News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by CamperBob on Thursday July 01, 2010 @10:25PM (#1479942)
The real elephant in the room, which Grove and practically everybody else knows very well but refuses to talk about, is that nobody starts a company to employ people. People start a company to make stuff. To the extent this can be done with fewer people, this is always a good thing from that company's perspective, with no exceptions I can think of offhand. People suck, and you don't want to deal with them if you can help it. Just as factory farmers would love to be able to grow meat in vats without dealing with the messy parts of animal welfare and husbandry, most managers would love to be able to carry out their missions with fewer people. This is a simple reality of productive life, not a question of social morality or human values.

Why does it make sense for companies like Foxconn to take on more and more of our high-tech manufacturing work? Simply because, in contrast to most of the twentieth century, most consumer products are built pretty much the same these days. There is absolutely nothing about a PS3 that requires different components, production lines, or assembly techniques from a desktop PC. There is nothing about an iPhone that justifies building it in a factory that doesn't also make pocket calculators, handheld game consoles, or, hell, competing phones such as Droids. Massive contraction and consolidation of the manufacturing sector, whether here or elsewhere, is both desirable and inevitable. Right now this is true of high-tech items but soon enough, it will be evident enough across the spectrum of durable goods.

This wasn't the case when producing a new widget required a lot of custom tool and die work, specialized worker training, or the development of advanced processes unique to that widget. For a drop-dead awesome example of what I'm talking about, look at the processes Tektronix had to develop in the 1960s in order to build CRTs for their oscilloscopes: http://classictek.org/index.php?option=com_seyret&Itemid... (Flash required)

Grove is basically saying we need to start more companies that "scale up" to require factories where people sit doing stuff like what's seen in that video. He's wrong. Today, if I design a better oscilloscope, I'd be out of my mind if I didn't find a way to use the same generic LCD panels that Chinese factories produce by the tens of millions for sale to everyone from Apple to Boeing. And when my hypothetical design is complete, it will use at most one or two custom ASICs (the fewer the better -- I'll use FPGAs if I can), and Foxconn can start building it as soon as they finish their rush order of iPhone 5G Extremes.

I have a lot of respect for Grove, but as a captain of industry, he's fighting the last war. His subtextual premise is dead-on, though: we need to figure out how to put 200,000,000 underemployed US workers to good use, or things are going to suck.

To me, it's obvious what the future of mass production will look like, but it's not at all clear how to stave off a future where 10% of us are shouldering the entire productivity burden for the rest of the country.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by 3d3mon on Friday July 02, 2010 @01:09AM (#1480249)
> Grove is basically saying we need to start more companies that "scale up" to require factories where people sit doing stuff like what's seen in that video. He's wrong.

You have to give Grove more credit than that. Obviously, he does not want to create clock-punching jobs just for the sake of having clock-punching jobs. Grove is known to run a tight ship. His example of the alternative energy space is a perfect one demonstrating the inability of even new industries invented in the US to remain here. All the "scaling" happens in China, leaving little secondary benefits to the innovating nation. Why can't your oscilloscope be made here? Sure, they have the know-how, but so do we. They have assembly lines, so can we. In theory there shouldn't be a problem. But in the real world, we know the playing field isn't level. Like how China allows externalities to develop by quashing labor/worker conditions and the environment to create the perfect arbitrage situation for offshoring US entrepreneurs. Can't forget their dollar/yuan "managed" exchange rate. Again, they are subsidizing the offshoring startup. China has clearly stacked the deck hence the inevitability of your oscilloscope being made overseas. This is by design and its all policy-driven. Should the US sit idly by as a de facto trade war is staring at them in the face? Or should they follow through with the offshore tariff that Andy suggested? Controversial, no doubt, but one must do whatever it takes to win a war.

CB, you make good business argument for the current microeconomic behavior of firms but you must put on a political-economic hat and think decades down the road to really get at his thinking (and he's as sharp as they come). I believe Andy is being long term greedy. He's fighting the next war.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by stretchwithme on Saturday July 03, 2010 @05:36PM (#1484522)
"Can't forget their dollar/yuan "managed" exchange rate"

A currency tied to the dollar is not a subsidy, any more than a common currency between New York and New Jersey is a subsidy for New Jersey exports.

