I think one way to answer this is by analogy to farming. Every year, less and less of our food is touched by human hands on its way to the market.
According to the USDA, in 1900 41% of the American workforce was employed in agriculture. If you went back to 1900 and told a farmer that fewer than 2% of Americans would be involved in the production of food in 100 years, would he believe you?
This tectonic change has gone unnoticed by most because displaced agricultural workers have been able to find gainful employment elsewhere. The whole issue here, I think, is what we'll do when most of the productive labor across all economic sectors isn't needed anymore. So yes, in that sense, whether we use 99% automated domestic factories or whether we build 99% of our stuff overseas, I think we'll reach that point.
And he would be wise not to... well at least not if you add Farmville numbers in there.
I suspect war will remain a popular pastime.
Exactly -- science led to technology which led to job creation. That's the whole story of the 20th century, with a couple of wars tossed in to keep things moving.
Meanwhile, in 2010, science and technology are just two more things most Americans take for granted. We still have to fight the Scopes monkey trial every few years, we couldn't get back to the Moon with any less time and money than it took the first time, and especially since 9/11, we're no longer a place where the world's STEM students come to study and live.
That farmer from 1900 would say we're "eating our seed corn."
You're actually very wrong about foreign STEM students (every US graduate school is filled with Chinese grad students and post-docs), but that's neither here nor there. One of the main points of the article was that it gets harder to educate a new generation of high-tech workers when the industries that have all of the institutional knowledge out-source that knowledge to China.
Middle-achieving Chinese students have an incentive to come to the US for higher education -- it helps them get jobs back home. What incentive to middle-achieving American kids have, when the bottom 95% of high-tech jobs are sent to China?
The unspoken Myth of economics is that just because we've transitioned from an agrarian to an industrial economy in the past, we'll be forever able to use efficiency improvements to drive employment in the future. In real life, it's just plainly, obviously untrue. If nothing else, the simple fact that human intelligence follows a bell-curve should tell us that there's always going to be a large class of people who cannot function at the highest level of production. Those people need factory jobs, or farming jobs, or other lower-skill industries that pay a decent salary.
Well said. The jobs we're creating are achievable to a progressively smaller segment of the population, and that's a huge problem.
I wonder if as we run out of easily-mineable resources, we'll start creating low-skilled jobs again, in the recycling of the already-mined resources - garbage mining, effectively. If China's hold on rare earth metals, for example, continues to increase, I can imagine this being an important job area.
I challenge the idea that this is a "simple fact", rather that it's even true at all. How do you know? Right now it may appear so because so many schools grade on a bell curve (i.e. no other outcome is possible). In my experience, aside from people with genuine disorders, everyone has a similar (high) potential. The majority are just not properly stimulated. Maybe they have bad teachers, bad parents or are just lazy but if they were properly motivated they could achieve much more than they do.
Personally I find ideas like "the simple fact that human intelligence follows a bell-curve" dangerous. You're framing the potential of a whole species and people tend to assume this is true and act accordingly (e.g. grading on a bell curve).
Am I?
(every US graduate school is filled with Chinese grad students and post-docs), but that's neither here nor there
What happens immediately after they graduate?
Yes.
"What happens immediately after they graduate?"
It depends greatly on where they're from, and what they've been studying. A lot of my Chinese colleagues have gone back to China...because there are jobs there, and not here.
Which I think you'll find was my exact point. We may still be the world's standard in STEM education, but we aren't necessarily benefiting from that position.
The world's best students come here to study, but not to live.
That's the quote from your original comment -- the one to which I was replying. So, while you may have meant to say something else, I don't see that in the text. If anything, now you seem to be contradicting your earlier remark.
Also, re-reading the original comment, I get the impression that you're arguing that we're falling behind in science and tech because of a cultural failure -- a lack of societal focus on science and technology. I don't think that's true for a variety of reasons, but the big one is the same argument raised by the article: we've out-sourced generations of technical expertise. There's little incentive for the foreign grad student to stay here, when the jobs are over there. The jobs are there because we sent them there, not because we've stopped educating American students.
btw, do you ever think we'll reach a point where it will be common to have 99.9%+ automated factories? (robotic, possibly even full input/output lifecyle & distribution, etc.)