News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by irrelative on Sunday July 04, 2010 @04:06PM (#1486285)
The hatred of linux on the desktop is terribly cliche, especially on a site targeted towards hackers. Linux on my desktop is the greatest development environment I've ever used, having played extensively with OSX and Windows as well. I can easily install new libraries and "apt-get source" allows me to tinker with existing software easily and immediately build and execute the results. All of the development environment is thoroughly documented.

But now, some influential people start saying how much better their version is. Specifically their closed, sealed-off, experience-driven version. Arguing "ease of use" and "shiny end user experience" rings really hollow to me. I use vim -- think I care about easy to use or shiny user experiences? -- and I use it because it's a powerful tool for its job. I just don't get it when hackers start telling other hackers that they should use a more restrictive environment because it'll make them feel better or is easier to use. Instead, ask yourself: is it the most powerful tool for the job?

So sure, tell your parents and siblings to buy an iPhone. Hell, use your iPhone for anything you can -- it's a fantastic device. But stop telling future developers that it's worth giving up control for rounded corners and subtle shadows. And stop comparing its competition negatively to an environment that I, and others, find superior to any other.

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by cmelbye on Sunday July 04, 2010 @05:26PM (#1486412)
You completely missed the point of this article, which I find odd because the author clearly explained why he compared Android with desktop Linux. By "Linux on the desktop", he means Linux on regular Joe's desktop, not the hacker's desktop. The author agrees with you that Linux is made for people like you that want/need the extra control, etc, whatever. This is not what the majority are looking for in a desktop distribution.
Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by irrelative on Sunday July 04, 2010 @06:15PM (#1486527)
I think it's a little harsh to say that I "completely missed the point" of this article. I get it -- Apple products are very polished and carefully designed and the Android lacks that polish but is feature rich. Is that an accurate description, or did I completely miss something else?

Marco is a developer with some very successful products, and I really respect his work. I feel that makes him influential in the hacker community and this post did make it rather high on HN. However, respecting Apple's products has gone too far when I can barely tell it from a PR piece. I don't know what it is, but it's not news.

I really don't want to begin discussing regular Joe's desktop experience -- summarizing people into 2 camps trivializes the actual wants and needs of a computer user. What I can tell you is that on a site devoted to hacker news, this post seems like 'dog bites man' with an easy shot at a strawman.

I don't mean this to be a biting criticism. As a developer, I just wish that I had started using linux earlier because I would have learned a lot more and it would be more second nature. Out there, someone 10 years younger than me is being turned off from using linux on the desktop because of posts like this, and that's a shame.

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by MrFoof on Monday July 05, 2010 @12:54PM (#1488599)
"I really don't want to begin discussing regular Joe's desktop experience -- summarizing people into 2 camps trivializes the actual wants and needs of a computer user."

You can put people into two camps about most anything -- enthusiasts, and everyone else.

This applies to cooking. Cars. Television. Sports. Video games. Interior design. Phones. Music. Architecture. Computers. Gardening. Reading... and I'm running out of objects by looking about my apartment, but the crux is that some people give objects and activities a large amount of attention when compared to the vast majority of the population - that doesn't give a rat's tail about anything beyond the most basic functionality.

Many developers, or at least the ones that frequent forums on computing topics, are just that - enthusiasts. They are very savvy, very passionate, and sometimes considerably out of touch with everyone who doesn't care nearly as much. There's a distinct difference between someone who waits months and months for a specific type of TV to come out, pays 4x as much for it compared to other TVs for its size, and can take advantage of all the features they paid for. This isn't surprising as they've become a bit of a domain expert on the points that relate to their needs. However most people just want the biggest, flattest TV they can buy for the lowest price.

Would I like random mass storage on the iPhone? Sure, why not. My mom? My mother after 17 years still doesn't know what directories her files end up in (Profile\My Documents or \Profile). She has my father assist her in getting her music on her iPod. Recently I said, "Mom, you use a computer every day. You need to remember where (Windows, OS X) puts your files" in which she retorted, "No, I just want to send Lorraine some photos. I don't care how it works."

And that's it. Most people want to just get something done on a computer. Most people just want to drive to the store. Most people just want to have fun with a video game and don't care how critically acclaimed it is. Most people just want a roof over their head that looks familiar when compared to other homes they've been in. Most people just want mustard to put on their hot dog and aren't espousing the qualities of some mustard on online forums. And so forth.

Everyone else is an anorak. And that's fine as there's a market that caters to them, whereas the rest of the population is still plumbing the first 10% of depth. Everyone is passionate about different things. And most people aren't passionate about most things.

