It's not implausible that a modern weapon could punch a hole in tank armor and nonetheless not only fail to achieve even a mission kill, but leave the crew alive. It is really, really improbable, though. I could buy that it'd happened once, although I'd like to see some kind of cite for that. I'd have a hard time believing it had happened twice in the same, as yet rather short, conflict.
The hole was apparently not clean through because the original armor and extra layer and reactive armor installed during 'modernisations' did it job and protected the tank and the crew, it just now has this horribly looking hole in it so the Ukrainian crew abandoned it and separatists took it. This is a tank from the 60s, modernised in the 80s, by the way.
http://dziennikzbrojny.pl/artykuly/art,3,8,8725,pole-bitwy,1...
English Wikipedia also mentions 65 T-64s variants have been captured in Donbas (but the link is to a Russian website and I read Russian way too slowly and need a dictionary to do it so I can't confirm the citation): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equipment_of_the_Ukrainian_Gro...
Separatists took these over and patched/replaced the broken armor piece and used them.
It might all have been bullshit though and I can't find that article from years ago(and it wasn't in English anyway).