News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by sillysaurus3 on Saturday July 22, 2017 @07:40PM (#14830065)
Since you have merged PRs allowing use via Tor, you seem to be tacitly encouraging Open Bazaar to be used by those who want to hide their identity. In the wake of the recent darknet market closures, people have been saying that the drug trade might move to decentralized markets like this. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14828864

As facilitators of this technology, do you have an opinion on how it should be used? Are you concerned that the primary use case might be to acquire drugs? And are there any controls in place to encourage or discourage certain types of items from being bought and sold on this platform, or is it a complete free-for-all?

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by notliketherest on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:43PM (#14830641)
Dear Vint Cerf, since you have created TCP-IP, and another contemporary of yours - HTTP, you seem to be tacitly encouraging a decentralized worldwide exchange of information used by billions around the globe to facilitate exchange of ideas, pleasure, and commerce, free from government censor...
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by matthewbauer on Sunday July 23, 2017 @01:33AM (#14831031)
I thinks it totally different. At the end of the day, the law could reach the original Internet. It really wasn't much different than telephone lines. Encryption is where everything changes. I think everyone should be at least a little bit nervous about where these crypto technologies are taking us. Once criminals learn how to use this technology, there's probably no going back.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by csuwldcat on Sunday July 23, 2017 @01:45AM (#14831049)
Drug purchasing sites have actually helped reduce violence and crime associated with prohibited items/activities. I'm more nervous about where authoritarian government is taking us.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by soupbowl on Sunday July 23, 2017 @07:51AM (#14831832)
* citation needed.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by xtracto on Sunday July 23, 2017 @11:08AM (#14832578)
Well, there are some that I know. The original is here:

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2436643

Then there is Neil Franklin a Maryland police officer and director of the organization "Law Enforcement Against Prohibition"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rc29nw4Si3Y

And his interview in the Deep Web documentary at minute 60 (it is in Netflix).

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by foepys on Sunday July 23, 2017 @01:41PM (#14833391)
This paper doesn't directly support what you said. In the abstract it says: "With Silk Road functioning to considerable degree at the wholesale/broker market level, its virtual location should reduce violence, intimidation and territorialism."

There are 3 mentions of the word "violence", one says that the typical internet drug dealer is typically less violent than their offline counterparts but this doesn't meant that gangs will just let others take away their income because the new dealer is dealing out of a living room instead of on the street. Silk Road was B2B, as the paper mentions. But those businesses still need to get their drugs to the end user which seemingly happens on the street.

So it's an assumption, not a proven fact.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by Keeeeeeeks on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @09:04PM (#14853065)
Harm reduction (IRL, safe injection sites) reduces violence.

That way, a registered nurse/healthcare official who has a job/career to lose if someone overdoses. Nothing is stopping a random dealer using a DNM from cutting a batch with fentanyl, and anonymity means they can fake reviews and hide it

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by SamPatt on Saturday July 22, 2017 @07:46PM (#14830081)
Keep in mind that OpenBazaar has been used for over a year now, and only a small minority of the trade has been illicit. Most people just want a platform where they can buy / sell in crypto and avoid marketplace fees.

We built OpenBazaar to be an agnostic protocol for trade online. It's like any other protocol in that it's neutral, and people can use it how they please. I don't like the idea of people using it for immoral things, but that's their decision.

I know linking to a reddit thread might be heresy here, but I talked about the more on our subreddit (I'm CC_EF_JTF):

https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenBazaar/comments/6oi2k0/rules_of...

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by sillysaurus3 on Saturday July 22, 2017 @10:35PM (#14830615)
After digging into some Reddit comments, this reply appears to downplay the extent to which you're directly facilitating the darknet market migration.

https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenBazaar/comments/6oifak/is_it_po...

"Well if the devs want massive adoption and 2.0 is functional then getting it to work on tails in the next 3 months will get them that."

"If someone would post an eli18 walkthrough on how to config tails so that OB 2.0 will work when that comes out that'd be great."

https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenBazaar/comments/6opqii/i_read_s...

"It's actually about to enter the alpha testing phase. Tor is working with some manual steps. You can test out a week-old build here."

