News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by chroem- on Friday July 28, 2017 @06:35AM (#14873252)
I'm curious if the author would also refer to the M4 carbine as an "infamous killing machine," given the opportunity.

The fact of the matter is that the US is also developing these systems, albeit with more focus on autonomous air combat vehicles. To say that this is a Russia-only problem vastly understates how serious of an issue this is.

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by RobertoG on Friday July 28, 2017 @06:43AM (#14873277)
But it's not the same, the article makes it clear here:

"Known informally inside the corridors of the Pentagon as 'the Terminator conundrum,' the question being asked is whether stifling the development of these types of weapons would actually allow other less ethically minded countries to leap ahead?"

As a not American, I feel totally safe when it's the ethically minded USA who does it.

Yep. That was sarcasm, sorry.

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by candiodari on Friday July 28, 2017 @10:41AM (#14874572)
That was the question until the Kalashnikov announcement.

Now the question is, "given that everybody from Putin, to terrorists, Maduro, and North Korea have these weapons, do you want the US government facing them without such weapons ?"

In an arms race, you can perhaps refuse to pull ahead (even that is risky), but nothing good will come of falling behind.

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by euyyn on Friday July 28, 2017 @07:07PM (#14878292)
Is there even real competition, though? Doesn't the US already have the military power of the 6 following nations combined, or something like that?
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by candiodari on Sunday July 30, 2017 @09:54AM (#14885942)
If that's supposed to work like a threat to keep others in line, then of course, the US should work to (at least) maintain and (preferably) increase that power. Otherwise the threat won't matter. In other words, this depends on developing and demonstrating any and all weapons capabilities before others develop them, because if just one such technology provides an overwhelming advantage ...

Furthermore, there can also be no doubt that the US would use such weapons to maintain it's own and it's allies' security. There can be no doubt that we'd fire such weapons at Russian armies attempting to invade the Ukranian parliament for example. More controversially, there can be no doubt that we'd fire them at not really civilian Palestinians if Israel's army loses control.

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by euyyn on Sunday July 30, 2017 @02:23PM (#14887140)
> because if just one such technology provides an overwhelming advantage

I don't think an autonomous Kalashnikov can overwhelm a squadron of drones, which aren't the most powerful thing in the US arsenal either.

> There can be no doubt that we'd fire such weapons at Russian armies attempting to invade the Ukranian parliament for example.

Haha well, they'll have to keep invading and leave just the parliament alone then.

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by lmm on Friday July 28, 2017 @07:15AM (#14873384)
The M4 isn't infamous though? I don't even know which one that is. The M-16 is famous but associated more with militaries than with guerillas or terrorists. I can't really think of a US-made weapon with a reputation for disreputable uses - maybe the "Tommy Gun" (associated with gangsters, at least in the popular imagination)?
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by throwanem on Friday July 28, 2017 @07:39AM (#14873489)
The M4 and M16 are both versions of Eugene Stoner's AR-15 design. You know which one that is, even if you don't know you know it. Think about the last movie you saw that was made since 1980 and included American soldiers. What rifle were they carrying? There you go.

There also exist many AR-15-pattern rifles in the civilian market - obviously without the full-auto and burst-fire modes one finds in military models, but otherwise quite similar. They're generally satisfactory firearms - cheap to feed, not unpleasant to use or overly difficult to maintain.

They're also a longstanding bête noire of the anti-guns crowd, among whom the type is infamous because people have used them in a few mass shootings, and also because if you're afraid of firearms already then this type looks super extra scary - dressed in full tacticool ribs and Picatinny, it looks like something a Terminator might carry, and they're usually finished in black.

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by lmm on Saturday July 29, 2017 @08:58AM (#14880988)
> You know which one that is, even if you don't know you know it. Think about the last movie you saw that was made since 1980 and included American soldiers. What rifle were they carrying? There you go.

See I thought that was the M-16; I could even have told you "the civilian version is the AR-15 and doesn't have full auto" but I'd never heard it called an M4 before. (Speaking as someone from a non-gun country whose only exposure to any of this is popular culture).

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by throwanem on Saturday July 29, 2017 @03:11PM (#14882585)
That's not too far off base - just that the AR-15 came first, followed by the M16 and later M4 variants on the military side, and any number of manufacturers' and homebrewers' variants on the civilian side.
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by Grangar on Monday July 31, 2017 @04:00AM (#14890214)
The M4 is a carbine variant - the barrel and handguard are shorter. That's about where the differences end.
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by maxerickson on Friday July 28, 2017 @09:08AM (#14873951)
Perhaps no single US made weapon has gained such a reputation because there are so many to choose from?

There's a category for cheap, small-caliber pistols, "Saturday night special".

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by Grangar on Friday July 28, 2017 @07:32AM (#14873458)
How about the Predator drone?
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by lou1306 on Friday July 28, 2017 @08:54AM (#14873873)
Calling it infamous would be an understatement. That thing single-handedly attached a negative connotation to the term "drone".
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by jeff_petersen on Friday July 28, 2017 @06:48PM (#14878192)
Perhaps the AR-18 would fit, the IRA were big fans
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by lmm on Saturday July 29, 2017 @08:59AM (#14880992)
Never heard of it, couldn't tell you anything about it - it's not one you see in movies / on flags / what-have-you (indeed the IRA are rarely seen in movies full stop - perhaps because they were allegedly Hollywood-funded?)
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by wmil on Friday July 28, 2017 @04:32PM (#14877331)
It's a high reliability, low maintenance weapon. As a result the AK-47 is the weapon of choice for poorly trained armies.

That gives it a worse reputation than most other rifles.

Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by marblar on Friday July 28, 2017 @06:34PM (#14878124)
Serious question: why would a non-poorly trained army select a more maintenance-heavy weapon? Would it have other benefits?
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by wmil on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @03:55PM (#14904691)
AR-15 base weapons (M16, M4) are much more accurate. So there's an advantage at distance. Also it uses smaller, faster rounds that have less stopping power, but are easier to carry. So there's a greater chance of running out of ammo with an AK-47.
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by germinalphrase on Friday July 28, 2017 @08:02PM (#14878594)
Tighter tolerances can produce higher rates of fire and improved accuracy at the expense of reliability.
Re:Kalashnikov’s new autonomous weapons and the “Terminator ... by Koshkin on Friday July 28, 2017 @07:41PM (#14878478)
Lower reliability.