News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Paint to be killed off after 32 years by emilsedgh on Monday July 24, 2017 @12:00PM (#14839566)
I don't get it. On windows each app has a completely different look and feel and guidelines and people are fine with it.

But on Linux we have 2 and people are complaining.

Btw, GTK+ apps look very close to Qt apps on KDE as KDE's Breeze engine has a GTK+ version.

Additionally, an open source windows paint (that parent comment asked for) will not look consistent go GTK+ apps as well.

Re:Microsoft Paint to be killed off after 32 years by cobalt on Monday July 24, 2017 @12:54PM (#14840122)
well people do complain, but i think the point is that windows has one UI framework (win32/user32) and (most) everyone uses that. It provides all of the primitives and norms that people expect
Re:Microsoft Paint to be killed off after 32 years by Joeri on Monday July 24, 2017 @01:55PM (#14840900)
Do you actually use windows? That's not my experience at all. The difference between even just the stuff windows ships with is staggering. Just compare control panel to settings app, they look like they belong to different OS's, and you have to use both to access all configuration.
Re:Microsoft Paint to be killed off after 32 years by buzzybee on Monday July 24, 2017 @02:35PM (#14841334)
IME real users don't care about the app being aesthetically different, but they do care if the common idioms have changed(e.g. position of OK/Cancel). That shouldn't depend on your toolkit, though.
Re:Microsoft Paint to be killed off after 32 years by sqeaky on Monday July 24, 2017 @04:30PM (#14842369)
There are like 50 different toolkits...

I exagerate, but: win32 GDI, windows.forms, MFCs, ATL and that is just from microsoft off the top of my head. There are way more when you start looking at all the solutions that a typical user might actually have running on their machine.

Re:Microsoft Paint to be killed off after 32 years by slededit on Monday July 24, 2017 @08:27PM (#14844011)
MFC, ATL, and the .NET stuff with the exception of XAML all use win32 controls under the hood. XAML still uses user32 albeit not the control toolkit. Because everything shares the same common core things work together better than on Linux.
Re:Microsoft Paint to be killed off after 32 years by sqeaky on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @03:36PM (#14851153)
> MFC, ATL, and the .NET stuff with the exception of XAML all use win32 controls under the hood.

Oh, I wish that were true. I have twice been a test automation engineer and stopped exactly that not being true for all widgets. Some are, but many of them, including some styles of buttons are not. A simple heuristic to tell is that when a UI widget does something the win32 can't, its probably not a win32 widget.

Even using UI inspection tools like Spy++ panels with .Net buttons that aren't backed by win32 buttons just show don't show up as an item is the tree of UI elements. There are also applications that just do silly things like use GDI, DirectX or OpenGL to draw a thing that looks like a button and isn't controlable of adjustable via external calls at all.