Any economic system fails when practiced by corrupt or incompetent governments. There are many failed capitalist states, too.
Edit: if you want to talk about scaling, China and India are debatably doing well (or at least improving rapidly), and both countries have 1.3B people.
China had an interesting idea with special economic zones: let people opt out of socialism if they want to, but stay within the country and get basic protections.
In many ways China is closer to pure capitalism than most countries on the planet. The vestiges of "socialism" primarily live on in their authoritarian government, restrictive social policies, financial repression and massive state-owned-enterprises. China is slowly moving away from the latter two as their massive problems are uncovered.
> authoritarian government, restrictive social policies, financial repression and massive state-owned-enterprises
None of these are key tenets of socialism as the article formulates it.
As I've said elsewhere, historical socialism is not the socialism anyone is advocating. No one is suggesting Stalinism.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_liberalisation_in_Ind...
No one is proposing anything remotely similar to Stalinism/USSR-esque or Nazi socialism. When people bring those things up, it's a straw man.
America did it twice: native genocide and African slavery.
One thing I'm curious about...Trump says Let's make America Great again--was he talking before white people came and before the genocide? Or after? Was he talking about Slavery? Or the lynch mobs of the KKK? What about criminal enterprises and suffering during Prohibition and the Great Depression?
Damn, I long for the an FDR style leader to come along, well at this point we need quite a few to fill congress and start making America about the people again, not corporate interests.
> Meanwhile one of the United State's biggest problem is obesity due to being so prosperous. This blows my mind. You think that obesity is due to prosperity, when all those poor people who cannot afford decent food and physical exercise are the ones who are getting obese.
Please, consider refraining from posting before trying to understand correlations and connections between multiple factors from which you draw such strong (and very misleading) conclusions.
The goal becomes to leave the power in a democratized space, as socialism dictates. When labor members own their fair shares of the companies that are interacting on the market, they will make decisions socially and profit proportionally. Exploitation in its current form will be greatly reduced. Naturally any economic system bears its own unique issues to contend with, but these can be addressed in time for what seems at this point to be a net improvement in inequality.
2. We're on HN so we all now about scaling. There's a big difference between 5 million and 300+ million citizens.
3. The US subsidizes those countries in terms of defense and innovation in health care. Pharma makes their profits off us while they have price controls in those other countries.
Social Democracy -- is capitalism with some programs added in, heck Police, Fire, and Roads maintained by the state are SOCIAL DEMOCRACY programs -- maybe you should have to pay if you want the fire truck to come put out your fire, call 911 what's your emergency? And can I have your credit card?
Dictionary definition: a political and economic theory of social organization that advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole
Under social democracy you can still start companies, still own businesses, nobody's taking that away, we just want to make sure that those who earn the most off the backs of the people's work contribute to lift up those who are burdened the most at the bottom.
In this US any talk about redistributing wealth will have your policy (and you) branded as a socialist.
Unfortunately people has short memory. In the last elections here in Spain more people than ever voted far-left parties, including supporters of terrorist groups. Just the coalition between communists (Unidos Podemos) received more than 5 million votes.
Even convicted terrorists from ETA, and Terra Lliure won their seats.
Sadly, far-left and far-right populism is going up in Europe.
In my mind they are fairly easy to confuse.
People on Medicaid claim to value the services at only 1/5 of their cost. If you taking that estimate at face value, if you shut down medicaid entirely and just paid each former recipient 20% of the price you'd been paying to provide health insurance, they would be better off. You can debate those numbers and methodology, but it's very suggestive, and very real.
http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/07/med...
This is more equitable.
Taxation is necessary to live in a stable society. The question is, how much to take and how to spend it.
We've seen how our current path works out. The rich accumulate more and more wealth and with it more political power until such time that the masses are sufficiently poor and disenfranchised that they engage in a bloody revolt.
Blows my mind people can even be calling for socialism while we have a real time implosion going on in Venezuela right now. It's ending like every other socialist regime in history, cannibalism, famine, riots, and murder. Meanwhile one of the United State's biggest problem is obesity due to being so prosperous.
Actually I'm not surprised, just look up Yuri Bezmenov's talk on ideological subversion he foretold everything 30+ years ago