Re:Great design: The airplane bathroom lock and light switch
by easyfrag on Thursday March 27, 2008 @07:48AM
(#147694)
You're introducing unnecessary complexity into the system; instead of the lock, light, and wiring between the two we would have lock, light, motion detector, and wiring between all three. It may be trivial, but ensuring fewer failure points is good design, especially at 30 000 feet.
Re:Great design: The airplane bathroom lock and light switch
by anupamkapoor on Thursday March 27, 2008 @01:28AM
(#147588)
i for one _really_ like the lightning conductors built such that the radars on the plane don't get fried during a lightning strike.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ram_air_turbine
and if I had to choose between the bathroom lock and this set of technologies,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_protection_system
...well, I just don't know. But no one adores the trivial like 37signals. Of course, you say, "They are focusing on user-centric design." Well...in that case, the door-light combination doesn't seem as good as a motion-detector-door-light combination, which would turn ON with motion, stay on when LOCKED, and turn off when UNLOCKED. That didn't take an engineering degree to come up with. Where's my kudos?