Borrowing creates trade deficits. The US has been borrowing massive amounts to simulate prosperity.

When you borrow for the sake of consumption, you import a lot and export a lot less.

It doesn't matter what other countries do. What matters are the choices we make for ourselves. And massive government borrowing and super low rates are bad choices with bad consequences.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by CamperBob on Friday July 02, 2010 @01:39AM (#1480321)
My real point, though, is that consolidation is inevitable. Production jobs ("Scaling," etc.) are going to become less important over time, not more important, whether they're in China or America. Any forward-looking argument that doesn't take that fact into account is flawed from the outset, and I think Grove's piece falls into that category.

Is it really healthy for Silicon Valley if Apple has a factory cranking out iPhones in Cupertino, Google has a 99%-identical factory for Droids in Mountain View, and Palm has yet another factory producing Pres in Sunnyvale? What's the point? The hardware's all very similar from a production viewpoint, or it soon will be. In a rational business climate, all of these products would be made on the same line, by a company that sells manufacturing capability to the highest bidder. Competition will happen on a purely IP-based playing field, not on the factory floor.

Going back to the Tektronix example, when Tektronix finished one of those CRTs, they practically had a one-of-a-kind relic on their hands, a part that would not only not fit in any one else's oscilloscope, but could in most cases be used only in a single model in their own product line. They didn't have what we'd call excess capacity, and if they did, they darned sure wouldn't use it selling excess tubes to the competition, because those tubes were a big part of what made their overall product competitive. So every manufacturer of those particular widgets had to either build their own CRTs or buy them from a common vendor (in which case their scopes sucked).

Tektronix in 1960 couldn't afford to treat production as a red-headed stepchild in their overall business plan... but they sure can today, when the bulk of the test equipment they sell is OEM'ed out of China just like everything else. Sorry, but IMHO, the production of solar panels, portable fusion reactors, or whatever is just going to take the same inevitable course. The business will be commoditized if it prospers at all. Trade policies and externalities have absolutely nothing to do with that.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by Kadin on Friday July 02, 2010 @03:12AM (#1480479)
> Is it really healthy for Silicon Valley if Apple has a factory cranking out iPhones in Cupertino

You're begging the question; there is a country beyond Silicon Valley, and Grove's argument is that what is best for Silicon Valley (meaning, the bottom lines of a few tech firms which together only employ a small percentage of the U.S. population) isn't necessarily what is best for the country as a whole.

Put more directly, it's not clear that there are enough IP-based jobs to keep the United States at or near full employment. To do that, which we need for social stability, because high unemployment is intensely corrosive, we need to capture some of those manufacturing jobs. And it might be worth doing things that hurt tech companies' profitability in the short term -- taxing outsourced manufacturing, for instance -- in order to achieve that.

If we don't, the "rational business climate" might drive all the manufacturing overseas, leaving the U.S. with a very small number of employed people doing the design work, and hordes of disaffected, unemployable people with nothing to do. As you point out, once you have the production line set up in China, it makes sense to just scale it out there rather than build a second one here.

The long-term social effects of such a 90/10 split would be very bad, and would in all likelihood eventually make it very hard to be very profitable at all. So it might make sense for IP-centric design companies to take a short-term hit and try to maintain something closer to full employment, lest they find themselves first up against the wall when the welfare proletariat they created revolts.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by yummyfajitas on Friday July 02, 2010 @12:04PM (#1481454)
Suppose, hypothetically, that we really do reach a stage where we have a small number of highly productive individuals and a large number of unskilled people without manufacturing work to do.

In that case, it is likely that the skilled will hire the unskilled as servants, making the skilled people even more productive (every hour spent doing laundry is an hour spent not designing the latest iPhone). People will probably also work fewer hours, and take productivity gains in the form of leisure rather than money.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by _delirium on Friday July 02, 2010 @06:26PM (#1482573)
If there's ever a situation where the majority of Americans are working as mere servants for the wealthy, I think simply taking the wealthy's money and redistributing it will be the more likely outcome, and that's if it's done peacefully. A situation like India's, where there's such huge income inequality that there's strongly differentiated classes, between the servants and the people who have lots of servants, isn't sustainable. People are only willing to protect the prerogatives of the wealthy if they think that overall the system is reasonably fair, supports opportunity and income mobility, has benefits trickle down substantially to everyone, etc.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by Vivtek on Sunday July 04, 2010 @08:15AM (#1485558)
Y'know, if you really think that's inevitable, you could <i>try</i> living in the Third World for a while and see how well that works out for you.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by 3d3mon on Friday July 02, 2010 @04:49AM (#1480597)
> Trade policies and externalities have absolutely nothing to do with that.

