"Whatever happened to good old koans? Just because they're tricky doesn't mean they were an accident."
Koans are hardly omnipresent throughout Buddhism. They're a pretty late addition. The Buddha wouldn't have had a clue what you were talking about.
Re:Meditation: Why Bother?
by silentbicycle on Sunday July 04, 2010 @01:48AM
(#1485234)
Yeah, but "Buddhism" in the US means Soto and (especially) Rinzai Zen, since the Beats (esp. at the San Francisco Zen Center) did so much to popularize it. Otherwise, Buddhism has mostly stayed in local ethnic enclaves.
Re:Meditation: Why Bother?
by cylinder714 on Sunday July 04, 2010 @04:19PM
(#1486307)
Insight meditation, a.k.a. "vipassana", has made big strides, thanks to Insight Meditation Society in Massachusetts and Spirit Rock in California, as well as S.N. Goenka's centers around the country.
Regarding Zen, koans are a feature of Rinzai, whereas Soto centers on just sitting.
Postmodern angst isn't the introduction of new ideas on the global scale, just a particular rehashing of them that has resonated with consumerist America for the last 50 years. Perhaps it's safest to say there are many outlooks on human suffering, but any and all ways of saying them are insufficiently precise to have claims of solutions be anything more than delusion.
So now, I'll apologize beforehand should I misspeak, but I believe the heart of the study of meditation is wrapped up in just doing meditation because talking about it only occludes one's understanding of the practice. With that in hand, I find the article even more disingenuous. Whatever happened to good old koans? Just because they're tricky doesn't mean they were an accident.
Shut up and meditate. Or exercise. Or backpack. Or go dancing.