I worked at Twitter when we opened our Seattle office and we were trying to hire maybe 50 engineers the first year. This was before the IPO, trying to hire the ideal skillset for the area (backend) and it was still hard. Meanwhile we had more than 50 offers a week in SF.
The employee base is just so much bigger, it's no wonder companies feel like they have to have offices here.
Also, why are you looking exclusively at the local market? I spent years trying to leave Dallas for greener pastures, only to be ignored by almost everyone out-of-hand except Amazon and Google.
Amazon is most definitely a technology (or, at least, a logistics) company with a store, not the other way around.
1. Seattle 2. Boulder 3. Minneapolis 4. Austin
In each city, you have amazingly talented folks and wonderful opportunities to build against common everyday problems without a ton of competition. You can net the same amount that you would in Silicon Valley or San Fransisco if you play your cards right.
I've done more than fine here with $80k and $100k, but maybe I have a cheaper lifestyle than most.
Off the top of my head I'm thinking Portland, Seattle, Boston, Austin and Chicago in no particular order.
The annoying part is that there's so much talent concentrated in the Bay Area that it makes going elsewhere very difficult, especially if you have specific senior talent in mind that have already established their lives there.
Hopefully telepresence tech gets so good that one day it won't matter.