kind or clever, to forgive or seek revenge, to pursue worthwhile activities or fritter away their time/money on drugs and alcohol, etc. There were many many very happy people I met in the worst of slums.

The most important choices we make in little have absolutely zero to do with how much money we have.

For a more extended essay on the topic, read "Man's Search for Meaning" by Viktor Frankl who survived a Nazi concentration camp.

To pull one quote off its Wikipedia page: "Fundamentally, therefore, any man can, even under such circumstances, decide what shall become of him – mentally and spiritually. He may retain his human dignity even in a concentration camp."

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by jacquesm on Monday July 05, 2010 @03:05PM (#1488850)
> He may retain his human dignity even in a concentration camp.

A key insight in ethics is that truly ethical decisions almost always go against the person making the decision.

A situation such as a concentration camp brings out the worst in some and the best in others in very stark contrast because of the environment, not because of the people in it. In less polarizing circumstances those on opposite ends of the spectrum might very well get along just fine.

A couple of movies and books bring that out really well, 'Der Faelscher' for instance, and the diary portion of the Odessa file as well as plenty of first hand accounts, such as the one you reference but also many others. The scary thing is that such an environment will also bring out the worst in otherwise decent people, and that our society in some ways does the same thing to its inhabitants, even if not on such a drastic scale.

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by dgordon on Monday July 05, 2010 @06:32PM (#1489295)
>A key insight in ethics is that truly ethical decisions almost always go against the person making the decision.

What? Which theory of ethics are you using? I don't agree with this at all.

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by exit on Monday July 05, 2010 @01:33PM (#1488675)
> to pursue worthwhile activities or fritter away their time/money on drugs and alcohol

no, that's genetically predetermined.

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by brianpan on Monday July 05, 2010 @12:23PM (#1488537)
But he's talking to a class of Princeton grads. Being stuck with few choices is not a problem most of them will have.
Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by jbgoddard on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:41PM (#1489564)
The speech emphasizes making good choices, which has nothing to do with the quantity of choices of available. The billions of dollars, in the context of his speech, is a gift, while leaving a job and starting an online bookstore is one of the choices that defines his life.
Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by nandemo on Monday July 05, 2010 @06:52PM (#1489347)
> Everyone has to make the choice between being clever or kind.

I was baffled by this remark; since when being clever or kind are mutually exclusive options? According to the transcript he said "will you be clever at the expense of others, or will you be kind?".

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by aik on Monday July 05, 2010 @07:44PM (#1489457)
Being "clever or kind" isn't mutually exclusive, but being "clever at the expense of others, or kind" is. It's a good point in my opinion. It's easy to forget the human element.
Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by nandemo on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @12:00AM (#1489910)
Being "clever or kind" isn't mutually exclusive, but being "clever at the expense of others, or kind" is.

Hmm, yes, that's the point of my comment.

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by dannyr on Monday July 05, 2010 @02:29PM (#1488769)
jacquesm,

I'm actually really curious about your life experiences. I remember arguing with you last time similar to this (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1373349).

You seem to be always against advising people to make bold choices to pursue their dreams.

I grew up in a poor family in the Philippines. I have lived with the poor and I have seen many people rose from poverty because they chose to. My mom who never finished grade school is the best example for that. I have also seen so many people who just never made an effort to rise out of poverty.

I just can't imagine a world full of people with the same views as yours. People who keep telling others that they don't have a choice - "be content to where you are now because that's as far as you can get" or "it may have worked for others but it doesn't mean it's going to work for you".

Re:Jeff Bezos to Princeton's class of 2010 :"We are What We ... by jacquesm on Monday July 05, 2010 @03:11PM (#1488863)
> You seem to be always against advising people to make bold choices to pursue their dreams.

On the contrary, but there is a right time for everything.

Pretending that a class of graduates has something to learn from a guy that basically is standing before them not because of how ethically he lived his life and how happy he is but because he simply is rich (and therefore successful by our most common yardstick, wealth) is dishonest.

If you'd go out and find someone that has actually managed to achieve such a state of mind from hardship (say Nelson Mandela) then I'd be all for it.

My life experiences are one long series of bold moves, and I wouldn't have it any other way but I'm very careful to tell other people to 'do as I do', everything has its price and you have to make people aware of the price before you tell them to purchase the wares.

I think you are completely misreading me in what I wrote back then, I made it pretty clear in this sentence:

"Yes, so it worked for you. Great. It worked for me too, 23 years ago, one idle day in July. But that does not mean it will work for everyone."

To put out the advice to quit to someone without further knowledge of their situation is short-sighted, at a minimum you should spend a good bit of time to ascertain that that really is what's best for them, off the cuff advice like that can be very harmful.

If you want to know more about my life experiences feel free to read: http://jacquesmattheij.com/ .