You're right on that since we're clearly talking past each other :-) Yes, businesses become commodities over time. We agree here. However this is orthogonal to innovation and job creation. If an old mature industry is on its last throes, then by all means, farm that out. Those jobs are gone. But that's not what we're talking about here. We're talking about new industries that if they can stay put for even say 5-10 years could provide immense benefits to the innovating nation. It keeps the middle class healthy and prevents the have/have-not scenario that you mentioned as troublesome. I share those same concerns. It also creates an in-house knowledge base for future innovation and an investing base for venture capital formation (think Paypal/Google mafia). It also has the effect of incenting the country to implement pro-innovation policies to continually lay those golden eggs. A virtuous cycle if I ever saw one.

Now enter the bureaucrats in Beijing who have created their own "incentives". The main one being cost which they obtain by mortgaging their labor/environment and toying with the exchange rate. These aren't truly economic advantages but are really artificial rules put in place by a planning committee for national interest. Government intervention if you will. Entrepreneurs and startups who must factor in cost to any decision are thus improperly incented to quickly offshore. Thus we have the familiar story of "we innovate and they get the jobs" This is why Grove said creating more startups won't do anything to help US unemployment since they do their scaling elsewhere. The proper course of action is for China to due away with their policies but we can't make them. This is game theory folks. The unfortunate reality is that the rules of engagement are written by bureaucrats and Grove is saying if China is playing that game we must too.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by binaryfinery on Friday July 02, 2010 @02:12PM (#1481844)
Except that if we do, China will simply stop recycling its share of our government debt and the US government defaults. It will take a president with huge balls to call China on its trade war, and risk having to monetize that debt.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by linhares on Saturday July 03, 2010 @05:23PM (#1484496)
As of now, if I remember correctly, China has over 2 Trillion greenbacks. It's _impossible_ to win a trade war. We're talking about something _very_ much like this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suez_Crisis#Financial_pressure

It is easy to be protectionist. But a major selloff of the USD by China would create the mother of all confidence crises, and, while _everyone_ would lose, the world's reserve currency, the USD, would be forever damaged.

This is not a war you can realistically fight to win. I really expected more from someone of Grove's intellect. Much much more.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by binaryfinery on Thursday July 08, 2010 @02:30PM (#1498297)
"Damaged" i.e. lose a lot of value. Precisely. We could no longer afford to buy goods from China, Japan, etc. China doesn't have the internal economy to risk that. Yet. US manufacturing, and the US social fabric, would win win win. This is absolutely a war we can fight to win. And win it we must.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by todayiamme on Friday July 02, 2010 @02:22AM (#1480392)
I know I am repeating myself#, but why do we make more stuff? To make even more stuff?

Isn't all of this a really circular argument? I am really sorry, but I am extremely confused about what you are trying to say over here. :(

I know it's extremely stupid of me to ask this, but how is any method of mass production built upon exploiting people whether they are on a piece of land called the united states of america, or china or india help anyone in the longer term?

# http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1479902

----

Edit: I am sorry if this strikes you as an inane question/off-topic, but I ask this for a reason. The OP states that;

>>>To me, it's obvious what the future of mass production will look like, but it's not at all clear how to stave off a future where 10% of us are shouldering the entire productivity burden for the rest of the country.<<<

That is the conclusion only if you accept that the only way for us to function is to make more new stuff and to consume that new stuff. I somehow don't understand that.

I cannot understand why we have accepted an endless cycle that dwindles our resources as the only means to make a contribution? How do you define the value of all of these things that we churn out in the longer term? By measuring their impact on human beings? By their impact on the environment? By their impact on us? By productivity increased through that device? Some standard of living increased for the shorter term by it?

