Re:Bitcoin Cash and a Critical Alert for Bitcoin Margin Traders
by TD-Linux on Friday July 28, 2017 @04:23PM
(#14877257)
Luckily they last-minute added replay protection so that transactions are chain-specific, making the situation far better. I've not reviewed their solution for correctness, but others seem content with it.
Re:Bitcoin Cash and a Critical Alert for Bitcoin Margin Traders
by IwNpcJ on Friday July 28, 2017 @04:28PM
(#14877305)
That is good news. This means that even if CoinBase doesn't initially support the fork, they can do so at any later time without any losses to their user base.
Re:Bitcoin Cash and a Critical Alert for Bitcoin Margin Traders
by matt_wulfeck on Saturday July 29, 2017 @12:18AM
(#14879447)
That's a fantastically positive spin on what looks like (to an outsider) a hot pile a poop. It's more like two children tearing the teddy bear in half because neither could compromise.
This causes issues because Bitcoin was never engineered for this contingency. In the ideal case, you would be allowed to select which blockchain you are spending your tokens on. Bitcoin transactions do not contain any information about which blockchain they should be allowed to be spent on, so all transactions spent after the fork are valid on both blockchains regardless of the author's intentions. BCC could have fixed this by provisioning their transactions to be chain-specific, but it seems they did not.
There are significant tax ramifications of this, which are sure to cause a headache for everyone. It seems to me that the tax basis of the original Bitcoins will become diminished by the proportional amount of the value of BCC on the day of the spin-off.