You don't need to pay for anything, including phones, up front any longer. Credit is (too) easily available and basically guaranteed to be cheaper and more flexible if you unbundle it from the actual purchase. These disguised loans should really only be attractive to people with low incomes and terrible credit ratings, and they will be taken advantage of because they have no other options.
The fact that you seem to be repulsed by the idea of paying amount $X for a phone, but think that paying that exact same sum, plus interest, plus hidden markup is acceptable as long as it's made complicated and so hidden in plain view is mind-boggling to me.
It's not always going to be cheaper for everyone to pay up front but on the whole it does seem better.
We could probably get cars subsidized if we agreed to only purchase gas for a Ford from Mobil stations, and Toyotas could only by gas at BP stations. But why would we accept that?
More to the point, if phones/service was truly split up, and the majority of people bought there items separately, there would be more competition to drive phone prices down.
Local BestBuy here has a Spring Palm Pre - the older 8gb model - for (IIRC) $99 - but buying it without the 2 year service agreement, the 'suggested retail price' is $749. But it's still locked down - I can't buy it and use it on anything except Sprint, and I can't get any service from Sprint except for a 2 year service agreement anyway (IIRC).
What's also interesting is that the 'retail' price of the Pre seems to have gone up over time - last summer I could swear it was $599 or $649. It was $749 checking today.
Yes, Sprint may be a bad example here, but the gist is the same. If the voice service plans truly are subsidizing the cheap prices, give me an option to buy a full price phone and get service without the monthly service subsidy built in. My $39 voice plan should be $29 or $24 monthly if I'm not having to subsidize the phone price purchase.
In the Pre example, there's ostensibly a $650 'subsidy' for the Palm Pre, but I still can't get a used Pre and set it up with Sprint and get a cheaper 'unsubsidized' service plan. Over 2 years, I should be able to save $27/month without having to subsidize the original phone purchase price.
We're not given those options because the status quo is a combination which maximizes profit for the companies and presents the biggest barriers to people switching or canceling service.
I might pay that back over two years but I'd rather do that than put down $800 for a phone. I'm not even sure that I will pay it back because I am getting service in exchange for staying with AT&T for two years. I feel like I end up breaking even on this deal and if I lose a little then I'll live with it. I just can't put down $800 for an iPhone when I could get an iPad 3G for that.