I want to make beautiful things, but I have to ask myself the question; am I creating wealth? Some would argue that wall street creates wealth (parts of it certainly do, but not all of it). However, everything here is dependent on the assumption that the money that is being generated here is wealth, and that the only way to do this is by earning more money. The only way to do that is to make and sell more stuff, which leads to more money, and so on.

I am not saying manufacturing is evil. It isn't. Neither is capitalism or any other ideology. I am merely questioning the ends for which it is being used. People have argued over the centuries that an action itself is stripped of being right and wrong, but it is the context in which it is performed, due to what intention and what effect that makes it good or evil.

So, as someone who doesn't know anything I just want to ask; why?

I am truly sorry if this is something not suited for this space.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by Roboprog on Friday July 02, 2010 @10:14AM (#1481163)
I believe he was talking about a national policy, not a corporate policy.

The idea that we, as a nation, somehow resist the neo-colonialism known as "free trade", and, as Mr Grove says, fight a trade war TO WIN.

Corporations are legally obligated to make the biggest profit they can, which implies cutting costs any way that they legally can (so long as the cuts do not disproportionately impact gross incomes). No one is suggesting that we ask companies to invent charitable make-work.

I believe what he finally gets to at the end of the essay is to suggest that we, as a society, provide financial disincentives to offshore work, and incentives to do the work within our own country.

People making $40,000 per year are much more likely to buy your stuff than people making $20,000 (or $0), and are less likely to crash your gated villa, even if it costs 20 to 50 percent more. He also mentions that doing the grunt work trains (st least some -- enough) people to do the more creative stuff later.

Don't worry, though. The multi-national corporations so own our government, so it's doubtful our national self-interest is going to have much influence anyway. You can continue living the libertarian dream. Unless you end up being one of the untouchables. Ouch.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by cageface on Thursday July 01, 2010 @10:52PM (#1480001)
For an eerily prophetic look at this from 1849 read John Ruskin's The Seven Lamps of Architecture: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Seven_Lamps_of_Architecture

If you're currently making a living doing creative, intellectual work (like programming), count yourself lucky to be among the few remaining craftsmen in the world.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by ebiester on Friday July 02, 2010 @07:07AM (#1480758)
The first thing we do is kill all the robots...

If we honestly look at things right now, the only reason these jobs haven't been automated is because we have people so cheap. Even so, in the US, if you strip away the metajobs: service, marketing, entertainment... our infrastructure and creation now is around ten percent of the population. [citation needed.] http://www.yesvirginia.org/Images/charts/EmploymentMajorSect... shows 24% of the working population in manufacturing, construction, IT, and educational/health services. This does not count the unemployed and children.

We are hurdling toward a world where fewer than a quarter of the population are required to maintain the society.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by say_ on Friday July 02, 2010 @08:37AM (#1480902)
I can't wait. The more people that can focus on making things that we want instead of things that we need, the better.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by pstuart on Thursday July 01, 2010 @10:36PM (#1479962)
Why not focus on how to make stuff more efficiently locally, i.e., robotics? At least that could keep some manufacturing jobs local.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by Kadin on Friday July 02, 2010 @03:20AM (#1480492)
I recently read an interesting book by the guy who runs Sherline, a U.S. manufacturer of small lathes and milling machines.

The book is sort of a meandering opus covering basic machining techniques but also talking about the history of the company and how the business was built. A lot of it involves finding ways to use technology and advanced manufacturing methods to keep U.S. manufacture competitive with Asian imports.

E.g., the Sherline mill is built on an aluminum extrusion filled with some sort of epoxy/concrete for rigidity. Most Asian lathes are built on castings which are machined to final specifications. The Sherline method is more difficult and requires more capital investment, but requires less labor.

Basically in every case he mentions, the way you keep a U.S. based company competitive with Asia is by engineering away all the labor. What you do with 15 people in an Asian factory using 100-year-old methods you do with one guy and millions of dollars worth of state-of-the-art tooling in a U.S. one. And even then it might only buy you a few years of competitiveness, until that machinery can get moved over to Asia and installed, and then they beat you based on the cost of the one guy.

Anyway, it's an interesting book if you're interested in that sort of thing but doesn't do much to restore my confidence that we're not engaged in a race to the bottom as a country.

