News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android Is a Dead End by Animats on Sunday July 16, 2017 @08:54PM (#14784959)
Extend, engulf, devour.

Most of the comments here miss the point of the article. The article author is saying that Google will replace the Linux component of Android with something proprietary. Then Google will have total control, and will be able to prevent Android clones.

Already, Android apps make such heavy use of Google proprietary code that open source Android systems such as Cyanogen and FDroid have mostly given up.

Re:Android Is a Dead End by nextInt on Sunday July 16, 2017 @09:07PM (#14785002)
Except that the only evidence provided is Fuschia which is open source
Re:Android Is a Dead End by on_and_off on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:10AM (#14810791)
Also, how does google prevent Samsung & co from taking over the AOSP codebase ?

Sure they could add rules to the "Google Play agreement for Fuchsia" but they are already in hot water because of the current Play Store contracts.

Re:Android Is a Dead End by dingo_bat on Sunday July 16, 2017 @09:20PM (#14785039)
I don't think Google will do that anytime soon. Because they don't know how to make and sell a phone for profit. The only player that can do that is Samsung, and Google cannot cut them off. I bet Samsung would sell more tizen phones than Google would sell fuschia phones, if Google were to lock Android up.
Re:Android Is a Dead End by anon4728 on Sunday July 16, 2017 @10:02PM (#14785166)
Google lacks fundamental business and product management skills.

Creating an "open platform" encourages device makers to polish it only for their needs but not upstream features and fixes to competitors (OS fragmentation) and let multiple, insecure versions run forever that rarely get updated (legacy fragmentation). Plus, Linux security is usually an oxymoron which Fuchsia may address. If Google wants their platform to survive, they're going to have to require approval for apps and devices, and stipulate things like UX usability and mandatory OS patches.

PS: There are thousands of servers run by handset manufacturers and telcos that are required for some features of mobile devices to work at all. For example, Motorola Mobility smartphones' depended on their own servers for many social media features to work. These backend-heavy designs are supremely easy to brick, disconnect and invade privacy of users, en masse, for profit and for government spying.

Re:Android Is a Dead End by hota_mazi on Sunday July 16, 2017 @10:18PM (#14785225)
> The article author is saying that Google will replace the Linux component of Android with something proprietary. Then Google will have total control, and will be able to prevent Android clones.

Sounds like a great conspiracy theory. Looking forward to the evidence to back up this link bait article.