And... every society is an immensely complex machine, and probably can't be boiled down to an ideology (something Marx never understood, hence his inability to actually propose an alternative besides a utopian vision, and his inability to be a very effective political actor.)
While I think countries shouldn't be run by strict adherence to the rules of an -ism, people who subscribe to an -ism are useful because they help frame and suggest solutions to the bugs in the current organization of society. The problem with the -ism folks is that they are hard to disprove because society will never reflect a pure enough implementation of their ideas. Where things get dicey is when politicians buy too strongly into a particular -ism and aren't able to employ other tools when necessary.
Why not radical changes?
Where things get dicey is when politicians buy too strongly into a particular -ism and aren't able to employ other tools when necessary.
How do we know what kind of idealism that politicians are employing? Why not think that they're just a bunch of self-interested politicians who wants the vote?
How do you know which tools are suited to which problems? How do you know if they're suited to any problems at all?
I think the motivation for radical changes is based on the idea that we are stuck in a "local maxima" (of some "goodness of society" function) that gradual change can only optimize to some limited degree and that large change is required to put us on a different part of the curve that can be maximized to a greater degree.
But I've never seen a proposed (or implemented) radical reorganization that I believed would put us on a path some global maxima (or better local maxima). Taken a step further, I don't believe that we are stuck in a local maxima and think we can make significant positive change using gradual reform.
You assume that -isms are inherently wrong. Why?
This isn't a very specific argument, but it's hard to argue against -isms as a general idea.
Also, the police force not a socialist institution. To sustain a free market requires the state-sanctioned protection of life and property. The police force is a very 'capitalist' institution.
And, as long as we are trading isolated examples to prove general theories, what country is on the capitalist side of the spectrum and doing notably well? For bonus points, find me a nation that bet the farm on innovative securities and is doing especially well.
Don't get me wrong, I love markets and entrepeneurship (sp?); I just tend toward the Rockefeller Republican / Conservative Democrat zone, in which we believe that (1) the important thing is the details of governance (tax policy details, not debates about whether taxes are good) and (2) that "society" is more fundamental than "the market."
My point was not to prove a general theory by isolated example - simply to provide a counterpoint.
I think it's more fruitful to compare the economic/moral philosophies of these systems than to compare examples of them. Primarily because no isolated example is a paragon of its stated parent philosophy and (more practically) because a Marxist country doesn't exist and a capitalist country doesn't exist to compare.
And I'm genuinely curious how you separate tax policy debate from whether taxes are good. I don't think any socioeconomic system says all taxes are bad, but they do differ on what it is moral to tax for.
The Wild West huh? Well, we know how that turns out: professional pistoleros rob at will, and honest citizens flee to towns that have a police force. Back to square one.
These same libertarians would use examples of the wild west as "not so wild west". Their historical interpretation is a bit different than yours.
Seriously? Are you are claiming that socialism has very little or no need for police?
This whole statement seems a little... shoddy.
Similarly, in a socialist nation, people eat hamburgers. This does not imply that hamburgers eat people in a capitalist nation.