News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by aero142 on Thursday July 01, 2010 @11:23PM (#1480061)
I find this line of thinking very disturbing. Mr. Grove follows others in believing a common fallacy, by ignoring secondary effects, and fails to see how issues in macroeconomics affect each other. Where to start...

The American standard of living is higher than China. In order for a worker in the US to continue to enjoy his standard of living and salary, she must contribute to creating something of value equal to what she consumes that is then exchanged at a market price(which determines it's value relative to goods/services created by others). When the US is a leader in technology and innovation, we create things that are very valuable, because rare and productive people make them, and trade them for other, largely commoditized goods, from poorer countries. The reason these commoditized goods are produced in poorer countries is because they can... The ability to produce them is well known so there is more competition, and therefor demand, and the price drops, along with the wages. If you work in a factory cheaply, you do so because replacing your skills in that factory is easy. There are many other people with that set of skills to replace you. The value you produce is cheaper, therefor you are paid less and have less to consume .

Now, back to Mr. Grove's statements. The factory jobs left the United States because wages were higher here than there. It's that simple, but where he goes wrong is say that "managers were happy", which is not quite as harsh, but very close to the usual line, which attributes the offshoring to "greed". Not quite. If an American company has to produce it's goods in a factory where people make 2x the salary of the same good in China, the goods will cost more to buy. If the American company, doesn't outsource, and a Chinese company is able to produce the same or similar good(think commodity again), then they will be undercut in the market and go out of business. Not only will management be un-"happy", but the US as a whole is worse off because the profits now go to a Chinese company instead of an American one. The US has now lost not only the manufacturing jobs, but the high value add jobs as well. Mr. Groves proposes the "solution" that we tax imports and use the proceeds promote American production. This merely shifts the money around. Those imported goods were cheaper than their American counterpart. Assuming current wages remain the same, it now cost more dollars to purchase that good because of the tariff and American's have less stuff because it is more expensive relative to their salary. The other option(without the tariff), is that the American factory worker cannot find other work that will pay him more, so he agrees to accept lower wages for performing that same job here and can therefor buy less stuff. I believe that these, as a whole, offset one another and are probably net a wash.

As for unemployment, I believe that it is caused by many different things, probably many reasons that are poorly understood, but I'll address a few of them that I think are important here. Unemployment can be caused by temporary mismatches between market demands for goods and supply of those goods. Demand changes, prices change, companies don't require as many employees to produce the goods(this can also be caused by changes in the efficiency of production), and people are fired. There may not be a job in their previous line of work. If there is some other skill set which is in demand, that person can learn a new skill and make whatever salary the market demand supports for that skill. It is also possible that the market will not support the workers previous salary. Labor costs go down, but here is where people usually go wrong. When labor costs drop, it becomes affordable to pay people to do things that you might have automated(for a high cost in machinery or software for example). Or, the market might now support the cost of producing a good which must be done with tedious manual labor. Or, if the American worker is more efficient than his Chinese counterpart, then it might be cheaper to start doing manufacturing in the US again. In other words, as wages drop, the unemployment rate will go down, and less will be outsourced. This is just the tradeoff. The fact that jobs are sent to China means that cheaper goods are available here in the US. Mr. Groves states that the trend is towards an economy where there are high value add jobs and high unemployment. This is true only if current wages hold. If wages drop, then outsourcing makes less sense and unemployment picks up. What we really want is lots of high value add jobs here. This comes through innovation, creativity, a highly skilled and motivated workforce and outsourcing production(if it makes sense) to cheaper markets.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by nl on Friday July 02, 2010 @01:37AM (#1480317)
In other words, as wages drop, the unemployment rate will go down, and less will be outsourced. This is just the tradeoff.

You make that sound so simple.

You left out the bit about that meaning falling standards of living, and the social dislocation that causes.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by aero142 on Friday July 02, 2010 @11:12AM (#1481338)
I really hope that things don't change and the US continues to be a location for these high value jobs. Yes, this is very hard to maintain. I couldn't agree more. The point I am trying to make is that outsourcing is a sign that the US has a high value workforce because they can make more money doing things other than working in chinese style factories, which are very low value add jobs. All the consequences you list are correct, and I don't want them to happen, but tariffs are not going to lock in our current high standard of living.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by lokiujhytyu on Friday July 02, 2010 @02:20AM (#1480385)
>falling standards of living

You mean only being able to buy a 27" TV for $1000 instead of a 50" one? Or having to stick with a 3G phone for another year before getting a 4G one?

