News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by davidw on Saturday July 03, 2010 @09:01AM (#1483750)
I think that, given a limited amount of time, I'd rather do exercise (cycling) than meditate, as it's a pretty good way of 'getting away from things' and thinking without interruptions, and I also get some physical benefits from it.
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by Estragon on Saturday July 03, 2010 @12:38PM (#1483994)
I do about 2 hours of meditation a day. This is useful because it builds a huge capacity for emotional regulation and lets me stand in situations I once would have run from or otherwise sought to avoid, and and I can still clearly see what's going on in these situations. Exercise has its merits (I also walk about 2 hours a day) but they are very different.

As Suzuki Roshi said "Sit Zazen. To live life without sitting Zazen is like winding a watch without setting it: It will run, but it won't tell you the correct time."

Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by bumbledraven on Saturday July 03, 2010 @01:29PM (#1484086)
I also sit for 2 hours a day, and I see the same benefits. I wouldn't normally post a "me too" message, but I don't see too many comments about meditating 2 hours a day.
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by zackattack on Saturday July 03, 2010 @01:37PM (#1484092)
How did you guys get to this point? Did you do a Vipassana retreat?
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by Estragon on Saturday July 03, 2010 @01:47PM (#1484120)
I started out reading Wake Up To Your Life, built up to doing about an hour a day, went on a retreat[1] run by the author of that book, from which I saw huge benefits, started meditating for really long stretches in order to hammer home the skills I'd learned there, then settled down to an hour after rising and an hour before bed. (Plus any time it's useful during the day.)

[1] Recordings of the talks at that retreat are linked from this URL: http://unfetteredmind.org/audio/podretreat.php?code=PAP#here They're the PAP01-PAP10 links.

Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by carbon8 on Saturday July 03, 2010 @01:49PM (#1484124)
If you do vipassana via http://www.dhamma.org/ the ideal daily sitting schedule in day to day life is an hour in the morning and an hour in the evening. If you make it part of your routine, it can be somewhat easy to do. It's actually trivial to be on the 2 hr/day schedule after finishing a 10 day sitting since 2 hours is nothing at that point and you remember exactly what you're doing, but in my experience it's difficult to start up again with regular 2 hr/day sittings once you stop. My routine for a bunch of years was to do the 2 hour sittings for a while, but eventually fall off until going to another 10 day sitting.

Even though 2 hours seems like a lot, because of what it is (focusing the mind, learning to not overreact to external stimuli, stability of the mind), it makes people able to be very highly productive throughout the day.

Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by brihas on Saturday July 03, 2010 @02:35PM (#1484212)
Here is a nice essay by S.N. Goenka titled "The Art of Living: Vipassana Meditation" http://www.dhamma.org/en/art.shtml
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by Herring on Saturday July 03, 2010 @02:08PM (#1484158)
I've sat for 30min a day since Jan, & I get a similar 'regulation' effect. YMMV
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by silentbicycle on Sunday July 04, 2010 @12:07AM (#1485102)
That said, 2 hours is a pretty extremeTM amount of time to meditate every day. Fifteen minutes, give or take, will still go a long way. (Fifteen minutes in the morning AND before bed is even better, though, and who doesn't spend half an hour a day just farting around?)
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by Estragon on Sunday July 04, 2010 @06:01AM (#1485460)
Yes, I don't mean to imply that two hours a day is a necessary threshold. I brought that up in response to the statement about exercise, to highlight how valuable it is to me.
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by petervandijck on Saturday July 03, 2010 @09:39AM (#1483786)
Exercise is awesome.

I do think the concept of "limited amount of time" is a little flawed. Perhaps the real reason people shy away from meditation is that it's hard and takes discipline and willpower (in a good way)?

Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by davidw on Saturday July 03, 2010 @09:44AM (#1483789)
> I do think the concept of "limited amount of time" is a little flawed.

And you do have a kid. Huh:-)

Well, I do not have enough time for all the activities that I would like to do, so for me it's a very real concept. Proper training is hard and takes discipline in a good way too, so exercise has that one covered.

Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by chacha102 on Saturday July 03, 2010 @09:49AM (#1483795)
I don't think the concept of "limited amount of time" is flawed.

Frankly, some people are constantly working and don't have time to meditate. It isn't that they shy away from it because it is hard or takes discipline and willpower, it is because we live in a world that (unfortunately) gives us a limited amount of time during the day that we can spend awake consistently if we don't want to possibly damage our health.

Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by petervandijck on Saturday July 03, 2010 @10:11AM (#1483810)
Fair enough. Still though, I don't know, I personally spend a lot of time on things that are not obligatory, so that time is mine to choose how I spend it. Family time, kid time, HN time...

If you're "constantly" working, then that's a choice you made, right?

[edit: just realized I sound kind of like an ass. I shouldn't speak for other people. Just read this as me talking to myself :)]

Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by davidw on Saturday July 03, 2010 @10:22AM (#1483827)
It's not about 'constantly working' (I don't), it's about having lots of things that I like to do, plus work. I think even if I were wealthy and didn't have to work I'd find more ways to fill my time than time available. In some ways that's good - I don't remember the last time I was bored - but it does mean my time is limited.

I guess the point is that for me, exercise is probably more efficient, time wise, in terms of benefits/time, and also includes some of the mental things that I think meditation must give you, but of course it's a fairly personal thing, and to each his own.

Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by skybrian on Saturday July 03, 2010 @11:04AM (#1483873)
Willpower is a limited resource, at least in the short term: http://scienceblogs.com/cortex/2009/12/willpower.php
Re:Meditation: Why Bother? by awt on Saturday July 03, 2010 @10:35AM (#1483836)
Mediation is sort of the opposite of thinking. You don't actively think, and when thoughts do occur, you dismiss them.