(Link to book: http://www.sherline.com/bookplug.htm)

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by kiba on Thursday July 01, 2010 @10:50PM (#1479991)
You mean 3D printers like Cupcake CNC from Makerbot Inc? It's already happening to some extent. People, more than ever before, are accumulating technical skills in their hobby time.

At least some of them will be able to accumulate enough knowledge to build something cool, kits, startups, or something else.

Eventually, you'll end up with a scavenging masses that scavenge junks thrown out by the Doctors, Lawyers, movie stars, and all sort of non-technical people of the world.

It'll be an interesting world to see half of society built on high tech junks and sophisticated hacking.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by rbranson on Thursday July 01, 2010 @10:43PM (#1479979)
This is exactly the problem. The cost of labor is a cop-out for short-term profit. Industries where the cost of shipping exceeds the savings in off-shore labor almost always find a way to automate labor and eliminate these costs.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by CamperBob on Thursday July 01, 2010 @10:40PM (#1479974)
I think that's a valid point, but it will quickly devolve into an argument as to where the robots should be built. It still won't magically add any objective value to your product just to have the nuts and bolts tightened in your hometown.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by rbranson on Thursday July 01, 2010 @10:45PM (#1479980)
You're confusing a capital investment (the robots) with cost-of-goods-sold (the widgets). Automated manufacturing systems are complex systems that require highly trained individuals to maintain and operate, while reducing the total labor cost. In addition, if more manufacturing utilized these systems, scales of economy could be reached that would allow them to be more modular and commoditized.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by CamperBob on Thursday July 01, 2010 @11:11PM (#1480036)
Automated manufacturing systems are complex systems that require highly trained individuals to maintain and operate, while reducing the total labor cost.

For now.

Also, keep in mind that everything I said about it being economically undesirable to employ human labor in production goes out the window when there are a billion workers available who have nowhere to go but up. There is no (natural) law that says that our robots will be any more economical than low-cost Chinese workers, even though they might be more economical than high-cost American workers.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by rbranson on Thursday July 01, 2010 @11:32PM (#1480080)
It's all "for now." Eventually we will exhaust the Earth's resources and possibly become enslaved by a race of artificial intelligence, but I'm not pretending to even think about solutions to those problems.

It'd also be cheaper to have slaves, but we don't do that either. The ends do not justify the means. In order for capitalism to be effective at increasing standard-of-living across the board and allocate resources and capital efficiently, it must be tempered with rules that set limits on what avenues are pursued for profit.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by lokiujhytyu on Friday July 02, 2010 @12:49AM (#1480210)
The only purpose of a public company is to make money for shareholders.

Not make stuff, not employ people, not even turn a profit - just increase the share price / pay dividends

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by ericd on Friday July 02, 2010 @01:11AM (#1480254)
This is an extremist point of view. Realistically they have a lot of purposes that should be kept in mind.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by lokiujhytyu on Friday July 02, 2010 @02:17AM (#1480381)
When you become a director of a company you have a legal duty to "enhance shareholder value" thats the only rule.

Anything else you do, every hire, every contract, every charity donation must be justifiable in this context - unless you enjoy shareholder lawsuits.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by Kadin on Friday July 02, 2010 @03:35AM (#1480511)
This is false. You have a duty to do what the shareholders want you to do and what is in their best interest, but you are allowed to use your own judgement to a great extent to determine what that might be.

There is a great deal of caselaw dealing with this (you can google "shareholder primacy" if you want to jump in) but it is anything but clear cut.

If the duty of directors to shareholders was as absolute as many people on the Internet think it is, companies would have to shut down and go into liquidation every time their market cap dropped below book value. But they don't (even, in some cases, when some investors might prefer it) because directors have the prerogative to seek long term gains at the expense of short term ones.

(They also have the prerogative to do the opposite, and the market unfortunately tends to reward it, but there are many exceptions.)

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by yardie on Friday July 02, 2010 @05:21AM (#1480628)
Can you point this out in a legal brief, law book, SEC ruling? something?