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by AlisdairO on Friday July 02, 2010 @06:53AM (#1480736)
Inability to buy gadgets is unlikely to be the main problem - it's not like gadgets are a huge proportion of the expenditure of poor people right now. The problem that will be created is extremely high wage mismatch between the highly educated, and those that are not able to achieve such a high level of education.

This is a problem for a variety of reasons. The poor are, of course, less able to compete for scarce resources such as housing (particularly in cramped places like the UK), healthcare, high quality education, etc. This uncompetitiveness isn't too bad in places with reasonably limited income inequality, but as the inequality scales up becomes a really serious issue. All of this is a bad recipe for social stability - as being part of society becomes less beneficial for the poor, more and more will choose to live outside it.

Over time, income inequality also leads to poor social mobility, which is a real issue with keeping a country competitive.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by Tichy on Friday July 02, 2010 @07:50AM (#1480824)
But the next elephant in the room: suppose with a huge effort, you build a factory that employs all the 100 million (or whatever) uneducated people in your country. Then these people have a steady income and decide to have children. In a couple of years, you suddenly have 400 million uneducated people. Then what? (I don't know a proper answer - simply throwing more money at education seems unlikely to work...).
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by AlisdairO on Friday July 02, 2010 @10:38AM (#1481237)
That's not really too much of an elephant. Most western countries have sub-replacement birth rates right now, and this effect seems to occur a short while after countries develop.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by patrickk on Friday July 02, 2010 @05:51AM (#1480661)
"What we really want is lots of high value add jobs here. This comes through innovation, creativity, a highly skilled and motivated workforce...."

This is what most of the Western world wants, yet it is very difficult to achieve this - largely because of education. Most of the West, not just America, wants the bulk of it's jobs in high value-added positions because of labour costs arbitrage which many companies are forced to engage in because of intense competition. Where education is concerned, some people don't want to go to college, some aren't suited to it and well, funding education is damn expensive and the pressure on politicians to cut educational spending (which takes a long time to payoff) is huge. So you are never going to get all of the workforce in the country to work in high value-add roles, for various reasons.

I was fascinated by this interview with Andy Grove, because I had read an interview with Craig Barrett (current as chairman of Intel) who took a largely polar opposite view to what Grove has said in this article. Barrett was talking about how Ireland must change in order to move out of recession. I think he would be appalled at the notion of the US entering into a fully-blown trade war with China, as Grove advocates.

Barrett quote [on Ireland]: What I said is that [having] smart people (good education) is important, smart ideas (investment in research) is important, and then letting smart people get together with smart ideas to do something is the third thing (the environment). The very same could just as easily apply to the US.

Full article here (a very good read): http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/finance/2010/0212/122426...

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by rbranson on Thursday July 01, 2010 @11:56PM (#1480120)
He agrees with you. You both come to the same conclusion. What you fail to realize is that we've essentially paid the capital to educate people and build infrastructure in another country. Once their wages rise and our massive capital investments no longer make economic sense, they've gained these, and we are stuck without domestic manufacturing capacity. Essentially, we are mortgaging our future.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by aero142 on Friday July 02, 2010 @12:34AM (#1480183)
I don't think that we do. My post was largely spent explaining why jobs move overseas, which is not the same as agreeing on what to do about it. He concludes that protectionist policies will result in manufacturing jobs staying in the US, but doesn't look past that to see that those policies will not create value and will just redistribute it around by moving the wage decreases to tariff increases. Wealth comes from innovation and productivity increases. You cannot "create jobs" by instituting tariffs.

We will not be left with no domestic manufacturing, we will be left with the manufacturing that we are most efficient at. Anything else is just fighting gravity. We need to be making tomorrow's jobs, not fighting over yesterday's. Tariffs will not solve unemployment.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by codexon on Friday July 02, 2010 @01:30AM (#1480296)
You cannot "create jobs" by instituting tariffs.

You can't create jobs through tariffs, but you can shift the balance towards the US.

China keeps artificially inflating their currency when it would've naturally increased by now; maybe to the point of being economically infeasible for some companies. Don't forget that there is a huge overhead in shipping products across the Pacific Ocean.

And to fight this economic manipulation, tariffs are needed.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by rbranson on Friday July 02, 2010 @01:02AM (#1480235)
They will only be setup to be more efficient because of our capital investment though. We have lost these assets because their only justification was based on the predicate of suppressed wages, which are temporary. This is a fools game.