Even if it seems obvious, how are you going to prove that they didn't actually download the font or have the special Windows edition?
Although it might turn public perception, it shouldn't, I believe, be considered judicially.
Of course, I do not know the standard in use in this country's court system.
Among American (and British, Canadian etc) lawyers who advocate quantifying the concept of "reasonable doubt,"[1] the consensus figure seems to be that proof beyond a reasonable doubt means greater than 95% certainty (or, stated negatively, a less than 5% level of uncertainty). Judge Weinstein of the Eastern District of New York[2] puts the 95% number in his jury instructions, for example.
If we assume the Bayesian prior that it's at least 19x more likely that Pakistani politicians at the highest level of influence are secretly corrupt and/or evading taxes, than it is that they're secretly tech nerds who eagerly download the latest Microsoft betas and try out all the new fonts, then we have met that 95% standard. If the accused were a Microsoft executive instead of an official of one of the world's most corrupt states,[3] the equation would be different.
Of course, there might be other arguments for doubt besides "the font was available in obscure beta software." One potential argument is that it's a newer version of an older document that was typeset in a different font, which was changed to Calibri at some later point (recent MS Words might default to displaying the document in Calibri if it were sent to a computer that didn't have the original font installed, or the file type doesn't include font information in a way Word supports, or it was copied and pasted from the clipboard).
[1] Which IMO it should be; most of the clear miscarriages of justice in either direction that I know of seem like they could have been prevented or at least been mistrials if, as much as possible, we'd nudged the jury to carefully quantify the strength of both sides' evidence instead of voting emotionally.
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_B._Weinstein
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_Perceptions_Index
This is not the U.S., though, and I ain't a lawyer anyway.
It's not unusual to have trials where there's no unassailable smoking gun but rather a number of facts that strain credulity to explain away.
It looks like we may only have seen scanned copies of the documents, so any Office metadata would be missing.
I wonder if there is any other subtle metadata. Perhaps default tab stops or borders?
If you see what I mean...
And I'm not really commenting on the current case (not familiar with it at all)... just positing a possible way to prove a document's date as inaccurate.
It'd be hilarious if they said "Here's my 2006 tax report, but you need Office 2013 to open it."
From what I remember, the EU wanted to standardize an open document format, and had their eye set on OO ODF, as the most mature of those at the time. Microsoft put out their OXML format, gave out free patent grants, lobbied hard, and managed to get it into ISO.
If you want some nightmares though, open an office XML file in a text editor some day.
They came with Office 2007. For Office 2003, there was a plugin that allowed to open the XML files, in a limited way.
I wrote that and on a whim thought, "I'll make this a pip package," severely underestimating that task. The tool works but I never finished that packaging. The working source should be on github if you're interested.
It is really quite distinct from the memory dump of pre-xml doc/excel files.
I woulda cobbled something together to suck the text out of them.
The real problem was using word as our documentation format, but at Microsoft in the early oughts there really weren't many alternatives.
The cobble-together part, to be successful, would pull the text out reliably. And the format is readily documented, and Open/Libre office processes it as well. The code to do the extract might be ugly, but so long as it reliably produced the text in a CI/CD environment, that would be OK.
> Microsoft's website states that version 1.0 of the font was available to download separately as far back as 2005. And, according to font consultant Thomas Phinney, Calibri was also available as part of a Windows pre-release in 2004.
Back then many people were using beta-versions of Windows 2003 Server (or other server products) . Server edition was great desktop (compared to XP and Vista), but also very expensive. Prerelease version had 90 days trial period, which could be easily reset.
MS Office format is basically a memory dump. So forged documents should leave much more evidence with timestamps, office patches versions, error handling etc...