Would you rather have bought stock in Tesla, Nissan or Toyota ten years ago?
Leafs and Priuses are only part of Nissan and Toyota, their stock obviously cannot fully reflect the success of those vehicles. And Tesla's stock is notoriously overvalued.
Similarly, I'd rather have a McLaren than Tesla (or Toyota), but that doesn't speak anything about the talents of either firm at mass producing cars.
> Tesla certainly did a lot better than other attempts at electric cars
You have decided that that claim hinges on their ability to mass produce cars.
I think Tesla has done more for the electric car market than any of the other companies. I can't justify that with data, but I think it's a reasonable position. We have different points. I'm not missing yours.
What's really tough is turning a Bluetooth speaker business or a smart-watch business into a multi-billion dollar business. It's the over-investment and sunk-cost problem that ruined Jawbone, not the hardware nature.