I believe the only thing legal you are required to do is not to defraud your shareholders. Any idiot can, legally, run a company into the ground.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by gaius on Monday July 05, 2010 @05:24AM (#1487788)
The phrase you are looking for is "fiduciary responsibility". You can just Google it: http://www.efmoody.com/arbitration/fiduciary.html
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by _delirium on Friday July 02, 2010 @06:29PM (#1482583)
In particular, if that were the only justification for corporations, we wouldn't have them. There would be no reason not to abolish them. The argument for permitting corporations is that they have a lot of benefits, such as, for example, creating jobs.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by codexon on Friday July 02, 2010 @01:19AM (#1480275)
To me, it's obvious what the future of mass production will look like, but it's not at all clear how to stave off a future where 10% of us are shouldering the entire productivity burden for the rest of the country.

Extrapolating your logic, that 10% will probably shrink to 1%.

And chances are, you or your descendants probably won't be part of that 1%.

Grove isn't saying that we should have more mundane manufacturing jobs. He is saying there is a problem with stratification when 1% of people make all the money while the other 99% are left unemployed because they couldn't patent X technology 1 day faster, or didn't beat the other 99% of applicants for the rare number of jobs left.

Whether or not the only solution to this is to artificially preserve mundane manufacturing jobs is another matter.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by say_ on Friday July 02, 2010 @08:56AM (#1480942)
The solutions are welfare and subsidies for education.

Creativity in business requires a fair amount of luck. The successful 1% will need to be drawn from a large, educated, middle class. Even if most people end up striking out, it will be in our best interest to keep as many people within striking distance as possible.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by mkramlich on Thursday July 01, 2010 @11:19PM (#1480051)
great comment!

btw, do you ever think we'll reach a point where it will be common to have 99.9%+ automated factories? (robotic, possibly even full input/output lifecyle & distribution, etc.)

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by CamperBob on Thursday July 01, 2010 @11:36PM (#1480086)
btw, do you ever think we'll reach a point where it will be common to have 99.9%+ automated factories? (robotic, possibly even full input/output lifecyle & distribution, etc.)

I think one way to answer this is by analogy to farming. Every year, less and less of our food is touched by human hands on its way to the market.

According to the USDA, in 1900 41% of the American workforce was employed in agriculture. If you went back to 1900 and told a farmer that fewer than 2% of Americans would be involved in the production of food in 100 years, would he believe you?

This tectonic change has gone unnoticed by most because displaced agricultural workers have been able to find gainful employment elsewhere. The whole issue here, I think, is what we'll do when most of the productive labor across all economic sectors isn't needed anymore. So yes, in that sense, whether we use 99% automated domestic factories or whether we build 99% of our stuff overseas, I think we'll reach that point.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by dasil003 on Friday July 02, 2010 @12:09AM (#1480141)
If you went back to 1900 and told a farmer that fewer than 2% of Americans would be involved in the production of food in 100 years, would he believe you?

And he would be wise not to... well at least not if you add Farmville numbers in there.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by rbranson on Thursday July 01, 2010 @11:48PM (#1480105)
Many of them shifted into fields that didn't exist in 1900 because in 1900, food and shelter were the majority of what people in the US worked for.
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by adammichaelc on Friday July 02, 2010 @12:44AM (#1480198)
I wonder if something similar will happen in the future, except replacing "food and shelter" with "food, shelter, manufacturing, electronics, clothes, etc.". Would new industries then come out of the ashes of manual labor in these different fields?
Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by Kadin on Friday July 02, 2010 @03:24AM (#1480496)
You still need raw materials for those factories.

I suspect war will remain a popular pastime.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by CamperBob on Friday July 02, 2010 @12:44AM (#1480196)
Many of them shifted into fields that didn't exist in 1900 because in 1900, food and shelter were the majority of what people in the US worked for.

Exactly -- science led to technology which led to job creation. That's the whole story of the 20th century, with a couple of wars tossed in to keep things moving.

Meanwhile, in 2010, science and technology are just two more things most Americans take for granted. We still have to fight the Scopes monkey trial every few years, we couldn't get back to the Moon with any less time and money than it took the first time, and especially since 9/11, we're no longer a place where the world's STEM students come to study and live.

That farmer from 1900 would say we're "eating our seed corn."

