A signature pad could work too; I think HelloSign has something like that. But it's not a great solution if you don't have a tablet, since it's really hard to draw a proper signature with a mouse. Honestly, even just adding a "handwriting font" might be good enough for most circumstances. Most of the document signing services provide this, and it could be implemented very quickly with minimal changes to your API.
If I were you, I would probably start with a handwriting font, and add hand-drawn signature support afterward. I would also look into what the law says about this sort of thing. I know that services like HelloSign require that you authorize them to use your signature in a legally-binding manner. But I don't know if that regulation would apply to your service, since your service is a lot more bare-bones. For example, you don't store the PDFs indefinitely, and you don't coordinate any sort of multi-party signature operation; that all happens out-of-band. So you might be in the clear.
The PDF Otter API powers the PDF editor advertised on the homepage. The editor is simple but I think its better than similar services because you don't need to sign up/pay to fill-in and download your PDF. I think there's a lot of potential out there for apps built on the API. Feel free to reach out to me at mariusz [at] pdfotter [dot] com if you have any questions or ideas!