The situation appears to be that OpenBazaar has been used for a year for mostly legal trade due to the technical hurdles of using Open Bazaar with identity-hiding software like Tor and Tails. In fact, OpenBazaar does not work at all on Tails, though work is ongoing to promote this use case (https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenBazaar/comments/6oifak/is_it_po...) and a release with Tor support is scheduled for August.

In fact, most of the recent activity on the OpenBazaar subreddit has been questions about exactly that: sale of illegal substances. https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenBazaar/comments/6oigt2/so_i_hea...

It feels like Open Bazaar is poised to become the next Silk Road. The keystone to achieve that is Tor support plus a Tails walkthrough guide. Both of these seem to be on the verge of being released.

I just wanted to clarify for onlookers that the Open Bazaar team seems to be going into this with both eyes open.

Developing a protocol is one thing. Going out of your way to enable anonymity as a means of acquiring users is a very interesting tactic. It's doubly interesting to repeatedly claim that Open Bazaar was not developed as a darknet market and "may not work for that use case" while also accepting merge requests for Tor support and eventually providing binaries that will work on Tails.

According to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14829076 OB has taken $4M of investment. Perhaps investors are pushing you to acquire users. The DarkNet market crowd is certainly a large target market. Or perhaps all of your intentions are as transparent as you claim, and you're innocently laying the foundation to become the next Silk Road -- an unstoppable decentralized market accountable to no one.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by Frogolocalypse on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:06PM (#14830710)
Another american who has this baffling belief that things that aren't given permission by the government are illegal. Which, in a country full of guns, is kind of interesting. By the rationale you just espoused, the gun manufacturers should be held accountable for the actions of their users.

How about you start focusing on what THEY are doing that is supposedly 'illegal', instead of relying upon insinuation and surveillance.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by detaro on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:11PM (#14830718)
The parent doesn't mention anything about the devs doing anything "illegal" or that they should be "held accountable" for it by the state, so I'm not sure why you argue as if they do.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by sillysaurus3 on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:17PM (#14830731)
Yep. Once Tor is integrated and people start using it for darknet-type activities, it won't be possible to hold anyone accountable or to shut it down. It's decentralized. Personally I find the implications pretty fascinating.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by mirimir on Sunday July 23, 2017 @02:37AM (#14831140)
That's the plan. The key aspects are anonymity, privacy and decentralization. What we get is democratization of freedom.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by mtgx on Sunday July 23, 2017 @03:05AM (#14831193)
He was saying he would be facilitating illegal drug trade. I think he was implying that he would be at least partially responsible.

At the end of the day, the law/Constitution doesn't hold Tor developers accountable for what happens over Tor (nor should it), and I see the OpenBazaar developers being in exactly the same position. I don't think this discussion is even worth having. The case is settled from my point of view and such discussions only serve to cause FUD around the product.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by Frogolocalypse on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:30PM (#14830753)
So things are illegal unless you can prove they aren't?
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by detaro on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:33PM (#14830762)
As far as I can tell, nobody here has made any claim like that, so I have no idea what you are trying to argue, sorry.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by mirimir on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:44PM (#14830795)
> It feels like Open Bazaar is poised to become the next Silk Road.

It might be a decentralized replacement for Silk Road. But there won't be central servers to take down, or owners of such to arrest. I mean, Tor devs don't get busted, do they? So rather, I'd say that it could replace centralized dark markets.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by sillysaurus3 on Sunday July 23, 2017 @12:39AM (#14830923)
Interestingly, a comment below pointed out that the team has roots in the American intelligence community, and the founders live in Virginia (http://samuelrpatterson.com/about-me and https://twitter.com/brianchoffman) within a 20min drive of Langley.

I'm not sure what to make of that, but it seemed worth mentioning.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by e12e on Sunday July 23, 2017 @03:55PM (#14834064)
Absolutely worth mentioning - because it implies similar roots as Tor: a project that provides a platform for plausible denials communication for the intelligence community in the case of Tor - for a "dénivelé" marketplace in the case of Open Bazaar.

