News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's Time To Stop Subsidising Mobile Phones by ZeroGravitas on Friday July 02, 2010 @08:49AM (#1480931)
There seems to be some confusion on this in the linked comments too, even though the very first commenter hit the nail on the head, but:

You don't need to pay for anything, including phones, up front any longer. Credit is (too) easily available and basically guaranteed to be cheaper and more flexible if you unbundle it from the actual purchase. These disguised loans should really only be attractive to people with low incomes and terrible credit ratings, and they will be taken advantage of because they have no other options.

The fact that you seem to be repulsed by the idea of paying amount $X for a phone, but think that paying that exact same sum, plus interest, plus hidden markup is acceptable as long as it's made complicated and so hidden in plain view is mind-boggling to me.

Re:It's Time To Stop Subsidising Mobile Phones by dagw on Friday July 02, 2010 @09:28AM (#1481041)
I was looking at some phones the other day and overheard a customer who agreed to basically pay 15$ more a month for the next two years, just so that they could avoid having to pay $120 up front. That sort of thinking is strange (unless you are a cell phone carrier, in which case it is awesome).
Re:It's Time To Stop Subsidising Mobile Phones by pbhjpbhj on Friday July 02, 2010 @10:15AM (#1481167)
So the answer is to extend your credit elsewhere and third the overall costs - which is fine if you have access to an easily extended line of credit.

It's not always going to be cheaper for everyone to pay up front but on the whole it does seem better.

Re:It's Time To Stop Subsidising Mobile Phones by dagw on Friday July 02, 2010 @10:24AM (#1481192)
If they are so poor that they absolutely cannot scrape together $120 then they really should be buying a $20-30 second hand phone and a pay-as-you-go plan. Committing to $30+ a month in those sort of financial situations is just a really bad idea.
Re:It's Time To Stop Subsidising Mobile Phones by mzl on Friday July 02, 2010 @10:28AM (#1481202)
While subsidized phones exist in Sweden, the interest is not nearly so bad. In fact, after my 18 month plan is up, I will have paid the same amount for the phone in increased monthly payments as if I had bought it directly. The uptake for the carrier is of course that I am locked into their service for 18 months. The base plan (without the phone payment) is only about $14 per month though for unlimited texts, 500 MiB data, and reasonably cheap phone calls, so I don't mind it.
Re:It's Time To Stop Subsidising Mobile Phones by mcknz on Friday July 02, 2010 @09:20AM (#1481016)
Correct, but convenience is a strong motivating factor -- why else would people pay 20-30% interest just to take their own money out of an ATM? Most people just want to get a phone with service, and don't really want to mess around with the specifics.
Re:It's Time To Stop Subsidising Mobile Phones by nijikunai on Friday July 02, 2010 @08:57AM (#1480947)
Though it's very bad for consumers, it's very advantageous for the carriers. By locking you to a particular plan they're making it hard for you to move to another carrier with cheaper plans.