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by timr on Friday July 02, 2010 @04:24AM (#1480565)
"Meanwhile, in 2010, science and technology are just two more things most Americans take for granted. We still have to fight the Scopes monkey trial every few years, we couldn't get back to the Moon with any less time and money than it took the first time, and especially since 9/11, we're no longer a place where the world's STEM students come to study and live."

You're actually very wrong about foreign STEM students (every US graduate school is filled with Chinese grad students and post-docs), but that's neither here nor there. One of the main points of the article was that it gets harder to educate a new generation of high-tech workers when the industries that have all of the institutional knowledge out-source that knowledge to China.

Middle-achieving Chinese students have an incentive to come to the US for higher education -- it helps them get jobs back home. What incentive to middle-achieving American kids have, when the bottom 95% of high-tech jobs are sent to China?

The unspoken Myth of economics is that just because we've transitioned from an agrarian to an industrial economy in the past, we'll be forever able to use efficiency improvements to drive employment in the future. In real life, it's just plainly, obviously untrue. If nothing else, the simple fact that human intelligence follows a bell-curve should tell us that there's always going to be a large class of people who cannot function at the highest level of production. Those people need factory jobs, or farming jobs, or other lower-skill industries that pay a decent salary.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by AlisdairO on Friday July 02, 2010 @07:01AM (#1480751)
"If nothing else, the simple fact that human intelligence follows a bell-curve should tell us that there's always going to be a large class of people who cannot function at the highest level of production. Those people need factory jobs, or farming jobs, or other lower-skill industries that pay a decent salary."

Well said. The jobs we're creating are achievable to a progressively smaller segment of the population, and that's a huge problem.

I wonder if as we run out of easily-mineable resources, we'll start creating low-skilled jobs again, in the recycling of the already-mined resources - garbage mining, effectively. If China's hold on rare earth metals, for example, continues to increase, I can imagine this being an important job area.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by loewenskind on Monday July 05, 2010 @04:18AM (#1487675)
>If nothing else, the simple fact that human intelligence follows a bell-curve

I challenge the idea that this is a "simple fact", rather that it's even true at all. How do you know? Right now it may appear so because so many schools grade on a bell curve (i.e. no other outcome is possible). In my experience, aside from people with genuine disorders, everyone has a similar (high) potential. The majority are just not properly stimulated. Maybe they have bad teachers, bad parents or are just lazy but if they were properly motivated they could achieve much more than they do.

Personally I find ideas like "the simple fact that human intelligence follows a bell-curve" dangerous. You're framing the potential of a whole species and people tend to assume this is true and act accordingly (e.g. grading on a bell curve).

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by CamperBob on Friday July 02, 2010 @09:33PM (#1482952)
You're actually very wrong about foreign STEM students

Am I?

(every US graduate school is filled with Chinese grad students and post-docs), but that's neither here nor there

What happens immediately after they graduate?

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by timr on Monday July 05, 2010 @05:06PM (#1489105)
"Am I?"

Yes.

"What happens immediately after they graduate?"

It depends greatly on where they're from, and what they've been studying. A lot of my Chinese colleagues have gone back to China...because there are jobs there, and not here.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by CamperBob on Monday July 05, 2010 @09:27PM (#1489673)
A lot of my Chinese colleagues have gone back to China...because there are jobs there, and not here.

Which I think you'll find was my exact point. We may still be the world's standard in STEM education, but we aren't necessarily benefiting from that position.

The world's best students come here to study, but not to live.

Re:Andy Grove: How To Make An American Job Before It's Too Late by timr on Tuesday July 06, 2010 @12:26AM (#1489958)
"we're no longer a place where the world's STEM students come to study and live"

That's the quote from your original comment -- the one to which I was replying. So, while you may have meant to say something else, I don't see that in the text. If anything, now you seem to be contradicting your earlier remark.

Also, re-reading the original comment, I get the impression that you're arguing that we're falling behind in science and tech because of a cultural failure -- a lack of societal focus on science and technology. I don't think that's true for a variety of reasons, but the big one is the same argument raised by the article: we've out-sourced generations of technical expertise. There's little incentive for the foreign grad student to stay here, when the jobs are over there. The jobs are there because we sent them there, not because we've stopped educating American students.