Things like iran-contras would probably be easier today (under many Panopticon watchers) with such tech available.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by mirimir on Sunday July 23, 2017 @08:18PM (#14835106)
Sure, unconstitutional military actions like Iran-Contra would be easier. But the key point is that suitably educated and skilled individuals can also do such stuff. Without nation-scale (or even corporate-scale) resources. That's what I meant about democratization of freedom.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by e12e on Sunday July 23, 2017 @10:36PM (#14835526)
Yeah, the point I was trying to make, is that having a real, anonymous digital marketplace might be very useful to intelligence agencies, so it might make sense for them to help build one. Without looking to build in back doors - just like naval intelligence might want an onion router system that works, and has enough traffic going through it that picking out the (smallish) sub-set that is intelligence traffic isn't trivial (eg: a traditional, secure, encrypted (overlay) network that is only used by a single/handful of intelligence agencies isn't very robust/useful for hiding communication).
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by mirimir on Sunday July 23, 2017 @11:32PM (#14835704)
OK, got it. And indeed, that is the Tor Project argument.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by e12e on Sunday July 23, 2017 @07:12PM (#14834867)
Eh, fr/en autocorrect, too late to edit:

plausibly deniable communication

"deniable" marketplace

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by mirimir on Sunday July 23, 2017 @12:51AM (#14830956)
It sure is worth mentioning! But then, Snowden has similar roots. So ???

But yes, I'm sure that the code will be reviewed carefully.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by TheAdamAndChe on Sunday July 23, 2017 @09:24AM (#14832156)
So it's a legitimate concern that this software will be some sort of honeypot to hack and monitor those who have the technical skills to evade typical monitoring, who have a moral code that doesn't align with the federal government, and who probably have a general distrust in the federal government in the first place. It's not a secret at this point that the US government has an incredibly powerful intelligence gathering and spying apparatus, and there have been many signs that they are very willing to spy on those with questionable morals, regardless of whether or not there's any proof they're doing anything wrong.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by mirimir on Sunday July 23, 2017 @05:39PM (#14834549)
For sure. Some have the same concerns about Tor. I mean, Paul Syverson does work for the US Navy. But of course, he's an ornery idealist who would never stand for Tor being backdoored. At least, that's the story. I'm ~90% convinced, but how would one be sure? Except that the code is open-source, anyway.

> So it's a legitimate concern that this software will be some sort of honeypot to hack and monitor those ... who have a moral code that doesn't align with the federal government ...

Yes. And it's not just about the US. The US government is a serious threat for many non-Americans, and does pretty much whatever it likes on the Internet. There are effectively no rules, and no justice. Only the raw exercise of power.

> ... regardless of whether or not there's any proof they're doing anything wrong.

Well, who gets to decide what's wrong?

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by Iranibangbang on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:04PM (#14830703)
You're wrong that they are supporting illegal dark type uses. The team has background in the American intelligence community. Some people are saying their aim is to push toward a backdoored or monitorable supposed darknet.
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by sillysaurus3 on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:23PM (#14830743)
The team has background in the American intelligence community.

For what it's worth, there is a Forbes article that supports this claim: https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2016/03/16/openb...

"Brian Hoffman, a former lead associate for cybersecurity at Edward Snowden's old employer Booz Allen Hamilton"

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by nyolfen on Sunday July 23, 2017 @01:49AM (#14831055)
were there only some way we could examine the software for such a backdoor. alas

tor was developed by the US military initially, as well

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by tripzilch on Sunday July 23, 2017 @03:03PM (#14833832)
> the extent to which you're directly facilitating the darknet market migration

Since it's other people speculating and discussing how to integrate OB with Tails etc, shouldn't that more accurately be "indirectly facilitating (...)"?

You can question the ethics just the same, but it sounds like you're not, and already made up your mind.

Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by coding123 on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:05PM (#14830706)
Why does everything have to be subject to govt control?
Re:Open Bazaar – decentralized Bitcoin marketplace by petre on Sunday July 23, 2017 @12:00AM (#14830843)
Because gov't tends to control everything over time, as it becomes more and more powerful. Rewind that back to the American Revolution and you'd see the federal gov't being less autocratic and states being more autonomous. The Civil War was a turning point. This is not a case with the UK however, because they did not have an equivalent of the French Revolution.