News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by bad_user on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @11:15AM (#14753234)
> But wasn't the feature of making yourself a "brand page" and/or having "subscribers" (which don't count toward the 5,000 friend limit) supposed to mitigate this a bit?

If you have a page, Facebook wants to milk you, so they've got this weird algorithm that pushes your posts to only a small fraction of the page's followers, expecting you to start "promoting" them.

Basically they screwed "organic reach".

Oh, and about 3 days ago I created a second Facebook account with the purpose of connecting with software developers and my English-speaking friends (I'm Romanian). I did this thinking that I don't want to share semi-private pictures of family with strangers, or to spam my family and friends with programming stuff.

But only 24 hours later they've disabled my account because of "security concerns", without notice and now I'm waiting on their support to reply after I've sent them my picture for validation.

And another thing - the online parents group from my son's school is on WhatsApp. They tried a Facebook group, but the problem is that when important announcements happen, not all parents receive notifications, so they resorted to something that works.

Facebook is freaking terrible.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by sangnoir on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:31PM (#14753933)
> But only 24 hours later they've disabled my account because of "security concerns", without notice and now I'm waiting on their support to reply after I've sent them my picture for validation.

I'm not a Facebook's biggest fan, but I think this is a valid security concern (I'm assuming you used the same name as your initial account). Cloning FB accounts and impersonation is a valid threat vector for getting inside someone's network: when accepting friend-requests, most people don't double check if they are already friends with the purported requester.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by kuschku on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @05:58PM (#14757046)
I’ve got over a dozen Facebook accounts with the same name, and people frequently message the wrong one, but Facebook never tried closing any of them.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by ProblemFactory on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:10PM (#14753724)
> If you have a page, Facebook wants to milk you, so they've got this weird algorithm that pushes your posts to only a small fraction of the page's followers, expecting you to start "promoting" them.

While this does enable Facebook to force brands to buy advertising, it is also an user-friendly change.

Nobody who I have spoken to about this thinks that "like/follow" = "I want to see everything they post" on Facebook. People like restaurants they had a nice dinner at and want to publish their support, it doesn't mean they want to see the daily special every day. Even if they "follow" you, it doesn't mean it should show up before a friend's holiday pictures today, and tomorrow there is already new content.

The reality is that most facebook users do not care about the posts from pages they like/follow, even if they pressed the button some time ago. An automated filter that keeps these posts from showing up is good for the user experience.

It's the same as "facebook friends" - they aren't real friends, just people you met once at a party in college. It might be interesting to see a post from them once in 10 years when they get married or move to a new country, but not their daily life. The same applies for brand pages - a like should give you once in 10 years access to their feed, but not more.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by specialist on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:45PM (#14754068)
I wasn't aware that facebook does partial publishing/pushing from Pages.

I'm co-admin for an org's official Page (and Group). Our bylaws require advance announcement of various things, like meetings and resolutions. We've been using our official Page just like our mail listserv, assuming all our subscribers are getting all of our announcements.

Frankly, this sucks. Minimally, it violates the UX design principle of least astonishment.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by ValentineC on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @01:08PM (#14754298)
> We've been using our official Page just like our mail listserv, assuming all our subscribers are getting all of our announcements.

They will get it if they access your page directly, or subscribe to notifications from your page. It's the same with a personal profile, I believe — not everyone will receive your posts on their news feed unless you've interacted with them a fair bit.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by radarsat1 on Thursday July 13, 2017 @09:03AM (#14760877)
I would be pretty annoyed if I was part of an organization that required me to be keeping up to date on Facebook posts, that used it as the only way to know what's going on. You should definitely have a mailing list people can sign up to. Facebook is not really an appropriate medium for that kind of thing.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by pjc50 on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @04:32PM (#14756381)
I'm afraid you need to use email for that, unless people have starred your page they will not be getting all your announcements.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by guelo on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:28PM (#14753905)
I know better than The Algorithm whether I want to see every post or not. But I'm not allowed to decide that because The Algorithm isn't there to serve me it's there to serve Facebook.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by traek on Thursday July 13, 2017 @02:40PM (#14763947)
You can decide that whenever you want, just change your follow settings for the page to 'See First' from 'Following'.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by watwut on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:59PM (#14754222)
I followed specifically to be informed of events. It was quite infuriating when they changed algorithm and I missed them. If I get notices from pages/groups I dont care about anymore, I either unfollow or mute the next time their post annoys me.

Quite a few friends were following pages for the same reason.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by ProblemFactory on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @02:10PM (#14754987)
> If I get notices from pages/groups I dont care about anymore, I either unfollow or mute the next time their post annoys me.

I do that as well, but I think it's extremely rare among Facebook users. Everyone else I know either:

* Puts up grudgingly with "spam" they no longer want to see, or eventually

* Complains "Facebook is full of crap these days, I'm deleting my account".

