Re:How the Web Became Unreadable (2016)
by adrianN on Thursday July 20, 2017 @12:37PM
(#14814002)
It looks very neat for me, but I have scripts disabled and run an adblocker. Javascript makes the experience worse on almost every site.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable (2016)
by andrewstuart2 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @01:31PM
(#14814588)
Surely we can acknowledge that JS is not the cause, just as HTTP is not the real cause of all those ads you see.
The problem is shortsighted business and design decisions that have prioritized squeezing every last fraction of a penny out of the page, borrowing against the user's perception of the site. In the long run, that debt is going to come due and the user is going to stop coming back to your site from lack of cost/benefit.
Well yes, JS is not the cause, but it's the tool that enables websites to invade their users privacy, eat their battery, and blink and slide and splash-screen ads from every angle. Before JS became so well suited for that task Flash was the main culprit. The web was better without a Flash plugin (and it still is).
Used "correctly" the web with JS is way better than the web without. There's plenty of sites that use JS great from actual apps to articles and tutorials with interactive examples. In fact personally I find myself disappointed when I see an article that would clearly be better with interactive diagrams but the authors are stuck thinking the web it just a transmitted book and not it's own medium but better strengths.
A couple of examples where IMO JS makes the page superior to one without
https://mattdesl.svbtle.com/drawing-lines-is-hard
If you acknowledge that javascript is not the problem (as it is just an implementation detail), then I'm curious if you still agree with your comment above that is complaining about javascript?
I just have an adblocker. Don't know how much better it looks for you, but this one looks great over here and I don't get to be the guy in every other HN post complaining a site doesn't work with JS disabled.
It doesn't seem to me that JS by itself is the issue here.
Re:How the Web Became Unreadable (2016)
by stephengillie on Thursday July 20, 2017 @02:32PM
(#14815120)
I just have JS disabled (whitelisting sites I do use) and the article displays cleanly and with no ads.
It's not like JavaScript is some virus or moral hazard. It's a tool, to be used when it's helpful, and discarded when it hinders.
Like everything, the ability to execute JavaScript is a tool I use to get what I want.