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by sandee on Sunday July 04, 2010 @09:12PM (#1486833)
> As a developer, I just wish that I had started using linux earlier because I would have learned a lot more and it

Total agree.

After years of windows, i moved to Linux Desktop since last 2 years. How i wish, i had done that earlier.

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by Robin_Message on Monday July 05, 2010 @12:08PM (#1488505)
> I think it's a little harsh to say that I "completely missed the point" of this article. I get it -- Apple products are very polished and carefully designed and the Android lacks that polish but is feature rich. Is that an accurate description, or did I completely miss something else?

What you are missing is that what you are calling "polish" is 90% of the quality of a product to a consumer.

It's not about gradients or drop shadows. It's about saying no in the development process, and making sure everything just works.

To give a counter-example of polish, here is a problem I had on my work machine. It was recently upgraded to Fedora Core 11, a seemingly sensible choice. When I first logged in, the volume control mumbled something about having been deleted. I had a look for another one, only to discover that there is no simple volume control. For some development reason, which I don't give a shit about, someone has removed the existing volume control, and some other subsystem is meant to provide one, but they haven't gotten around to it yet.

That is why Linux on the desktop is dead, and as long as Linux is developed in the bazaar, it will always be dead (but great for geeks!)

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by davidw on Sunday July 04, 2010 @06:07PM (#1486507)
I run the web site for a friend who has an antique book store here in Padova. He is not a power user kind of guy. And his friend put Ubuntu on his laptop after he got sick of getting viruses and random problems. So far, he's quite happy with it - which honestly surprised me, because I don't really push people to convert to Linux (I don't like doing desktop support). It's surprisingly good these days, though, and continues to improve.
Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by sprout on Sunday July 04, 2010 @05:56PM (#1486477)
The only reason I don't recommend desktop Linux to people is that explaining ubuntu-restricted-extras to them is too much work. Other than that it 'just works' out of the box and anyone who is currently using Windows XP should upgrade.
Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by neilc on Sunday July 04, 2010 @06:19PM (#1486538)
anyone who is currently using Windows XP should upgrade

Can we stop this silly meme of calling a switch between two unrelated products an "upgrade"? WinXP => Linux is an "upgrade" that has 0% software compatibility, and requires a massive amount of retraining and reconfiguration. Which is to say, it isn't an "upgrade" at all.

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by sprout on Monday July 05, 2010 @05:34PM (#1489152)
There are a variety of accepted definitions of upgrade, and most of them agree with my usage. Only one agrees with your 'correct' usage.

Ubuntu is a software platform that provides improved performance in a variety of ways, including 90% software compatibility, since most of the important software is web, Flash, or Java based. (Of course, I'm talking about home use.)

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/upgrade

http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/upgrade

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by etfb on Sunday July 04, 2010 @08:11PM (#1486694)
...has 0% software compatibility, and requires a massive amount of retraining and reconfiguration...

Naaah. Too easy. No comment.

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by scottdw2 on Sunday July 04, 2010 @07:19PM (#1486627)
You bring up some interesting points. One question worth pondering, though, is "what does it mean for a tool to be powerful"? Since you brought up VIM let's take text editors as an example.

VIM is indeed a powerful editor. It gives you a lot of tools for quickly editing text. The problems I face, usually aren't related to typing. It's in figuring out what to type in the first place, and where to type it. When dealing with a large code base, the things I need most are code navigation capabilities. What is this? Where is it used? What does the call graph look like? Etc. Is VIM the most powerful tool for code navigation? No. It's far from it. One of the best is a tool called source insight. It's simple, fast and easy to use.

No one will ever tell you are cool for learning how to use it, because you don't have to learn how to use it. It just works. There's no sense of mastery involved. It just works. It brings the information to you, when you need it, in the context it's needed in. That makes it VERRY powerful.

You can say the same thing about a phone. Bringing you information in a way that is efortless and enjoyable is powerful.

It may not be "cool" with the same ubergeek street cred you get from learning VI. But that doesn't mean it's not powerful. Far from it.

Re:The difference between iPhone + Android: Great since day... by againstyou on Sunday July 04, 2010 @11:51PM (#1487176)
I can easily install new libraries and "apt-get source" allows me to tinker with existing software easily

you can do the same thing on a mac, in a elegant way, so what's the advantage to do it on linux ?

I use vim

you can also use vim in a elegant mac terminal, what's the point here ?

And stop comparing its competition negatively

who was doing that ?