A filter algorithm is a much better experience than manual unsubscribe for most users. With how easy it is to "like" anything you see on Facebook and the rest of the web, it is almost necessary to assume that subscriptions should "expire" unless the user keeps actively interacting with the page.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by lanstin on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @03:08PM (#14755589)
What I want to read is stuff my friends have taken the trouble to type in, all of it whatever the topic. I don't want to read whatever random crap on the web they are reading or what ever. Original user generated content made Facebook and the inability to find my friends' generated content is what makes it not worth reading. I have about 1B ways to get hot memes and trending internet topics. I have relatively few ways to see how all the people in the various corners of my life are doing.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by freehunter on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @08:11PM (#14757770)
A few years ago I had to manually add a few specific people to my "close friends" list because Facebook decided to stop showing me their posts completely. One of the people was the best man at my wedding, another was my wife. You know, just the two people I care about most in the world. Just completely stopped showing me their posts, but I would see a ton of stuff from my wife's cousin that I'd never liked or commented on. So now I get a notification every time they post something so I can have a chance to see it.

I like Facebook's utility but man their algorithm sucks.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by watwut on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @04:52PM (#14756563)
Pretty much this. I see what a couple of people liked on facebook constantly,but I do not see things people I care about wrote nor get information about events I follow groups for.

Current version od algorithm is not working.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by krisdol on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:47PM (#14754089)
Well "like" and "follow" should be different things. I follow users on instagram/strava because I want to see what they do. I like the content they post when... well, when it pleases me, or I want it to get some more attention. I deleted my facebook account after nearly 10 years with the service, but I hated the decision they made to show content from pages you've liked (often inadvertently when you meant to like a post rather than the page). I fought against facebook for the last few months as I kept "unliking" every page/profile I had ever liked, but it was hard to keep that clean.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by rogov on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @04:15PM (#14756240)
They have changed this recently with respect to pages, so you can follow a page without liking it and vice-versa. However, the default still seems to be that like = follow. It takes additional action to decouple them.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by rhizome on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @01:58PM (#14754853)
I did this thinking that I don't want to share semi-private pictures of family with strangers, or to spam my family and friends with programming stuff.

Do you know there are friend groups you can use to eliminate that problem? "Family and school," "Programmery Peeps," if you post using either of those groups for visibility then it seems like the issue is moot.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by bluGill on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @02:10PM (#14754982)
Most people don't use them. It is too hard (10 extra seconds is too hard). Facebook is good at figuring out from the pattern of likes who else will be interested in seeing something. It is only when you have an important announcement that they screw up.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by rhizome on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @05:07PM (#14756688)
That's the thing: other people don't have to use them, but if you do, then you can segregate your posts the same way you would with an alt account.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by anigbrowl on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @02:04PM (#14754915)
Ah, that explains a lot. I know very little about social media marketing and wondered why my attempts to launch a few pages related to art projects were drawing such little attention from my social circle. Being me I assumed it was because my art is shit and largely abandoned a project I'd spent months developing. Zucked again.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by baq on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:14PM (#14753753)
...and it causes the political echo chamber problem which results in extreme polarization of whole societies based on fake perception of what the other side is doing vs what they're actually doing. terrible indeed but generates views thus revenue.
Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by anigbrowl on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @02:13PM (#14755011)
I find this thesis questionable. I'm a very political person and do a good bit of politicking on FB, including my group membership selections. I don't find this echo chamber effect at all, not least because there is a lot of inter-group antagonism (people who stage raids on other groups and so forth). I certainly don't get all my political ideas/news/anything from FB, but it seems more diverse than it is usually characterized as.

Does it make things more polarized, I would say yes. But that is a general thing with the internet and has been true since the creation of usenet; the Internet accelerates everything including political trends. I find the best way to guard against technology's impact on cognition is to maintain time for reading things on paper, and also time free of media consumption.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by zlynx on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:35PM (#14753975)
Only if you mostly have friends of one political kind, I think. I know that I get plenty of "fake news" links shared from all sides in my Facebook feed.

Usually the article contents themselves are fine and quite reasonable, but the Facebook shares have some completely false click-bait headline attached.

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by tehwebguy on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @12:15PM (#14753768)
> If you have a page, Facebook wants to milk you, so they've got this weird algorithm that pushes your posts to only a small fraction of the page's followers, expecting you to start "promoting" them.

> Basically they screwed "organic reach".

Average user follows way too many pages and has too many friends all posting to see all content every day.

Algorithm isn't here to milk you, it's to stop the news feed from becoming the MySpace bulletin feed (which was an effective way to post in 2007, so long as you posted 5x every hour)

Re:The Facebook Algorithm Mom Problem by Broken_Hippo on Thursday July 13, 2017 @05:42AM (#14759961)
I'd love to believe you. And you are likely right, the algorithm itself isn't there to milk anyone - but facebook surely acts like they want to, and they'll use that algorithm to do so if needed.

I have a page for artwork. Most of the time, facebook will tell me how much better the current post is doing than so many other posts on the page (even if it doesn't seem likely). It reminds me to post after 2-3 days, because my few fans will miss me. I do art and can't actually get things done that quickly, after all. Every post has multiple prompts to boost the post, noting how others with simiilar content have boosted posts. Sometimes it tells me how many hundreds of local people will see it. Sometimes it'll be a general prompt. These even show up as notifacations, sometimes on both my personal and my artist page. Additionally, I get ads for post or page boosts in my normal feed.

The algorithm is just a part of the milking.